The following discussion is found in the U.S. Bankruptcy Report on Lehman Bros. Holdings dated March...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
The following discussion is found in the U.S. Bankruptcy Report on Lehman Bros. Holdings dated March 22, 2010: Lehman employed off-balance sheet devices, known within Lehman as "Repo 105" and "Repo 108" transactions, to temporarily remove securities inventory from its bal- ance sheet, usually for a period of seven to ten days... in late 2007 and 2008. Repo 105 transactions were nearly identical to standard repurchase and resale ("repo") transac- tions that Lehman (and other investment banks) used to secure short-term financing, with a critical difference: Lehman accounted for Repo 105 transactions as "sales" as opposed to financing transactions ... By recharacterizing the Repo 105 transaction as a "sale," Lehman removed the inventory from its balance sheet. Lehman regularly increased its use of Repo 105 transactions in the days prior to re- porting periods to reduce its publicly reported net leverage and balance sheet. Lehman's periodic reports did not disclose the cash borrowing from the Repo 105 transaction...Lehman used the cash from the Repo 105 transaction to pay down other liabilities, thereby reducing both the total liabilities and the total assets reported on its balance sheet and lowering its leverage ratios.... A few days after the new quarter be- gan, Lehman would borrow the necessary funds to repay the cash borrowing plus in- terest, repurchase the securities, and restore the assets to its balance sheet. Lehman never publicly disclosed its use of Repo 105 transactions, its accounting treatment for these transactions, the considerable escalation of its total Repo 105 us- age in late 2007 and into 2008, or the material impact these transactions had on the firm's publicly reported net leverage ratio. According to former Global Financial Con- troller Martin Kelly, a careful review of Lehman's Forms 10-K and 10-Q would not re- veal Lehman's use of Repo 105 transactions. Lehman failed to disclose its Repo 105 practice even though Kelly believed "that the only purpose or motive for the transactions was reduction in balance sheet," felt that "there was no substance to the transactions;" and expressed concerns with Lehman's Repo 105 program to two consecutive Lehman Chief Financial Officers... advising them that the lack of economic substance to Repo 105 transactions meant "reputa- tional risk" to Lehman if the firm's use of the transactions became known to the pub- lic. In addition to its material omissions, Lehman affirmatively misrepresented in its financial statements that the firm treated all repo transactions as financing transac- tions i.e., not sales-for financial reporting purposes. Starting in mid-2007, Lehman faced a crisis: market observers began demanding that investment banks reduce their leverage. The inability to reduce leverage could lead to a ratings downgrade, which would have had an immediate, tangible monetary impact on Lehman.... In mid-to-late 2007, top Lehman executives from across the firm felt pressure to reduce the firm's leverage for quarterly and annual reports.... By January 2008, Lehman CEO Fuld ordered a firm-wide deleveraging strategy, hoping to reduce the firm's positions in commercial and residential real estate and leveraged loans in particular by half. In the words of one internal Lehman presenta- tion, “Reducing leverage is necessary to remove refinancing risk and win back the confidence of the market, lenders, and investors." Fuld recalled that Lehman had to improve its net leverage ratio by selling inventory ... Selling inventory, however, proved difficult in late 2007 and into 2008 because, starting in mid-2007, many of Lehman's inventory positions had grown increasingly "sticky"-i.e., difficult to sell without incurring substantial losses.…... In light of these factors, Lehman relied at an increasing pace on Repo 105 transactions at each quarter- end in late 2007 and early 2008 ... Notably, during Lehman's 2008 earnings calls in which it touted its leverage reduc- tion, analysts frequently inquired about the means by which Lehman was reducing its leverage.... CFO Callan told analysts that Lehman ... was reducing its leverage through the sale of less liquid asset categories but said nothing about the firm's use of Repo 105 transactions. Questions Is it ethical to keep the types of liabilities discussed in this article off the balance sheet, or is this a type of financial statement fraud? In general, what responsibility do auditors have to investigate whistleblower allegations that relate to the material accuracy of an audit client's finance statements? The following discussion is found in the U.S. Bankruptcy Report on Lehman Bros. Holdings dated March 22, 2010: Lehman employed off-balance sheet devices, known within Lehman as "Repo 105" and "Repo 108" transactions, to temporarily remove securities inventory from its bal- ance sheet, usually for a period of seven to ten days... in late 2007 and 2008. Repo 105 transactions were nearly identical to standard repurchase and resale ("repo") transac- tions that Lehman (and other investment banks) used to secure short-term financing, with a critical difference: Lehman accounted for Repo 105 transactions as "sales" as opposed to financing transactions ... By recharacterizing the Repo 105 transaction as a "sale," Lehman removed the inventory from its balance sheet. Lehman regularly increased its use of Repo 105 transactions in the days prior to re- porting periods to reduce its publicly reported net leverage and balance sheet. Lehman's periodic reports did not disclose the cash borrowing from the Repo 105 transaction...Lehman used the cash from the Repo 105 transaction to pay down other liabilities, thereby reducing both the total liabilities and the total assets reported on its balance sheet and lowering its leverage ratios.... A few days after the new quarter be- gan, Lehman would borrow the necessary funds to repay the cash borrowing plus in- terest, repurchase the securities, and restore the assets to its balance sheet. Lehman never publicly disclosed its use of Repo 105 transactions, its accounting treatment for these transactions, the considerable escalation of its total Repo 105 us- age in late 2007 and into 2008, or the material impact these transactions had on the firm's publicly reported net leverage ratio. According to former Global Financial Con- troller Martin Kelly, a careful review of Lehman's Forms 10-K and 10-Q would not re- veal Lehman's use of Repo 105 transactions. Lehman failed to disclose its Repo 105 practice even though Kelly believed "that the only purpose or motive for the transactions was reduction in balance sheet," felt that "there was no substance to the transactions;" and expressed concerns with Lehman's Repo 105 program to two consecutive Lehman Chief Financial Officers... advising them that the lack of economic substance to Repo 105 transactions meant "reputa- tional risk" to Lehman if the firm's use of the transactions became known to the pub- lic. In addition to its material omissions, Lehman affirmatively misrepresented in its financial statements that the firm treated all repo transactions as financing transac- tions i.e., not sales-for financial reporting purposes. Starting in mid-2007, Lehman faced a crisis: market observers began demanding that investment banks reduce their leverage. The inability to reduce leverage could lead to a ratings downgrade, which would have had an immediate, tangible monetary impact on Lehman.... In mid-to-late 2007, top Lehman executives from across the firm felt pressure to reduce the firm's leverage for quarterly and annual reports.... By January 2008, Lehman CEO Fuld ordered a firm-wide deleveraging strategy, hoping to reduce the firm's positions in commercial and residential real estate and leveraged loans in particular by half. In the words of one internal Lehman presenta- tion, “Reducing leverage is necessary to remove refinancing risk and win back the confidence of the market, lenders, and investors." Fuld recalled that Lehman had to improve its net leverage ratio by selling inventory ... Selling inventory, however, proved difficult in late 2007 and into 2008 because, starting in mid-2007, many of Lehman's inventory positions had grown increasingly "sticky"-i.e., difficult to sell without incurring substantial losses.…... In light of these factors, Lehman relied at an increasing pace on Repo 105 transactions at each quarter- end in late 2007 and early 2008 ... Notably, during Lehman's 2008 earnings calls in which it touted its leverage reduc- tion, analysts frequently inquired about the means by which Lehman was reducing its leverage.... CFO Callan told analysts that Lehman ... was reducing its leverage through the sale of less liquid asset categories but said nothing about the firm's use of Repo 105 transactions. Questions Is it ethical to keep the types of liabilities discussed in this article off the balance sheet, or is this a type of financial statement fraud? In general, what responsibility do auditors have to investigate whistleblower allegations that relate to the material accuracy of an audit client's finance statements?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Is it ethical to keep the types of liabilities discussed in this article off the balance sheet or is this a type of financial statement fraud No it is not ethical Explanation Keeping certain liabiliti... View the full answer
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these finance questions
-
As we know, physical and digital sales are on the decline and streaming consumption is increasing. Now that you know about the policies and procedures of working with a traditional distributor, what...
-
Read the case study "Southwest Airlines," found in Part 2 of your textbook. Review the "Guide to Case Analysis" found on pp. CA1 - CA11 of your textbook. (This guide follows the last case in the...
-
The Company classifies its investments in both fixed income securities and publicly traded equity securities as available- for- sale investments. Fixed income securities primarily consist of U. S....
-
Mark Hurd has just assumed the top job at H-P. He has asked you as a staff VP to draw up a course of action to get the ailing PC division up to competitive parity with Dell. If you need to make some...
-
In Fig P6.129 all four horizontal cast-iron pipes are 45 m long and 8 cm in diameter and meet at junction delivering water at 20°C. The pressures are known at four points as shown: p1 = 950 kPa...
-
Suppose that a dependent variable y is related to an explanatory variable x through a linear regression model with 0 = 4.2, 1 = 1.7. and with normally distributed error terms with a zero mean and a...
-
Explain induced drag and how the pilot changes it during flight.
-
Rolodex, Inc., is in the process of determining its capital budget for the next fiscal year. The firms current capital structure, which it considers to be optimal, is contained in the following...
-
Why are organization-wide strategic planning and planning for performance improvement interrelated activities? Reference :...
-
Taxation of reorganizations & liquidations dividends ABC Corp (ABC) was formed 15 years ago by Able and Body (2 individuals). ABC uses the cash method of accounting and reports on a calendar year...
-
Need help with DQ question. We are to identify three stakeholders (individuals or groups) who may have indirect or direct interest in a project outcome at the organization that may influence quality...
-
Describe the evidence that was used by Watson and Crick to define the double helix structure of DNA. and Explain
-
How does rational choice theory elucidate individual decision-making processes within complex social contexts, and what are the underlying assumptions and mechanisms guiding rational actors in...
-
How do enzyme kinetics elucidate the dynamic interplay between substrate concentration, enzyme activity, and reaction rates, particularly within the context of complex biochemical pathways?
-
Simmel argued a century ago that the pace of life had quickened inexorably: the populace of the metropolis was constantly searching out new entertainments and distractions, but satisfaction was only...
-
Find A in the network shown below. 2023 202 www (+6V O 2A 202 352 6V 40 20 8V
-
Does time go faster at the top of a building compared to the bottom?
-
Refer to the data in QS 10-1. Based on financial considerations alone, should Helix accept this order at the special price? Explain.
-
It was late May, just two weeks before Tommy would be leaving for Amarillo to begin the Altamesa audit-the company had a June 30 fiscal year-end. Tommy, Jack Morrison, and an audit manager were...
-
Two congressional investigations in the 1970s provided for the first time revealing insights into the internal operations of the eight major accounting firms that had dominated the U.S. accounting...
-
In late 1993, Joseph Fierro accepted a part-time sales position with a Saks Fifth Avenue store in New York City.1 Fierro was assigned to the Men's Polo Department of that store, a department...
-
Refer to the example concerning average sound intensity on page 260 . Calculate the power at \(\mu_{1}=77\) when (a) the level is changed to \(\alpha=0.03\). (b) \(\alpha=0.05\) but the alternative...
-
Use computer software to repeat Exercise 7.71. Data From Exercise 7.71 77 7.71 Refer to the example concerning average sound inten- sity on page 260. Calculate the power at when (a) the level is...
-
MINITAB calculation of sample size Refer to Exercise 7.72, but this time leave Sample size blank but Type 0.90 in power to obtain the partial output concerning sample size Refer to the example...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App