Should Dr. Ashwen accept Bernard's offer? Does it make any difference if her waiting room is...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Should Dr. Ashwen accept Bernard's offer? Does it make any difference if her waiting room is empty or full? (2 points) Dr. Ashwen is charging Mr. Crandall different rates per hour for AET and NERT, two procedures tha have the same operating cost per hour. Is it fair, just honorable, honest, ethical, legal, or at all appropriate to charge different prices to patients suffering from different ailments when the operating cost of treating the different ailments is the same (which appears to be true in the current case)? This question might be more easily answer by considering a more familiar hypothetical example: would it be fair to charge a patient suffering from cancer more than a patient suffering from indigestion if the operating costs of the treatments provided to both patients were the same? (Note: operating costs refer to those costs required to currently run and operate the clinic.) (2 points) Bernard Crandall's Proposal to Dr. Ashwen Although Bernard was quite happy with the treatments that he had received from Dr. Ashwen using NERT, he was concerned about the cost. So, before his next visit, he researched the market price for NERT. One of the alternative medicine practitioners Bernard had visited in the past was Dr. Greco, who practice was a twelve-hour drive away in another state (Bernard had recently moved). Dr. Greco had a national and international reputation as an alternative medicine provider because he traveled 20 weekends per year teaching seminars, at least one of which Dr. Ashwen herself attended. So, Dr. Greco was very reputable, and he treated patients using NERT, charging only $10 per treatment. While sitting in Dr. Ashwen's treatment room, he told her that he wishes to receive NERT but that he is only willing to pay $12.50 per treatment for a total of $100 for eight treatments. Place yourself in Dr. Ashwen's position. How should she respond to Bernard's request? What costs are relevant for Dr. Ashwen's decision about whether to accept or reject Bernard's proposal? Alternative medicaine providers were not so rare that Dr. Ashwen did not have competition. While Bernard was unaware of any other skilled providers for either treatment, Dr. Ashwen was aware that other skilled providers for both treatments were available, both with lower prices and a shorter drive from Bernard's home. TABLE 1 Summary of Dr. Ashwen's Costs One-Time Costs (Paid in Full) Purchased treatment table Purchased other miscellaneous equipment Fees and travel incurred for training in AET Fees and travel incurred for training in NERT Recurring (Monthly) Expenses House payment (monthly rent) Misc. house-related fees (utilities, etc.) (average) (monthly) Student loan payment (monthly) (30-year loan, 8% interest) All other living expenses (average) (monthly) Part-time secretary (monthly) TABLE 2 Summary of Dr. Ashwen's Revenues Chiropractic revenue (average) [Time per treatment = 10 minutes] AET revenue [Time for two treatments = 15 minutes] NERT revenue [Time for eight treatments = 15 minutes] Percent of revenue from chiropractic treatments Percent of AETS Percent of revenue from NERTS $12,195 5,700 6,100 7,250 $1,450 210 844 2,220 550 $75 per treatment $50 per treatment $50 per treatment 75% 15% 10% Should Dr. Ashwen accept Bernard's offer? Does it make any difference if her waiting room is empty or full? (2 points) Dr. Ashwen is charging Mr. Crandall different rates per hour for AET and NERT, two procedures tha have the same operating cost per hour. Is it fair, just honorable, honest, ethical, legal, or at all appropriate to charge different prices to patients suffering from different ailments when the operating cost of treating the different ailments is the same (which appears to be true in the current case)? This question might be more easily answer by considering a more familiar hypothetical example: would it be fair to charge a patient suffering from cancer more than a patient suffering from indigestion if the operating costs of the treatments provided to both patients were the same? (Note: operating costs refer to those costs required to currently run and operate the clinic.) (2 points) Bernard Crandall's Proposal to Dr. Ashwen Although Bernard was quite happy with the treatments that he had received from Dr. Ashwen using NERT, he was concerned about the cost. So, before his next visit, he researched the market price for NERT. One of the alternative medicine practitioners Bernard had visited in the past was Dr. Greco, who practice was a twelve-hour drive away in another state (Bernard had recently moved). Dr. Greco had a national and international reputation as an alternative medicine provider because he traveled 20 weekends per year teaching seminars, at least one of which Dr. Ashwen herself attended. So, Dr. Greco was very reputable, and he treated patients using NERT, charging only $10 per treatment. While sitting in Dr. Ashwen's treatment room, he told her that he wishes to receive NERT but that he is only willing to pay $12.50 per treatment for a total of $100 for eight treatments. Place yourself in Dr. Ashwen's position. How should she respond to Bernard's request? What costs are relevant for Dr. Ashwen's decision about whether to accept or reject Bernard's proposal? Alternative medicaine providers were not so rare that Dr. Ashwen did not have competition. While Bernard was unaware of any other skilled providers for either treatment, Dr. Ashwen was aware that other skilled providers for both treatments were available, both with lower prices and a shorter drive from Bernard's home. TABLE 1 Summary of Dr. Ashwen's Costs One-Time Costs (Paid in Full) Purchased treatment table Purchased other miscellaneous equipment Fees and travel incurred for training in AET Fees and travel incurred for training in NERT Recurring (Monthly) Expenses House payment (monthly rent) Misc. house-related fees (utilities, etc.) (average) (monthly) Student loan payment (monthly) (30-year loan, 8% interest) All other living expenses (average) (monthly) Part-time secretary (monthly) TABLE 2 Summary of Dr. Ashwen's Revenues Chiropractic revenue (average) [Time per treatment = 10 minutes] AET revenue [Time for two treatments = 15 minutes] NERT revenue [Time for eight treatments = 15 minutes] Percent of revenue from chiropractic treatments Percent of AETS Percent of revenue from NERTS $12,195 5,700 6,100 7,250 $1,450 210 844 2,220 550 $75 per treatment $50 per treatment $50 per treatment 75% 15% 10%
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Should Dr Ashwen accept Bernards offer Does it make any difference if her waiting room is empty or full 2 points No Dr Ashwen should not accept Bernards offer It does not make a difference if her wait... View the full answer
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these economics questions
-
According to the absorption approach, does it make any difference whether a nation's currency depreciates when the economy is operating at less than full capacity versus at full capacity?
-
Does it make any sense for both of a flip-flop's input wires to carry current at the same time? What would happen within the circuit if this were to happen?
-
What is a professional financial planner? Does it make any difference whether the financial planner earns money from commissions made on products sold as opposed to the fees he or she charges?
-
Find all conjugates in C of the given number over the given field. 1+2 over Q
-
In a survey of 1000 women age 22 to 35 who work full time, 540 indicated that they would be willing to give up some personal time in order to make more money (USA Today, March 4, 2010). The sample...
-
Explain each of the three other approaches to common stock valuation: (a) Book value, (b) Liquidation value, and (c) Price/earnings (P/E) multiples. Which of these is considered the best?
-
The magnitude of the magnetic field in a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) machine can be as great as \(B=3.0 \mathrm{~T}\). Under normal circumstances, this field cannot be shut off by just flipping...
-
Zhou Bicycle Company ( ZBC), located in Seattle, is a wholesale distributor of bicycles and bicycle parts. Formed in 1981 by University of Washington Professor Yong- Pin Zhou, the firms primary...
-
29. If A 21+j+k and B=1+2j+2k, find the magnitude of component of (A+B) along B: (1) 4 unit (2) 5 unit (3) 6 unit (4) 7 unit 30. Which of the following group of forces cannot produce the resultant of...
-
Using exponential smoothing with trend, a smoothing constant of 4, if the forecast for January had been 110, compute what the exponential forecast would have been for the month of April using January...
-
A cyclohexane-air misture (0.01 mole fraction cyclohexane) is scrubbed with an oil (mole fraction cyclohexane of 0.003) at 30C in a packed tower. The gas entering flow rate is 0.1713 m 3 /sec. Liquid...
-
A city is required to report to the state the mean property tax of its citizens. From previous years, officials know that the population standard deviation is likely to be $975. A 99 % confidence...
-
Suppose the quality control expert of question 30 knows from past experience that the number of defective light bulbs in a case of 10,000 has a population standard deviation of 221. She would like to...
-
Myers-Briggs Personality Types and Jungian Personality Types are two very popular descriptions of the material in this chapter. Using your search engine, access the Internet sites that refer to these...
-
Suppose you want to estimate a population proportion p. The total population consists of 1,000, your population consists of 100, and the sample proportion is .42. Find a 95 % confidence interval for...
-
A quality control engineer at the Brite Lite Light Bulb Company wants to test for the number of defective light bulbs in a case of 1,200. From past experience, he knows that the population standard...
-
What is the primary motive behind cyberterrorism? F O A To cause fear and harm in the real world To promote ethical hacking and network security To engage in recreational activities online To...
-
Suppose that a business sells 6-month subscriptions to its monthly magazine. On January 1, the company receives a total of $600 for 10 subscriptions. To record this transaction, the company debits...
-
Crane l uses 10 kJ of energy to lift a 50 kg box to the roof of a building. Crane 2 uses 20 kl to lift a 100 kg box the same distance. Which crane is more efficient? A. Crane 1 B. Crane 2 C. Both...
-
Christina throws a javelin into the air. As she propels it forward from rest, she does 270 J of work on it. At its highest point, its gravitational potential energy has increased by 70 J. What is the...
-
A runner is moving at a constant speed on level ground. Chemical energy in the runner's body is being transformed into other forms of energy. Most of the chemical energy is transformed into A....
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App