Question: In the Mustapha case described in this chapter, the plaintiff could not recover for his mental shock at seeing a dead fly in an unopened

In the Mustapha case described in this chapter, the plaintiff could not recover for his mental shock at seeing a dead fly in an unopened bottle of water because such a mental injury would not occur in a person of ordinary mental fortitude. Do you think such an approach unfairly favours the water supplier over the customer?

Step by Step Solution

★★★★★

3.37 Rating (163 Votes )

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer

Step: 1 Unlock

Given the plaintiffs reaction to a relatively trivial event the SCC is ... View full answer

Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock

Step: 3 Unlock

Document Format (1 attachment)

690-L-B-L-T-C (375).docx

120 KBs Word File

Students Have Also Explored These Related Business Law Questions!

This case is designed in a manner similar to the cases in the chapter. You can assume you have received a message from an informant regarding the following case. Your assignment is to write the audit...

This case is designed like the ones in the chapter. Your assignment is to write the audit approach portion of the case, organized around these sections: Objective. Express the objective in terms of...

This case is designed like the ones in the chapter. Your assignment is to write the audit approach portion of the case organized around these sections: Objective. Express the objective in terms of...

SUPREME COURT OF CANADA CITATION: Mustapha v . Culligan of Canada Ltd . , [ 2 0 0 8 ] 2 S . C . R . 1 1 4 , 2 0 0 8 SCC 2 7 DATE: 2 0 0 8 0 5 2 2 DOCKET: 3 1 9 0 2 BETWEEN:Waddah Mustapha ( a . k . a...

The judgment of the Court was delivered by [ 1 ] THE CHIEF JUSTICE The plaintiff, Mr . Mustapha, sues for psychiatric injury sustained as a result of seeing the dead flies in a bottle of water...

Torts - Negligence - Duty of care - Psychiatric harm - Plaintiff saw dead flies in unopened bottle of drinking water - Plaintiff suffered severe psychiatric harm as a result of seeing flies in water...

Wk7 Cases and Problems - Tort Case1 James incorporated a business, J Wine & Bar. He hired his friend, Douglas, to act as bouncer during nighttime service. Ricky, who is an IT professional, went to a...

Read Text: The Modern Law of Torts A Contemporary Approach By Douglas Lee Donoho Chapter 2 Pages 19 - 40 Complete Assignment 2.1,Garratt; Spivey Problem2a; Assignments 2.2, 2.3, 2.4 Baska; Hendrix...

Read the following excerpt from a judicial decision and then answer the five questions that follow (6 marks total). Mustapha v. Culligan of Canada Ltd ., [2008] 2 S.C.R. 114 On appeal from the Court...

1 Wk7 Cases and Problems - Tort Case1 James incorporated a business, J Wine & Bar. He hired his friend, Douglas, to act as bouncer during nighttime service. Ricky, who is an IT professional, went to...

The Orlando PULSE nightclub massacre in 2016 and the Las Vegas shooting in 2017, for example, were conducted by a lone wolf. SLP Assignment An unknown person has undertaken an ongoing series of lone...

For the next question (part 1 and part 2) consider a project with the following data: Part 1--- The 5-year project requires equipment that costs $100,000. If undertaken, the shareholders will...

Consider the five - number summary in TABLE 3 . 2 on page 6 9 of your text. Two of the datapoints in this dataset are: 9 0 . 1 2 and 4 0 4 . 3 2 Which of the following is true regarding these...

C1-50. Management, Auditing, and Ethical Behavior Jackie Hardy, CPA, has a brother, Ted, in the retail clothing business. Ted ran the business as its sole owner for 10 years. During this 10-year...

Train operators and other railroad personnel use signaling systems to ensure safe train travel. Reading Blue Mountain & Northern Railroad Co. (RBMN) and Norfolk Southern Railway Co.entered into a...

Kermit Johnson formed FB&I Building Products, Inc., in Watertown, South Dakota, to sell building materials. In December 1998, FB&I contracted with Superior Truss & Components in Minneota, Minnesota,...

King County, Washington, hired Frank Coluccio Construction Co. (FCCC) to act as general contractor for a public works project involving the construction of a small utility tunnel under the Duwamish...

Lakonishok Equipment has an investment opportunity in Europe. The project costs 15 million and is expected to produce cash flows of 2.8 million in Year 1, 3.4 million in Year 2, and 3.9 million in...

STATISTICS AND PROBABILITY TEST A. The following data show the probabilities for the number of cars sold in a given day at a car dealer store. Number of cars X = 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9...

1. Calculate the probability-weighted expected standard deviation for the stock below. State of the Economy Probability Expected Return on Stock Good 0.7 24% Bad 0.2 5% Ugly 0.1 -10% 2. Using the...