You are an engineer reviewing the production line for a great new smoke alarm. The following...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
You are an engineer reviewing the production line for a great new smoke alarm. The following is an extract of the FMEA that has been conducted on the product and you have been tasked with reviewing production costs and the safety of the product. System Subsystem Component Design Lead ore Team Item/Function Sensor A Alarm component Alarm housing Design Verification Process Shay Isaac See Project III R1 Report Potential Failure Mode(s) Not correctly calibrated Insufficien t volume Alarm cover breaks at first removal Potential Fifact(s) of Fallure Faulty fire KHTIXOT Faulty fire sensor Potential Cause(s) Mechanism(s) of Failure 9 thuman error Sev 8 Faulty component Replacement 3 Incorrectly housing required cast housing Potential Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (Design FMEA) Key Dute Occ Current Design Controls 1 Training and verification of tasting 1 Inspection Det 3 4 4 Inspection 2 RPN Recommende d Action(s) 54 Purchase specialised calibration tool 45 Investigate alternative alarm component 24 Negotiate quality with supplier Responsibility & Target Completion Dute Your investigations have led to 2 options for improving the products FMEA Number Project III Prepared By Sylvia Wu FMEA Date Revision Date Currently the product has the following (simplified) cost and revenue components: • The wholesale price of each sensor is $75 • The company has a contract to sell 24 000 units per year. • The company spent $350 000 to design this particular mechanism. They invested $1 million in setting up for production. . The production cost is $62 per unit Page 1 Actions Takan 22/10/2020 21/08/2021 Action Results New Sev New Occ New Det New RPN Your investigations have led to 2 options for improving the products Option A: You source a calibration unit for Sensor A which costs $235 000 and will increase the rate at which you detect the problem. You believe this will reduce the "Detection" value in the FMEA analysis for the Sensor A to a value of 2. Option B: You can change the manufacturer of the alarm housing to one with better quality casting. This will reduce the "Occurrence" of the problem of the alarm housing breaking at first removal to a a value of 3 but will cost an additional $0.50 per unit. Answer the following questions: 1. For Option A, how long will it take to break even? (Answer in years to 2 decimal places) 2. For Option A, what is the new RPN for the Sensor A failure listed? 3. For Option B, how long will it take to break even? (Answer in years to 2 decimal places) 4. For Option B, what is the new RPN for the Alarm housing failure listed? 5. Which option will you suggest to your manager? (A or B) Justify your answer (You can consider the costs, revenue, breakeven, the FMEA, improved safety etc. for your answer but you must to select one of the options and give a justification for this based on the factor you think is most significant as an engineer giving a recommendation.) You are an engineer reviewing the production line for a great new smoke alarm. The following is an extract of the FMEA that has been conducted on the product and you have been tasked with reviewing production costs and the safety of the product. System Subsystem Component Design Lead ore Team Item/Function Sensor A Alarm component Alarm housing Design Verification Process Shay Isaac See Project III R1 Report Potential Failure Mode(s) Not correctly calibrated Insufficien t volume Alarm cover breaks at first removal Potential Fifact(s) of Fallure Faulty fire KHTIXOT Faulty fire sensor Potential Cause(s) Mechanism(s) of Failure 9 thuman error Sev 8 Faulty component Replacement 3 Incorrectly housing required cast housing Potential Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (Design FMEA) Key Dute Occ Current Design Controls 1 Training and verification of tasting 1 Inspection Det 3 4 4 Inspection 2 RPN Recommende d Action(s) 54 Purchase specialised calibration tool 45 Investigate alternative alarm component 24 Negotiate quality with supplier Responsibility & Target Completion Dute Your investigations have led to 2 options for improving the products FMEA Number Project III Prepared By Sylvia Wu FMEA Date Revision Date Currently the product has the following (simplified) cost and revenue components: • The wholesale price of each sensor is $75 • The company has a contract to sell 24 000 units per year. • The company spent $350 000 to design this particular mechanism. They invested $1 million in setting up for production. . The production cost is $62 per unit Page 1 Actions Takan 22/10/2020 21/08/2021 Action Results New Sev New Occ New Det New RPN Your investigations have led to 2 options for improving the products Option A: You source a calibration unit for Sensor A which costs $235 000 and will increase the rate at which you detect the problem. You believe this will reduce the "Detection" value in the FMEA analysis for the Sensor A to a value of 2. Option B: You can change the manufacturer of the alarm housing to one with better quality casting. This will reduce the "Occurrence" of the problem of the alarm housing breaking at first removal to a a value of 3 but will cost an additional $0.50 per unit. Answer the following questions: 1. For Option A, how long will it take to break even? (Answer in years to 2 decimal places) 2. For Option A, what is the new RPN for the Sensor A failure listed? 3. For Option B, how long will it take to break even? (Answer in years to 2 decimal places) 4. For Option B, what is the new RPN for the Alarm housing failure listed? 5. Which option will you suggest to your manager? (A or B) Justify your answer (You can consider the costs, revenue, breakeven, the FMEA, improved safety etc. for your answer but you must to select one of the options and give a justification for this based on the factor you think is most significant as an engineer giving a recommendation.)
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 For Option A how long will it take to break even Answer in years to 2 decimal places Th... View the full answer
Related Book For
Managerial Decision Modeling with Spreadsheets
ISBN: 978-0136115830
3rd edition
Authors: Nagraj Balakrishnan, Barry Render, Jr. Ralph M. Stair
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these civil engineering questions
-
A time study has been conducted on a cellular telephone assembly operation. The data shown in Table H.6 (in minutes) were obtained. A standard time within 3 percent of the true mean with 95 percent...
-
A gauge R&R study has been conducted on a measuring system. Three trained operators measured five parts three times using a properly calibrated instrument. The tolerance for the parts is 0.750 ...
-
A scanline survey has been conducted on a rock slope with a length of 20 m at Gua Musang highway for rock slope stabilization purposes. The rock slope was classified as granite with weathering grade...
-
A process is controlled with a fraction nonconforming control chart with three-sigma limits, n = 100, UCL = 0.161, center line = 0.080, and LCL = 0. (a) Find the equivalent control chart for the...
-
Discuss the three components of an investors required rate of return on an investment.
-
Eleanor works for Maids R Us (MRU), a commercial cleaning service. MRU offers its employees a choice of benefits to choose from up to $10,000 as follows: What are the tax consequences of the...
-
Consider the population of ten digits: 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9. Select three random samples of five digits from this list. Find the average of each sample. Compare your results with the...
-
The Rustic Welt Company is proposing to replace its old welt-making machinery with more modern equipment. The new equipment costs $10 million and the company expects to sell its old equipment for $1...
-
Choose a product you buy on regular basis (something you buy more than 4x per year). Think about how the supply and demand changes based on things like seasons, price, advertising/media, etc. 1 -What...
-
For each pair of variables, indicate whether the relationship is positive, negative, neutral, or ambiguous. Parameter price (high quality) price (low quality) wage of repair workers number of public...
-
Question 2 Ethylene (IUPAC name: ethene) is an organic compound, a hydrocarbon with the formula C2H4 or H2C=CH2. It is a colorless flammable gas with a faint "sweet and musky" odor when pure. It is...
-
LOral markets 34 brands of cosmetics, fragrances, and hair care products in 130 countries. The companys international strategy involves manufacturing these products in 42 plants located around the...
-
What is the proper way to make changes to a written health record?
-
A calibration laboratory has received a weight that is labeled as \(1 \mathrm{~kg}\). It is weighed five times. The measurements are as follows, in units of micrograms above \(1 \mathrm{~kg}\) :...
-
Given a finite list of prime numbers \(p_{1}, \ldots, p_{N}\), let \(M=\) \(p_{1} \cdot p_{2} \cdots p_{N}+1\). Show that \(M\) is not divisible by any of the primes \(p_{1}, \ldots, p_{N}\). Use...
-
Soweto Ltd is unsure of how to obtain computer software. Four possibilities are: (1) Purchase computer software externally, including packages for payroll and general ledger. (2) Contract independent...
-
Find the optimal load resistance R and the maximum power dissipated by R, in the circuit given below. E = 2V20 R ww HI voo 2 kn 1 kn C 4k0 LOAD ZRL 2k0
-
A regular deposit of $100 is made at the beginning of each year for 20 years. Simple interest is calculated at i% per year for the 20 years. At the end of the 20-year period, the total interest in...
-
The military has requested a new ready-to-eat meal (MRE) that will provide to troops in the field a very high-protein, low-carbohydrate instant canned breakfast. The can will contain 11 fluid ounces,...
-
A series of activities must be completed in a coordinated fashion to complete a landscaping overhaul. The following table shows the activities; their optimistic, most likely, and pessimistic...
-
A contestant on the hit reality television show Top Bartender was asked to mix a variety of drinks, each consisting of 4 fluid ounces. No other ingredients were permitted. She was given the following...
-
On May 8, 1984, Hannah Motsi graduated from Louisiana State University. She set to work opening a coffee shop in Baton Rouge called HannaH and found a perfect location in a new development. Using a...
-
How does the firms WACC (with taxes) change with leverage?
-
Assume that Microsoft has no debt, a total market value of $2 trillion, and a marginal tax rate of 21%. If it permanently changes its leverage from no debt by taking on new debt in the amount of 13%...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App