Two fuel brands, Shell and Esso, are considering opening a gas station at the same highway...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Two fuel brands, Shell and Esso, are considering opening a gas station at the same highway intersection. There is a one-time $50 irreversible cost from opening a station. Once active, stations compete by choosing prices simultaneously. Both stations have a gas per-liter cost of $4; there are no ongoing fixed costs. The firms anticipate that aggregate fuel demand at the intersection will be Q = 100-10P, and consumers perceive gasoline as a homogeneous good, i.e., consumers shop for the lowest price across any active firm. 1. (10 points) Each firm makes a Yes/No decision about whether to enter the market simultane- ously. For each possible combination of entry decisions, describe the equilibrium price and profits (including start-up costs) for each firm. The question describes a simultaneous entry decision game, followed by Bertrand competition between firms with homogeneous goods. We know that for the symmetric case, both firms choose a price at the marginal in the Bertrand equilibrium. If only one firm enters, then it will choose the monopolist solution: maxp(100-10P) (P-4)→ p=7⇒ = 30 x 3-50=40. Hence, the matrix form of the entry games is: Shell Esso E NE E -50,-50 40,0 NE 0,40 0,0 . 5 points for the correct solution of the Bertrand situation. 5 points for the correct final answer 2. (5 points) Find all Nash equilibria of the entry game between the two firms. The Nash equilibria are (NE,E), (E,NE), and a strategy profile with mixed strategies. 4 points for the two pure strategy Nash • 1 point for the mentioning mixed strategy Nash 3. (5 points) What would the equilibrium profits be if one firm had a marginal cost of 87 while the other had a marginal cost of 84? Let's assume that Shell has a marginal cost equal to 84. In the Bertrand equilibrium of the asymmetric cost case, firms set prices at the highest marginal cost, and the firm with the lowest marginal cost serves the whole market. Shell's profit if both firms enter is now: (100-10x7) (7-4)-50-40. The monopolist profit of Esso is now 22.5. The new payoff matrix is: Shell Esso E NE 40.-50 40.0 NE 0,22.5 0.0 Now, Enter is a dominant strategy for Shell. The only Nash equilibrium is (E,NE). 2.5 points for the new Bertrand profits • 2.5 points for the new Nash equilibrium Two fuel brands, Shell and Esso, are considering opening a gas station at the same highway intersection. There is a one-time $50 irreversible cost from opening a station. Once active, stations compete by choosing prices simultaneously. Both stations have a gas per-liter cost of $4; there are no ongoing fixed costs. The firms anticipate that aggregate fuel demand at the intersection will be Q = 100-10P, and consumers perceive gasoline as a homogeneous good, i.e., consumers shop for the lowest price across any active firm. 1. (10 points) Each firm makes a Yes/No decision about whether to enter the market simultane- ously. For each possible combination of entry decisions, describe the equilibrium price and profits (including start-up costs) for each firm. The question describes a simultaneous entry decision game, followed by Bertrand competition between firms with homogeneous goods. We know that for the symmetric case, both firms choose a price at the marginal in the Bertrand equilibrium. If only one firm enters, then it will choose the monopolist solution: maxp(100-10P) (P-4)→ p=7⇒ = 30 x 3-50=40. Hence, the matrix form of the entry games is: Shell Esso E NE E -50,-50 40,0 NE 0,40 0,0 . 5 points for the correct solution of the Bertrand situation. 5 points for the correct final answer 2. (5 points) Find all Nash equilibria of the entry game between the two firms. The Nash equilibria are (NE,E), (E,NE), and a strategy profile with mixed strategies. 4 points for the two pure strategy Nash • 1 point for the mentioning mixed strategy Nash 3. (5 points) What would the equilibrium profits be if one firm had a marginal cost of 87 while the other had a marginal cost of 84? Let's assume that Shell has a marginal cost equal to 84. In the Bertrand equilibrium of the asymmetric cost case, firms set prices at the highest marginal cost, and the firm with the lowest marginal cost serves the whole market. Shell's profit if both firms enter is now: (100-10x7) (7-4)-50-40. The monopolist profit of Esso is now 22.5. The new payoff matrix is: Shell Esso E NE 40.-50 40.0 NE 0,22.5 0.0 Now, Enter is a dominant strategy for Shell. The only Nash equilibrium is (E,NE). 2.5 points for the new Bertrand profits • 2.5 points for the new Nash equilibrium
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
The question describes a simultaneous entry decision game followed by Bert rand competition between ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Managerial Economics and Strategy
ISBN: 978-0321566447
1st edition
Authors: Jeffrey M. Perloff, James A. Brander
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
A gas station at a rest stop along the highway can pay the owner of the rest stop $ 40,000 to prevent a second station from opening. Without entry, the incumbent gas stations profit is i = $ 100,000....
-
The directors of Zeus plc are considering opening a new manufacturing facility. The finance director has provided the following information: Initial capital investment: 2,500,000. Dividends for the...
-
A 58-year-old couple are considering opening a business of their own. They will either purchase an established Gift and Card Shoppe or open a new Wine Boutique. The Gift Shoppe has a continuous...
-
The two roots of a quadratic equation ax 2 + bx + c = 0 can be obtained using the following formula: b 2 - 4ac is called the discriminant of the quadratic equation. If it is positive, the equation...
-
Coras Music manufactures harmonicas. Cora uses standard costs to judge performance. Recently, a clerk mistakenly threw away some of the records, and only partial data for September exist. Cora knows...
-
Consider the liquid-level control system shown in Fig. P124. The tanks are noninteracting. The following information is known: The resistances on the tanks are linear. These resistances were tested...
-
I spent time with you. It seems that this deed is out of character for you. You were not awarded your normal annual bonus. I would probably feel the same. Is that what happened? You normally wouldnt...
-
The Association of Women in Government established an Educational Foundation to raise money to support scholarship and other education initiatives. The Educational Foundation is a private...
-
What are the reasons to use a relational database? What data does not fit well in the relational model?
-
The average grain diameter for a brass material was measured as a function of time at 650°C, which is tabulated below at two different times: (a) What was the original grain diameter? (b) What...
-
one side of a triangle is 50 units long. A segment parallel to the other side and 20 units from it cuts off a trapezoid with area 320 square units. Find the length of the other side and the segment....
-
What are the principal factors influencing the selection between relational and non-relational database models in the context of evolving data ecosystems, considering criteria such as data volume,...
-
Recommend where would you start to improve the user experience. Pharmacists are asking for your help due to struggles with non-integrated systems. What methods would you use to examine this issue?...
-
What are the emerging trends and challenges in the integration of graph databases and knowledge graphs into traditional relational and NoSQL database ecosystems to enable more sophisticated querying...
-
Q1 What are the three most common criteria used to determine movement through the day range? Q 2Discuss two advantages and two disadvantage of conducting compensation surveys in house Q 3Identify and...
-
Explore the intricacies of cancer metastasis by delving into the molecular underpinnings, particularly emphasizing the cellular and genetic determinants propelling tumor advancement and dissemination.
-
1 find support reaction at A and B 40KN 2MM 48KN- 3m 4
-
Write an SQL statement to display all data on products having a QuantityOnHand greater than 0.
-
Using a graph similar to figure, show that increasing output beyond the competitive level decreases total surplus because the cost of producing this extra output exceeds the value consumers place on...
-
Two firms face the following profit matrix: Given these profits, Firm 2 wants to match Firm 1s price, but Firm 1 does not want to match Firm 2s price. Does either firm have a dominant strategy? Does...
-
If a policy change causes a Pareto improvement, is the outcome necessarily Pareto efficient? If a situation is Pareto efficient, are Pareto improvements possible? If a change occurs that causes a...
-
Parents with a child in subsidized childcare in the province of Qubec, Canada, pay a basic amount and, depending on family income, may pay an additional amount. As of January 1, 2017, families with a...
-
A firm in the state of Karnataka in India can source one of its factors of production either within the state, \(F_{K}\), or from the neighboring state of Maharashtra, \(F_{M}\). Assume the quality...
-
A firm has the cost curve \(C(q)=25+q^{2}\). Show how the firm's average cost varies with output. Is there a minimum average cost and, if so, at what level of output is average cost minimized?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App