Question: Trolley Case ( There is a train that will kill 5 people on its path, do you pull the switch to divert the trolley to

Trolley Case ( There is a train that will kill 5 people on its path, do you pull the switch to divert the trolley to kill 1 person instead)

1. Explain how a Consequentialist would deal with this problem (5)

2. Explain how a Deontologist would deal with this case (5)

3. Which would you choose and why? (5)

4. Explain why intention matters in this scenario (5)

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer
Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image
Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock
Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related Accounting Questions!

Q:

Trolley Case ( There is a train that will kill 5 people on its path, do you pull the switch to divert the trolley to kill 1 person instead) 1. Explain how a Consequentialist would deal with this...

Q:

Trolley Case ( There is a train that will kill 5 people on its path, do you pull the switch to divert the trolley to kill 1 person instead) 1. Explain how a Consequentialist would deal with this pr...

Q:

Trolley Case ( There is a train that will kill 5 people on its path, do you pull the switch to divert the trolley to kill 1 person instead) 1. Explain how a Consequentialist would deal with this pr...

Q:

QUESTION 1 In 1967, British philosopher Philippa Foot created a scenario called: the train problem the trolley problem the car problem the boat problem QUESTION 2 With regard to the trolley problem,...

Q:

List and describe the ethical theories that the textbook DOES consider to be workable ethical theories. For each, be able to say if the theory would consider a given situation to be ethical, and why....

Q:

Read Chapters 1,2,4,7 and Write a 800 - 1000 word Reflection Paper Grading : ?Thoughtfulness?Reactions,personal experiences,criticisms, etc. ?Application to your futureprofessional(and personal)life...

Q:

The Trolley Problem is an ethical dilemma in which a person (you in this situation) sees a runaway trolley racing down a set of railway tracks. Five people are tied up on the railroad, and the...

Q:

Business Ethics: Best Practices for Designing and Managing Ethical Organizations, Second Edition Chapter 05: Ethical Decision Making While the trolley problem (Table 5.5) may seem unrealistic,...

Q:

In the negligence case, fully analyze the scenario in terms of the elements of negligence. That is, discuss duty, breach, injury, and causation (both actual and proximate). ILLINOIS OFFICIAL REPORTS...

Q:

A "thought" experiment: The Runaway Train Durham University Imagine you are standing on a bridge over two narrow ravines, each with rail tracks at their base. In the distance you see a runaway train...

Q:

a) Consider a model of voluntary incentive mechanism designed for private landowners to induce them to retire land for protecting biodiversity on private land, similar to the one we discussed in the...

Q:

Surgical Supplies Corporation paid a dividend of $1.12 per share over the last 12 months. The dividend is expected to grow at a rate of 25 percent over the next three years (supernormal growth). It...

Q:

Accessiblity of a retirement annuity vs a tax free savings account

Q:

Hugo decides to buy his Christmas gifts on Black Friday. To simplify his life, he is giving his 10 closest friends scarves for Christmas and everyone else Christmas cards. Hugo is willing to pay up...