William Johnson has recently graduated from a local community college in upstate New York. He is...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
William Johnson has recently graduated from a local community college in upstate New York. He is also the owner of "Lawn-Pro", a landscaping and lawn-mowing business. During the first couple of years when the business was at its early stages, William used the money from the lawn service business to supplement his allowance from his parents. However, more recently, his business had grown to the point it generated enough income for him to become almost financially independent. This provided him the incentive to continue this business and pursue it on a full-time basis. The business operated for six months each year and by the end of each season it generated a net income of $40,000. Most of the income (80%) was generated from the landscaping portion of the business and the mowing service's contribution was secondary (20%). Due to the prohibitive cost of new machinery, William had always used second- or third-hand equipment. However, lately his existing equipment appeared to have reached the end of its productive life. Its maintenance had increased dramatically both in frequency and cost. Consequently, William is now considering replacing the equipment with a new machine so he may have the benefits of a longer machine- productive life compared to that of the second-hand equipment he has been using in the past. After some brief research, he has identified two brands which he considers to be of high quality, John Deere and Ariens. The John Deere equipment costs $9,200, and the Ariens equipment costs $10,900. William could finance the equipment through a small business loan at 6% (which is his hurdle rate or cost of capital). One of the main differences between the machines is that the Ariens mower, although more expensive than the John Deere, has an overall lower maintenance cost. This will translate into higher projected future cash inflows for the Ariens and lower projected cash inflows for the John Deere mower. Based on his experience with various machines, Williams estimates the total useful life of both John Deere and Ariens lawn mowers to be five years. Williams also estimates the salvage value of these lawn mowers at the end of their estimated useful lives to be zero. With the help of his friend, Mr. CPA, Williams estimates the projected annual cash inflows generated by each machine and received at the end of each subsequent period/year as follows (see table below). John Deere Ariens Cash Inflows Year 3 Year 1 Year 4 Year 2 $8,400 $8,200 $7,900 $7,600 $9,000 $9.000 $9,000 $9.000 Year 5 $7,000 $9,000 Required: (Ignore income taxes.) a) (4 marks) For each of the alternatives, conduct NPV and IRR analyses. Based on these quantitative analyses, please advise William on which machine to select. (Note: ONLY IF you are using the present value tables for calculating IRR, as a simplifying assumption you can assume that the annual cash inflows for John Deere will be $8,142 equal per year. This assumption can be used only for John Deere IRR calculation and not for any other part of this question. If you are using Excel or your calculator, please proceed with the data given in the table above.) b) (5 marks) Briefly explain the limitations of NPV and IRR analyses each. Suggest a potential metric that mitigates these limitations (and explain how it mitigates any limitations of NPV and IRR). Calculate this metric for both the alternatives and advise William on which machine to select. c) (4 marks) Calculate and compare the Payback Period for both the alternatives. Based on this metric, please advise William on which machine to select. Explain briefly the pros and cons of using Payback Period to evaluate capital projects. d) (3 marks) Are there any other qualitative or not immediately quantifiable factors that could influence the capital budgeting analyses? Suggest at least three such factors that William should consider. e) (2 marks) William's sister (a third-year commerce student) happens to look over the capital budgeting metrics you have just calculated. She looks specifically at the impressive IRR for both the machines and says that: "With returns so good I almost feel like dropping out of college and pursuing lawncare as a full-time profession. Instead of one, I will buy 10 lawn mowers. With the help of friends and family, we can have a very successful business with returns that would be the envy of high flyers in the finance industry!!" Advise William's sister on whether dropping out of college based on William's IRR estimates is in her best interests. f) (2 mark) Mr. CPA recalls reading in the Wall Street Magazine about a recent government initiative that allows complete and immediate expensing of capital expenditure for tax reporting purposes by small businesses, to help spur capital investment activity in the U.S. But he also recalls his management accounting professor saying that how capital expenditure is allocated over future time periods (i.e., depreciation expense) for financial accounting purposes is not relevant. Can you help resolve Mr. CPA's confusion? William Johnson has recently graduated from a local community college in upstate New York. He is also the owner of "Lawn-Pro", a landscaping and lawn-mowing business. During the first couple of years when the business was at its early stages, William used the money from the lawn service business to supplement his allowance from his parents. However, more recently, his business had grown to the point it generated enough income for him to become almost financially independent. This provided him the incentive to continue this business and pursue it on a full-time basis. The business operated for six months each year and by the end of each season it generated a net income of $40,000. Most of the income (80%) was generated from the landscaping portion of the business and the mowing service's contribution was secondary (20%). Due to the prohibitive cost of new machinery, William had always used second- or third-hand equipment. However, lately his existing equipment appeared to have reached the end of its productive life. Its maintenance had increased dramatically both in frequency and cost. Consequently, William is now considering replacing the equipment with a new machine so he may have the benefits of a longer machine- productive life compared to that of the second-hand equipment he has been using in the past. After some brief research, he has identified two brands which he considers to be of high quality, John Deere and Ariens. The John Deere equipment costs $9,200, and the Ariens equipment costs $10,900. William could finance the equipment through a small business loan at 6% (which is his hurdle rate or cost of capital). One of the main differences between the machines is that the Ariens mower, although more expensive than the John Deere, has an overall lower maintenance cost. This will translate into higher projected future cash inflows for the Ariens and lower projected cash inflows for the John Deere mower. Based on his experience with various machines, Williams estimates the total useful life of both John Deere and Ariens lawn mowers to be five years. Williams also estimates the salvage value of these lawn mowers at the end of their estimated useful lives to be zero. With the help of his friend, Mr. CPA, Williams estimates the projected annual cash inflows generated by each machine and received at the end of each subsequent period/year as follows (see table below). John Deere Ariens Cash Inflows Year 3 Year 1 Year 4 Year 2 $8,400 $8,200 $7,900 $7,600 $9,000 $9.000 $9,000 $9.000 Year 5 $7,000 $9,000 Required: (Ignore income taxes.) a) (4 marks) For each of the alternatives, conduct NPV and IRR analyses. Based on these quantitative analyses, please advise William on which machine to select. (Note: ONLY IF you are using the present value tables for calculating IRR, as a simplifying assumption you can assume that the annual cash inflows for John Deere will be $8,142 equal per year. This assumption can be used only for John Deere IRR calculation and not for any other part of this question. If you are using Excel or your calculator, please proceed with the data given in the table above.) b) (5 marks) Briefly explain the limitations of NPV and IRR analyses each. Suggest a potential metric that mitigates these limitations (and explain how it mitigates any limitations of NPV and IRR). Calculate this metric for both the alternatives and advise William on which machine to select. c) (4 marks) Calculate and compare the Payback Period for both the alternatives. Based on this metric, please advise William on which machine to select. Explain briefly the pros and cons of using Payback Period to evaluate capital projects. d) (3 marks) Are there any other qualitative or not immediately quantifiable factors that could influence the capital budgeting analyses? Suggest at least three such factors that William should consider. e) (2 marks) William's sister (a third-year commerce student) happens to look over the capital budgeting metrics you have just calculated. She looks specifically at the impressive IRR for both the machines and says that: "With returns so good I almost feel like dropping out of college and pursuing lawncare as a full-time profession. Instead of one, I will buy 10 lawn mowers. With the help of friends and family, we can have a very successful business with returns that would be the envy of high flyers in the finance industry!!" Advise William's sister on whether dropping out of college based on William's IRR estimates is in her best interests. f) (2 mark) Mr. CPA recalls reading in the Wall Street Magazine about a recent government initiative that allows complete and immediate expensing of capital expenditure for tax reporting purposes by small businesses, to help spur capital investment activity in the U.S. But he also recalls his management accounting professor saying that how capital expenditure is allocated over future time periods (i.e., depreciation expense) for financial accounting purposes is not relevant. Can you help resolve Mr. CPA's confusion?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
a 4 marks For each of the alternatives conduct NP V and IR R analyses Based on these quantitative analyses please advise William on which machine to select ANSWER John Deere NPV 9200 8400106 82001062 ... View the full answer
Related Book For
International Business
ISBN: 9781292274157
8th Edition
Authors: Simon Collinson, Rajneesh Narula, Alan M. Rugman
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
A local community college has a problem with the retention of students. The community college has done some preliminary research and found out that students feel disconnected and do not know what is...
-
Jess Brooks has recently graduated from a business school and has joined the family business as an accountant. At the first management meeting with production, marketing and sales, a great deal of...
-
Tim Carswell has recently graduated from his state university, majoring in accounting. He has taken a job with a medium-sized firm that offers financial accounting, audit, and consulting services to...
-
On January 1, 2012, Wilmes Floral supplies borrowed $2,413 from Bower Financial Services. Wilmes Floral Supplies gave Bower a $2,500 note with a maturity date of December 31, 2013. The note specified...
-
Claude is a CPA and a partner with SKH and Associates, a regional public accounting firm. In September 2009, Brokaw Technologies approached one of his clients, Walter Fenner, about acquiring 100...
-
Create T-accounts for cash (opening balance $4000), inventory (opening balance $2000), sales revenue and COGS and then post the following from the general journal to the ledger accounts. 10 Feb 2019...
-
The magnitude of the magnetic field in a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) machine can be as great as \(B=3.0 \mathrm{~T}\). Under normal circumstances, this field cannot be shut off by just flipping...
-
a. A friend of yours, Grace, wants to purchase a house in five years. To save for the house, Grace decides to deposit $112,000 in a savings account on January 1 of this year. The savings account will...
-
6. 7. 8. The reaction of sulphur in alkaline medium is given below Sais) +aOH bs2 (aq) (aq) + CS0 (aq) + H2O (1) . (Integer answer) The values of 'a' is 4.5g of compound A (MW = 90) was used to make...
-
Kofi Allon, who is 32 years old and single, is employed as a technical consultant for a large electronics distributor. He lives at 678 Birch Street, LaMesa, CA 91941. Kofi's Social Security number is...
-
Below is the Trial Balance for Voortex Ltd. (Voortex) at the financial year end 30 September 2019. Voortex operates as a wholesaler of goods, selling mostly on credit. VOORTEX LTD. Trial Balance as...
-
The weights of individual M&M plain candies were obtained by placing each candy in a paper cup, then obtaining the weight without accounting for the weight of the cup. Identify at least one likely...
-
You want to determine the average mercury content of the tuna fish consumed by U.S. residents. Suggest a sampling method that is likely to produce a representative sample. Explain why you chose this...
-
The five-year survival rate for Blacks for all forms of cancer increased from 27% in the 1960s to 48% now. Describe changes in which the measurements themselves are percentages. Express each change...
-
In an Opinion Research poll, 1,072 adults were asked what they would do with their old cell phones, and 44.0% of them said that they would donate them to charity. What is the actual number of...
-
You want to determine the mean age of all statistics instructors at the University of Colorado. representative Samples? In Exercises 1316, identify the sample, population, and sampling method. Then...
-
Design an M40 grade concrete mix using the given data: a) Flexural Str. 4.5 N/mm2 j. Sp. Gr. Cement 3.15 b) Cement OPC 43 Grade k. Sp. Gr. Coarse agg. 2.74 c) MNSA 31.5 mm l. Sp. Gr. Fine...
-
As long as we can't lose any money, we have a risk-free investment." Discuss this comment. Q2: Both investing and gambling can be defined as "undertaking risk in order to earn a profit." Explain how...
-
What are the causes of Brexit and what has it revealed about the politics of economic integration?
-
One of the rules of international production strategy is: manufacture the highest-quality product and the world is likely to beat a path to your door. A number of firms help illustrate this rule. One...
-
Which bank is the worlds largest? Prior to the merger of Citicorp and Travelers in 1998, it was the Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (HSBC). By 2018, HSBC was the worlds seventh largest...
-
Apple stock is selling for \($120\) per share. Call options with a \($117\) exercise price are priced at \($12.\) What is the intrinsic value of the option, and what is the time value?
-
Name five variables that can affect the price of options, and briefly explain how each affects prices. How important are intrinsic value and time value to in-the-money options? To out-of-the-money...
-
Twitter is trading at \($34.50.\) Call options with a strike price of \($35\) are priced at \($2.30\) . What is the intrinsic value of the option, and what is the time value?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App