The defendant, attempting to heal the plaintiff, left him blind in one eye. The plaintiff has...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
The defendant, attempting to heal the plaintiff, left him blind in one eye. The plaintiff has sued in trespass, a forerunner of today's tort action. The defendant made a procedural argument, claiming that the plaintiff should have brought an action of covenant. Issues: Did the plaintiff bring the wrong type of suit? Assuming the defendant's care was defective, could he be liable in any type of action? Holding: The court ignores the procedural point and reaches the merits. It holds that because the plaintiff voluntarily submitted himself to the defendant's care, the latter cannot be liable, even if his conduct caused the harm. The court distinguishes a deliberate attack, which would be actionable, from this accidental harm, where it finds no liability. More importantly, the court bases its judgment on a previous medical case involving accidental death. That case was dismissed, so this one should be as well: precedent begins to take hold. 1.Question: What is a procedural argument? 2. Question: Why did the defendant's attorney make a procedural argument? 3. Question: Is it good to allow procedural arguments? 4. Question: In a lawsuit today, would the plaintiff need to demonstrate that the defendant deliberately harmed him? The defendant, attempting to heal the plaintiff, left him blind in one eye. The plaintiff has sued in trespass, a forerunner of today's tort action. The defendant made a procedural argument, claiming that the plaintiff should have brought an action of covenant. Issues: Did the plaintiff bring the wrong type of suit? Assuming the defendant's care was defective, could he be liable in any type of action? Holding: The court ignores the procedural point and reaches the merits. It holds that because the plaintiff voluntarily submitted himself to the defendant's care, the latter cannot be liable, even if his conduct caused the harm. The court distinguishes a deliberate attack, which would be actionable, from this accidental harm, where it finds no liability. More importantly, the court bases its judgment on a previous medical case involving accidental death. That case was dismissed, so this one should be as well: precedent begins to take hold. 1.Question: What is a procedural argument? 2. Question: Why did the defendant's attorney make a procedural argument? 3. Question: Is it good to allow procedural arguments? 4. Question: In a lawsuit today, would the plaintiff need to demonstrate that the defendant deliberately harmed him?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answer Holding The court ignores the procedural point and reaches the merits It holds that because t... View the full answer
Related Book For
Smith and Roberson Business Law
ISBN: 978-0538473637
15th Edition
Authors: Richard A. Mann, Barry S. Roberts
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these business communication questions
-
Plaintiff Advance Industrial Coating, LLC brought a suit against defendant Westfield Insurance Company based on diversity jurisdiction. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant was an Ohio...
-
Should a landlord generally be liable for harm caused by a tenants dog? By a tenants dog off the premises?
-
Medical malpractice is one area where tort reform is argued most heavily. Some concerns are that caps on damages might result in costs that ultimately fall on the taxpayer; other concerns are the...
-
Why does Erasmus attack Church officials in his In Praise of Folly? O For spending money on lavish art O For not allowing clergy to marry O For supporting military campaigns O For selling pardons and...
-
1. Find the acceleration produced by a force of 6.75 x 106 N on a rocket of mass 5.27 x 105 kg. 2. An astronaut has a mass of 80.0 kg. His space suit has a mass of 15.5 kg. Find the acceleration of...
-
You purchase a bond with a coupon rate of 5.9 percent and a clean price of $984. If the next semiannual coupon payment is due in four months, what is the invoice price?
-
How to draft a statement of fact for complaints?
-
Find the present value of $500 due in the future under each of these conditions: a. 12% nominal rate, semiannual compounding, discounted back 5 years b. 12% nominal rate, quarterly compounding,...
-
Pantier Inc. is considering dropping one of its product lines, the BH4, due to losses experienced over the past quarter. To help with this decision, the company's cost accountant has gathered the...
-
Thompson Distributors packages and distributes industrial supplies. A standard shipment can be packaged in a class A container, a class K container, or a class T container. A single class A container...
-
Nittany Company uses a periodic inventory system. At the end of the annual accounting period, December 31 of the current year, the accounting records provided the following information for product 1:...
-
Discuss and elaborate about process Control Limits and process Specification Limits? Discuss also the three cases that compare specification limits to control limits.?
-
Aztec Company sells its product for $160 per unit. Its actual and budgeted sales follow. Sales units Sales dollars May (Actual) June (Budget) July (Budget) August (Budget) 2,400 $ 384,000 5,000 $...
-
EBay have a binary choice resist Elliott Management or conduct a strategic review that could lead to major portfolio change. What would be a right path forward for eBay?
-
What is the collection period calculation? ANNUAL BALANCE SHEET ($ Thousands) 31-Dec-15 31-Dec-16 ASSETS Cash & Short-Term Investments $17.11 $25.05 Net Receivables $1.62 $1.84 Inventories $42.72...
-
Reflectupon the challenges of managing and monitoring performance in an HRO. Your reflection should: Explain the unique elements of HROs and highlight some of the key areas managers should be aware...
-
Calculate the Internal Rate of Return on the sales plan!
-
Will the prediction interval always be wider than the estimation interval for the same value of the independent variable? Briefly explain.
-
The sole question presented in this case is which of several claimants is entitled to an award for information leading to the apprehension and conviction of certain bank robbers. * * * On June 12th...
-
Plaintiff, a seller of milk, had for ten years bid on contracts to supply milk to defendant school district and had supplied milk to other school districts in the area. On June 15, plaintiff...
-
In the sale of a house, must the seller disclose it was the site of a multiple murder? Dorris Reed purchased a house from Robert King. Neither King nor his real estate agents (the other named...
-
Describe the steps necessary to create a statement of cash flows.
-
Describe the statement of cash flow operating section created by Quick- Books Accountant.
-
Describe the steps necessary to make changes in the statement of cash flows report layout in order to properly reflect the adjustments needed to reconcile net income with cash provided by operations.
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App