This project involved a hospital extension consisting of a nine-storey building and a service building for...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
This project involved a hospital extension consisting of a nine-storey building and a service building for the power generator and water storage. The project was almost 3 years behind schedule and had just achieved 14% of the work scope. All the project outcomes or the project symptoms showed that the project was severely unhealthy. The only positive indicator identified was the quality of concrete work. Diagnosing the project, it was found that the contractor's project manager was handling this aspect well because of his extensive experience in the concrete industry. Apparently, however, this project manager had good experience with concrete, but was unqualified in project management. The Project Management Office and the client asked the contractor many times to replace the project manager, but this was not carried out. To make matter worse, there were many design changes in the project, which contributed to the delay. Project Key Performance Indicators The following KPIs were obtained from the progress reports, provided by the Project Management Office (PMO), and through the interview with them. • Cost: Highly confidential; the contractor could not specify the specific cost, but he mentioned that the project was over budget. Obviously, as the contractor was 30 months behind schedule, overhead costs were increasing. Time: The project did not have a planned expenditure cash flow (S curve), and the project was behind schedule. The proportion of time elapsed for the project was 97.26%, but the proportion of work performed is only 14.05%. • Scope: There were many changes in the project's architectural design. Some spaces and bedrooms needed to be redesigned to better use the space; and some spaces did not match with the medical code, such as elevators. • Quality: There were neither defects nor rework found in the project. The quality of concrete was better than the requirement, with an exception for a few concrete foundations and columns that were not properly protected, which could result in rusting of the reinforcement. • Safety: No safety issue was found that caused a problem to the project; however, it was found that the labourers did not follow basic safety regulations, such as wearing safety helmets and shoes. • Satisfaction: The owner was dissatisfied with the project's progress. Project diagnostic (PHC) The level of practice required for this project was 90, based on the complexity of the hospital projects. Unfortunately, the level of practice was found to be far below this target. None of the process enablers were carried out as required. The PHC assessment revealed that the project was managed haphazardly. The significantly large gap between the actual and the target PHC scores could be associated with the poor project KPIs. E.S. Almahmoud et al. / International Journal of Project Management 30 (2012) 296-307 QUESTION 1 1.1A failed projects denotes a misunderstanding of what project performance management is. From your own understanding share what you understand to be project performance management which could have assisted the project team on this failed project (20 Marks) 1.2 One of the causes mentioned in the case study that caused the project to fail was design changes. Critique the importance of the design phase. 1.3 Five KPIs were identified in order to monitor the project, and all of the KPIs seem to have failed. Identify the five (5) KPIs and what was wrong in the KPI. (5 marks) (5 marks) (10 marks) This project involved a hospital extension consisting of a nine-storey building and a service building for the power generator and water storage. The project was almost 3 years behind schedule and had just achieved 14% of the work scope. All the project outcomes or the project symptoms showed that the project was severely unhealthy. The only positive indicator identified was the quality of concrete work. Diagnosing the project, it was found that the contractor's project manager was handling this aspect well because of his extensive experience in the concrete industry. Apparently, however, this project manager had good experience with concrete, but was unqualified in project management. The Project Management Office and the client asked the contractor many times to replace the project manager, but this was not carried out. To make matter worse, there were many design changes in the project, which contributed to the delay. Project Key Performance Indicators The following KPIs were obtained from the progress reports, provided by the Project Management Office (PMO), and through the interview with them. • Cost: Highly confidential; the contractor could not specify the specific cost, but he mentioned that the project was over budget. Obviously, as the contractor was 30 months behind schedule, overhead costs were increasing. Time: The project did not have a planned expenditure cash flow (S curve), and the project was behind schedule. The proportion of time elapsed for the project was 97.26%, but the proportion of work performed is only 14.05%. • Scope: There were many changes in the project's architectural design. Some spaces and bedrooms needed to be redesigned to better use the space; and some spaces did not match with the medical code, such as elevators. • Quality: There were neither defects nor rework found in the project. The quality of concrete was better than the requirement, with an exception for a few concrete foundations and columns that were not properly protected, which could result in rusting of the reinforcement. • Safety: No safety issue was found that caused a problem to the project; however, it was found that the labourers did not follow basic safety regulations, such as wearing safety helmets and shoes. • Satisfaction: The owner was dissatisfied with the project's progress. Project diagnostic (PHC) The level of practice required for this project was 90, based on the complexity of the hospital projects. Unfortunately, the level of practice was found to be far below this target. None of the process enablers were carried out as required. The PHC assessment revealed that the project was managed haphazardly. The significantly large gap between the actual and the target PHC scores could be associated with the poor project KPIs. E.S. Almahmoud et al. / International Journal of Project Management 30 (2012) 296-307 QUESTION 1 1.1A failed projects denotes a misunderstanding of what project performance management is. From your own understanding share what you understand to be project performance management which could have assisted the project team on this failed project (20 Marks) 1.2 One of the causes mentioned in the case study that caused the project to fail was design changes. Critique the importance of the design phase. 1.3 Five KPIs were identified in order to monitor the project, and all of the KPIs seem to have failed. Identify the five (5) KPIs and what was wrong in the KPI. (5 marks) (5 marks) (10 marks)
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
11 Project performance management refers to the process of measuring and analyzing project performance against established objectives and goals It inc... View the full answer
Related Book For
Project Management The Managerial Process
ISBN: 9781260570434
8th Edition
Authors: Eric W Larson, Clifford F. Gray
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
A random sample of 100 students was taken from a large university to study the relationship between GPA and the number of hours of study per week. The following linear regression equation was...
-
The financial statements of P&G are presented in Appendix 5B or can be accessed at the books companion website, www.wiley.com/college/kieso. Instructions Refer to P&Gs financial statements,...
-
Use the same inputs as in the previous problem, except that K = $1.00. In previous problem Suppose that the exchange rate is $0.92/ = C. Let r$ = 4%, and r = C = 3%, u = 1.2, d = 0.9, T = 0.75, n =...
-
Rank in order, from largest to smallest, the currents \(I_{1}, I_{2}\), and \(I_{3}\) in the circuit diagram in Figure Q23.12. R = 3R www R = 2R ww ww T FIGURE Q23.12
-
Biscaynes Rent-A-Ride rents two models of automobiles: the standard and the deluxe. Information follows: Biscaynes total fixed cost is $18,500 per month. Required: 1. Determine the contribution...
-
Describe how technology can be integrated into the retail management strategy to improve the customer experience. Provide examples of technology solutions that can be implemented.
-
Pursuit Company produces two products: Bric and Brac. The following table summarizes the products details and planned unit sales for the upcoming period: Pursuit Company has total fixed costs of $10...
-
The journal entry for the outstanding checks would be a. Debit Expenses 1,594; Credit Cash 1,594 Ob. You would not write a journal entry for outstanding checks c. Debit Outstanding checks $1,594;...
-
3) lim, 3X'+ HX+2 x2-x-6 X-2
-
If you needed to raise ten million dollars ($10,000,000) for your for-profit healthcare organization, which would you prefer in exchange of the monies: Debt or preferred stock or common stock?
-
A standard bowling ball weighs 15 pounds. You wish to hold a bowling ball in front of you, with the elbow bent at a right angle. Assume that your biceps attaches to your forearm at 2.5 cm out from...
-
Linda knows that the price of a company's preferred stock is $130, and she knows that the dividend is $22 per year. What is her dividend yield
-
Using the information from this module's readings and the videos ( A strength Based Model of Mental Health, and The Strength-Based Model and Motivational Interviewing) write a 2-page paper reflecting...
-
From the following information related to Ralph Welfare Society prepare Income and Expenditure Account for the year ended 31st March, 2010. Dr. RECEIPTS AND PAYMENTS ACCOUNT for the year ended 31st...
-
Based on the scenario described below, generate all possible association rules with values for confidence, support (for dependent), and lift. Submit your solutions in a Word document (name it...
-
How did Singer establish effective patterns of communication?
-
The 2008 Olympic Redeem Team Which of the eight characteristics associated with positive synergy were evident in the case of the Redeem team? Which of the eight characteristics associated with...
-
Ventura Baseball Stadium is a 47,000-seat professional baseball stadium. G&E Company began construction on June 10, 2019, and will complete it on February 21, 2022. The stadium must be ready for the...
-
What percentage of women have red blood cell counts in the normal range from 4.2 to 5.4? Assume that red blood cell counts of women are normally distributed with a mean of 4.577 and a standard...
-
Find P 80 , the 80th percentile for the red blood cell counts of women.
-
If 25 women are randomly selected, find the probability that the mean of their red blood cell counts is less than 4.444. Assume that red blood cell counts of women are normally distributed with a...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App