refinery. It did not replace valves suffering similar problems that OSHA inspectors did not identify. Was such a decision legal? Was such a decision ethical?

$5-30.$ What would you have done if you were the manager of the Toledo refinery?

$5-31.$ Suppose you $($the manager of the Toledo refinery$)$ had just received a memo from corporate headquarters that your plant operating costs were over budget. Would that affect your answer?

$5-32.$ Should BP put safety first or profits first?

$5-33.$ Some critics have argued that BP$\text{'}$s commitment to safety was inadequate, despite the company's statements to the contrary. Suppose that critics were correct. If you were the new CEO of BP and were genuinely committed to improving safety, what steps would you take to do improve BP$\text{'}$s safety culture?

$5-29.$ BP replaced the deficient pressure$-$relief valves identified by OSHA during a $2006$ inspection of its Toledo