The North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria has dismissed a bid to have the environmental authorisation...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
The North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria has dismissed a bid to have the environmental authorisation for Eskom's proposed gas power plant in Richards Bay overturned, but has taken aim at the deficient public participation process. In the judgment handed down by Judge Anthony Millar last week, the court dismissed a landmark application brought by two environmental justice NGOs the South Durban Community Environmental Alliance and Groundwork - to review and set aside the Department of Environmental Affairs' decision to grant Eskom's proposed power plant an environmental authorisation. Eskom was granted environmental authorisation in December 2019 for the combined cycle gas power plant intended to be fuelled by gas via a pipeline that will be installed from the Richards Bay Port and which will supply up to 3000MW of energy. Construction on the project has not yet started. The judgment found six out of seven grounds for review of the decision were without merit and could not succeed. These grounds related to inadequate climate change impact assessment; failure to consider renewable alternatives; and the failure to consider cumulative environmental impacts. The court did, however, find the public participation process to be deficient, as communication was published in English only and not isiZulu - a language spoken by 79% of the community that would be directly affected by the proposed plant. Noting the failure to advertise and notify the public in a language other than English, the judgment said "the cavalier approach of the DEFF [Department of Environment, Forestry and Fisheries] and Eskom to this aspect is to be deprecated". The judgment further noted that such an oversight could have warranted setting aside the decision to grant the environmental authorisation, were it not for the fact the Environmental Authorisation for the construction of the gas plant is merely the first link in a chain of successive applications that will have to be processed for the associated gas infrastructure. Because the legal challenge has brought to the fore the deficit in the public participation process, the court was of the view that costs should be awarded in favour of the NGOs. Eskom and DEFF were therefore ordered to foot the bill for two legal counsel. QUESTION 1 (25 Marks) Identify and discuss the application of at least five (5) dimensions of corporate responsibility presented in the case study. State any assumptions you may be required to make. (25 Marks) With the aid of your appropriate examples, discuss at least six (6) factors that have significantly contributed to the current prominence of corporate governance. Based on the actions of the NGOs, evaluate which of the factors is being demonstrated in the case study. QUESTION 2 QUESTION 3 (25 Marks) In relation to the case study, elaborate on the importance of sound ethical decisions in business and discuss the four (4) considerations/requirements that can be utilised by Eskom to assist decision-making. Evaluate which of the consideration made the court decide that costs should be awarded in favour of the NGOS. (25 Marks) Discuss the importance of globalisation of ethical decision-making for companies like Eskom. Based on the case study, differentiate between accountability and compliance in the context of business ethics. QUESTION 4 The North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria has dismissed a bid to have the environmental authorisation for Eskom's proposed gas power plant in Richards Bay overturned, but has taken aim at the deficient public participation process. In the judgment handed down by Judge Anthony Millar last week, the court dismissed a landmark application brought by two environmental justice NGOs the South Durban Community Environmental Alliance and Groundwork - to review and set aside the Department of Environmental Affairs' decision to grant Eskom's proposed power plant an environmental authorisation. Eskom was granted environmental authorisation in December 2019 for the combined cycle gas power plant intended to be fuelled by gas via a pipeline that will be installed from the Richards Bay Port and which will supply up to 3000MW of energy. Construction on the project has not yet started. The judgment found six out of seven grounds for review of the decision were without merit and could not succeed. These grounds related to inadequate climate change impact assessment; failure to consider renewable alternatives; and the failure to consider cumulative environmental impacts. The court did, however, find the public participation process to be deficient, as communication was published in English only and not isiZulu - a language spoken by 79% of the community that would be directly affected by the proposed plant. Noting the failure to advertise and notify the public in a language other than English, the judgment said "the cavalier approach of the DEFF [Department of Environment, Forestry and Fisheries] and Eskom to this aspect is to be deprecated". The judgment further noted that such an oversight could have warranted setting aside the decision to grant the environmental authorisation, were it not for the fact the Environmental Authorisation for the construction of the gas plant is merely the first link in a chain of successive applications that will have to be processed for the associated gas infrastructure. Because the legal challenge has brought to the fore the deficit in the public participation process, the court was of the view that costs should be awarded in favour of the NGOs. Eskom and DEFF were therefore ordered to foot the bill for two legal counsel. QUESTION 1 (25 Marks) Identify and discuss the application of at least five (5) dimensions of corporate responsibility presented in the case study. State any assumptions you may be required to make. (25 Marks) With the aid of your appropriate examples, discuss at least six (6) factors that have significantly contributed to the current prominence of corporate governance. Based on the actions of the NGOs, evaluate which of the factors is being demonstrated in the case study. QUESTION 2 QUESTION 3 (25 Marks) In relation to the case study, elaborate on the importance of sound ethical decisions in business and discuss the four (4) considerations/requirements that can be utilised by Eskom to assist decision-making. Evaluate which of the consideration made the court decide that costs should be awarded in favour of the NGOS. (25 Marks) Discuss the importance of globalisation of ethical decision-making for companies like Eskom. Based on the case study, differentiate between accountability and compliance in the context of business ethics. QUESTION 4
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 The five dimensions of corporate responsibility presented in the case study are environment social governance human rights and philanthropy 2 The si... View the full answer
Related Book For
Fundamentals of corporate finance
ISBN: 978-0073382395
9th edition
Authors: Stephen Ross, Randolph Westerfield, Bradford Jordan
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Consider a combined gassteam power cycle. The topping cycle is a simple Brayton cycle that has a pressure ratio of 7. Air enters the compressor at 15°C at a rate of 10 kg/s and the gas turbine at...
-
A combined gas turbine-vapor power plant has a net power output of 15 MW. Air enters the compressor of the gas turbine at 100 kPa, 290 K and is compressed to 1100 kPa. The isentropic efficiency of...
-
Consider a combined cycle power plant using helium and water as the working fluids. Helium enters the compressor of the gas turbine at 1.4 MPa, 350 K and is compressed to 5.5 MPa. The isentropic...
-
Explain why entrepreneurial firms are often in a strong position to use combination strategies.
-
Why can't we pay our shareholders a dividend? shouted your new boss. This income statement you prepared for me says we earned $5 million in our first half-year! You were hired last month as the chief...
-
What is the difference between the peak amplitude and the resonant amplitude?
-
What are the two basic technologies used for mobile banking and financial services?
-
1. How is an opportunity created to commit appraisal fraud? Does the appraiser act alone, or is collusion routinely involved? 2. How is appraisal fraud detected? Is intent to deceive easy to prove in...
-
Quilters Newsletter Magazine gave instructions on making a quilt. The quilt required 4 yards of white-on-white print, 2 yards blue check, yard blue-and-white stripe, 2 yards blue scraps, yard yellow...
-
Derive and solve the equation of motion for the mass m in terms of the variable x for the system shown. Neglect the mass of the lever AOC and assume small oscillations. C k2 k1 ww TxB = bo cos ot A a
-
Design a synchronous sequential circuit that generates the repeating sequence of decimal numbers 0, 15, 30, 40, 50, 0, 15, 30, ... (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) Indicate all the inputs and outputs that are...
-
True Or False Public disclosure of private facts occurs when private details are published about the plaintiffs life that would be highly offensive to a reasonable person.
-
True Or False Invasion of privacy originated as the result of a Law Review article.
-
In todays defamation law, the standard of proof a plaintiff must meet is determined by the ____________ of the plaintiff and the ____________ involved.
-
True Or False Respond eat superior means let everyone answer.
-
True Or False Absolute immunity applies to spousal communications.
-
Identify your two topics of interest. For one, describe at least two of your current strengths for this topic, while for the other, outline at least two of your current opportunities for growth in...
-
Determine the values of the given trigonometric functions directly on a calculator. The angles are approximate. tan 0.8035
-
Empress Corp. has no debt but can borrow at 8.2 percent. The firms WACC is currently 11 percent, and the tax rate is 35 percent. a. What is the companys cost of equity? b. If the firm converts to 25...
-
a What is operating leverage? b How is operating leverage measured? c What are the implications of operating leverage for the financial manager?
-
Solve for the unknown interest rate in each of the following: Present Value Years Interest Rate Future Value $ 240 $ 297 360 10 15 3) 1,080 39,000 38,261 185,382 531,618
-
Two machines \(X\) and \(Y\) were used to produce two types of plastic polymers, PPET and PAMI. The polymers were produced using materials BA and PP. The production was run 3 times. The \(y\) values...
-
The effect on engine wear of oil viscosity, temperature, and a special additive was tested using a \(2^{3}\) factorial design. Given the following results from the experiment, Interpret the effects...
-
An engineering student wanted to know which factors influence the time (in seconds) for his car to go from 0 to 30 to 0 miles per hour. Factor \(A\) was the launch, which was either no wheel spin or...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App