1. Take a stance on what is more important - ethics or shareholder value and then answer the questions below:
   • Be sure to cite at least (1) outside resource that supports your answer.
   • Identify at least one example where AT&T has failed their ethical or CSR commitment and evaluate the role either profitability or strategy played.
   • How does the existence, or lack thereof, a CSR policy demonstrate, or not, the presence of ethical management?
   • What is the impact of ethics on the organizational strategy and profitability?
   • Explain your stance and the decision behind it.