Which is more important: Resources or industry? In the big picture of things, there are two...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Which is more important: Resources or industry? In the big picture of things, there are two opposing strategic views on the most important contributor to above average returns. Usually companies are rewarded when they produce greater profits than do rivals. These are referred to as either an industrial organization model (I/O) or a resource based view model (RBV). Proponents of the industrial organization (I/O) model believe that a firm's competitive advantage is based on external factors. According to this model, a company will get ahead by observing the actions of competitors and predicting their next moves. Competitive advantage, therefore, is obtained by gaining information on what other players in the market are doing. The I/O model specifies a firm's strategy based on external environment with the characteristics of general, industry and competitor environments (Hanson). This model allows the firms in an industry to compete on their performance regarding to the threat of new entrants, rivalry among competing firms threat of substitute products, bargaining power of suppliers and bargaining power of buyers. Specifically, this I/O relationship is easily observed in the stock market whereby price performance of firms tends to move in tandem over a period of years. Why enter the retail clothing industry when you could go marketing a variety of products online. According to the resource-based perspective (RBV), on the other hand, competitive advantage comes from internal rather than external sources. In other words, it is the human capital of the business, the customer loyalty that has built up around the brand, and other assets that the business already has that will make it more successful. As the name implies, the company will develop its competitive advantage based on the resources that it has. According to Dr. Jay Hanson, the RBV model specifies a firm's strategy internally to earn above- average returns based on its unique resources and capabilities. Resources such as capital, equipment, individuals' skills, patents and finances are formed into a capability and is managed dynamically to achieve competitive advantages over its rivals. Specifically, this is shown in obtaining superior financing, marketing, or use of technology. Examples are Nike loyalty and advertising. The RBV focuses on internal factors while the I/O model focuses on external factors to achieve above-average returns. It may seem the logical answer is both are important, and both are important. However organizations have limited resources and must decide the best way to allocate those resources. While both models may be considered, the emphasis perhaps should be on one or the other. Which is more important: Resources or industry? In the big picture of things, there are two opposing strategic views on the most important contributor to above average returns. Usually companies are rewarded when they produce greater profits than do rivals. These are referred to as either an industrial organization model (I/O) or a resource based view model (RBV). Proponents of the industrial organization (I/O) model believe that a firm's competitive advantage is based on external factors. According to this model, a company will get ahead by observing the actions of competitors and predicting their next moves. Competitive advantage, therefore, is obtained by gaining information on what other players in the market are doing. The I/O model specifies a firm's strategy based on external environment with the characteristics of general, industry and competitor environments (Hanson). This model allows the firms in an industry to compete on their performance regarding to the threat of new entrants, rivalry among competing firms threat of substitute products, bargaining power of suppliers and bargaining power of buyers. Specifically, this I/O relationship is easily observed in the stock market whereby price performance of firms tends to move in tandem over a period of years. Why enter the retail clothing industry when you could go marketing a variety of products online. According to the resource-based perspective (RBV), on the other hand, competitive advantage comes from internal rather than external sources. In other words, it is the human capital of the business, the customer loyalty that has built up around the brand, and other assets that the business already has that will make it more successful. As the name implies, the company will develop its competitive advantage based on the resources that it has. According to Dr. Jay Hanson, the RBV model specifies a firm's strategy internally to earn above- average returns based on its unique resources and capabilities. Resources such as capital, equipment, individuals' skills, patents and finances are formed into a capability and is managed dynamically to achieve competitive advantages over its rivals. Specifically, this is shown in obtaining superior financing, marketing, or use of technology. Examples are Nike loyalty and advertising. The RBV focuses on internal factors while the I/O model focuses on external factors to achieve above-average returns. It may seem the logical answer is both are important, and both are important. However organizations have limited resources and must decide the best way to allocate those resources. While both models may be considered, the emphasis perhaps should be on one or the other.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answer The debate between the importance of resources versus industry in achieving aboveaverage returns is central to strategic management theory Lets ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Organisational Behaviour In The Workplace
ISBN: 9781292245485
12th Edition
Authors: Jacqueline Mclean, Laurie Mullins
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
1. How strong are the competitive forces confronting J. Crew in the market for specialty retail? Do a [Michael Porter] five-forces analysis to support your answer. (see chapter 3 in the textfor...
-
Read the case study "Southwest Airlines," found in Part 2 of your textbook. Review the "Guide to Case Analysis" found on pp. CA1 - CA11 of your textbook. (This guide follows the last case in the...
-
The AFL-CIO has undertaken a study of the yearly salaries (in thousands of dollars) of 30 administrative assistants. The organization wants to predict salaries from several other variables. The...
-
Describe how we can find the hydrostatic force against a vertical wall submersed in a fluid.
-
How would you conduct a diagnosis of the situation at HealthCo? Provide examples of the types of data you would collect, how you would collect it, and how you would use it ?
-
In a spin to the left, which wing has a higher angle of attack?
-
You have been asked to advise a business-to-business manufacturing company how to detect fraudulent financial reporting. Management does not understand how early revenue recognition by backdating...
-
Based on the following memo, could you help me identify the key facts? Then could you help me with the assignment described at the end? TO: Associate FROM: I.M. Shirley Wright, Partner DATE: October...
-
2. (10 points) Consider the Macrotopia economy that produces the goods in the quantities listed below. Use this data for the following questions. (Hint: Spreadsheet software is your friend; it will...
-
A high-speed rail line is proposed to connect two large cities 200 miles apart. The "constant speed" is expected to be 110 mph, with acceleration and deceleration rates at 3 ft/sec/sec.. A. How much...
-
What is the likely rationale behind excluding persons convicted for certain offences from possessing guns? A belief that convicted persons are more likely to commit further crimes with firearms than...
-
Andy currently has a balance of $4,585.92 in an account he has held for 21 years. He opened the account with an initial deposit of $3,278. What is the simple interest rate on the account?
-
How can resource management be effectively implemented in agile and dynamic project environments, where flexibility and adaptability are paramount?
-
The City of Bowling Green wants to build a public recreational park that would have an initial cost of $200,000. They anticipate additional one-time costs of 30,000, and 15,000 after 2 years and 5...
-
How has food and product labeling affected the health and safety of the American consumer? Provide an example of labeling and its impact on the American consumer. Are federal antitrust laws designed...
-
Answer the following two independent questions. a. MM Corporation is considering several proposed investments for the coming budget year. MM produces electrical apparatus for industrial complexes....
-
Will the bulb in Figure Q22.2 light? Explain. + FIGURE Q22.2
-
Electroconvulsive therapy is a last-line treatment for certain mental disorders. In this treatment, an electric current is passed directly through the brain, inducing seizures. The total charge that...
-
When a current passes through the body, it is mainly carried by positively charged sodium ions (Na + ) with charge +e and negatively charged chloride ions (Cl - ) with charge -e. In a given electric...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App