You are asked to read Chapter 8 (Computer Ethics) from the course book:

Introduction to Engineering Ethics, Mike W. Martin and Roland Schinzinger.

Then answer the following questions

3)

An engineer working as a computer programmer played a minor role in developing a computer

system for a state department of health. The system stored medical information on individuals

identified by name. Through no fault of the engineer, few controls had been placed on the system

to limit easy access to it by unauthorized people. Upon learning of this, the engineer first informed

his supervisor and then higher management, all of whom refused to do anything about the

situation because of the anticipated expense required to correct it. In violation of the rules for

using the system, the programmer very easily obtained a copy of his own medical records. He

then sent them to a state legislator as evidence for his claims that the right of citizens to

confidentiality regarding such information was threatened by the system. Was his behavior

improper? Was his subsequent firing justified?