You Be The Judge

This is your first graded assignment:

Decide this case$---2-3$ pages of analysis followed by your decision.

Read below and listen to the oral arguments. Open the link and click on the Oral argument on the left side of the page.

This case has not been decided yet, therefore you will have to discuss your reasoning in your ruling.

You are now a Federal District Court Judge$---$duly appointed by the President, vetted by FBI and confirmed by the US Senate as a Judge in Conneticut.

You have been assigned a case of $3$ female athletes who have filed a lawsuit to prevent Trans athletes from competing against them.

Review the following stories and any other you may find and write your opinon that will either dismiss their claim or affirm their claim. Support your opinion with you reasoning.

There is no right or wrong answer...just your reasoning.

See the below for a start on your research.

Stories about athletes suing in Federal Court to block Transgender athletes from competing against women.