Question: The dafny program below keeps outputting the error attached. This is the code: predicate zeros 1 ( s: seq ) { forall i , j

The dafny program below keeps outputting the error attached. This is the code:
predicate zeros1(s: seq)
{
forall i, j :: (0= i |s| && 0= j |s| && s[i]==0 && s[j]!=0)==> i j
}
predicate zeros2(s: seq)
{
forall i :: 0= i |s| && s[i]==0==>(forall j :: 0= j i ==> s[j]==0)
}
lemma ValidateEquivalence()
ensures forall s: seq :: zeros1(s)==> zeros2(s)
ensures forall s: seq :: zeros2(s)==> zeros1(s)
{
// Proof: Show zeros1==> zeros2
forall s | zeros1(s)
ensures zeros2(s)
{
// zeros1 implies that if s[i]==0 and s[j]!=0, then i j
// Therefore, all zeros are at the start as specified in zeros2.
forall i |0= i |s| && s[i]==0
ensures forall j :: 0= j i ==> s[j]==0
{
forall j |0= j i
ensures s[j]==0
{
assert s[j]==0; // Since j i and s[i]==0, s[j] cannot be non-zero
}
}
}
// Proof: Show zeros2==> zeros1
forall s | zeros2(s)
ensures zeros1(s)
{
// zeros2 implies that if s[i]==0, then all elements before i are also 0
// Thus, zeros1 condition (i j for s[i]==0 and s[j]!=0) holds.
forall i, j |0= i |s| && 0= j |s| && s[i]==0 && s[j]!=0
ensures i j
{
assert i j; // As all zeros are at the start, j must be after all zeros.
}
}
}
method ZeroSortSeq(s: seq) returns (t: seq)
ensures zeros1(t)
ensures multiset(t)== multiset(s)
{
t := s;
var nonz :=0;
var next :=0;
while next |t|
invariant 0= nonz = next =|t|
invariant forall i :: 0= i nonz ==> t[i]==0
invariant forall i :: nonz = i next ==> t[i]!=0
// COMMENT
invariant multiset(t)== multiset(s)
{
if t[next]==0{
// Move the zero to the beginning of the nonz section
t := t[0..nonz]+[t[next]]+ t[nonz..next]+ t[next +1..];
nonz := nonz +1;
}
next := next +1;
}
}
predicate ValidateZeroSort(s: seq, t: seq)
{
zeros2(t) && multiset(s)== multiset(t)
}
method Main()
{
// test cases
var s1 :=[2,0,1,5,3,0,4,0];
var t1 := ZeroSortSeq(s1);
assert ValidateZeroSort(s1, t1);
print "Test 1 passed: ", s1,"->", t1,"
";
var s2 :=[0,0,0];
var t2 := ZeroSortSeq(s2);
assert ValidateZeroSort(s2, t2);
print "Test 2 passed: ", s2,"->", t2,"
";
var s3 :=[1,2,3];
var t3 := ZeroSortSeq(s3);
assert ValidateZeroSort(s3, t3);
print "Test 3 passed: ", s3,"->", t3,"
";
var s4 :=[];
var t4 := ZeroSortSeq(s4);
assert ValidateZeroSort(s4, t4);
print "Test 4 passed: ", s4,"->", t4,"
";
}
The dafny program below keeps outputting the

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer
Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image
Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock
Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related Programming Questions!