Question: Using this link Please help me complete this Journal Article Critique Instructions - YouTube Article Summary . What was (were) the independent variable(s)? What was

Using this link Please help me complete this

Journal Article Critique Instructions - YouTube

Article Summary.

What was (were) the independent variable(s)?
What was (were) the dependent variable(s)?
Describe the results: What did the author discover?

What are the

implications of the results?

Critique the internal, construct, and external validity:

Internal validity:

Can they make cause and effect statements? That is, was it an experimental (random assignment to groups, comparison, and manipulation) or a correlational design?

External validity:

Who were the subjects and how were they selected?

What, if anything, might be distinctive about them that would limit generalizability?

What was the drop-out rate and might it have affected the group's composition?

What evidence is given that the results should apply to other groups of participants?

External (cont).

What was the research setting? Would the results generalize to different settings? Can you pinpoint a difference between the

research setting and a real-life settingand give a specific reason why this difference would prevent the results from applying to real life?

Construct Validity

Questions about variables that were measured in the study:

  1. What evidence is given that the measures were reliable?
  1. What evidence did they provide for the validity (accuracy) of their measures?
  1. In your estimation, do you think the measures they used were good ones?

How might the researchers have biased the study's results?

  1. What "blind" or "double blind" techniques were used, if any?

b) Where might there have been a lack of standardization that could have biased the results?

Conclusion

Was there anything that may be questionable about theethics of this study (how human subjects were treated)?

Do you agree with the authors' stated implications of the results of this study?

Why or why not?

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer
Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image
Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock
Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related Psychology Questions!