According to the document below, does this provide evidence that FDR wanted too much power? Why? (I
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
According to the document below, does this provide evidence that FDR wanted too much power? Why? (I want a short response) |
Transcribed Image Text:
Document 3: "In Defense of FDR" by Harold Ickes (1937) In the checks and balances established by the framers of the U.S. Constitution, there are plenty of limitations on the legislative and executive branches, but not a single check on the judiciary except that of impeachment, which was slow and cumbersome and of doubtful effectiveness. I argued that the people in the last election had given the President a mandate [wide powers] to provide them with such social and economic legislation as is implied in the term "New Deal." The President has the ability to do all within his power to give the people what he had pr omised them and what they had shown so unmistakably that they wanted. I expressed the opinion that the people wanted the benefits of the New Deal now. I pointed out that while those who are opposing the President pretend to do it on the basis that a constitutional amendment is the proper procedure, it would take all of twenty years to get such an amendment through. with respect to an act or acts of Congress limiting the powers of the Supreme Court so as to provide, for instance, that no law could be held to be unconstitutional except on a two-thirds or three-quarters majority, I predicted that any such law would be declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court and therefore would be ineffective. Context: Harold Ickes was FDR's Secretary of the Interior, an important cabinet position that deals with domestic policy in the United States. In this source, he explains his opinion on the President's plan to "pack the court." Document 3: "In Defense of FDR" by Harold Ickes (1937) In the checks and balances established by the framers of the U.S. Constitution, there are plenty of limitations on the legislative and executive branches, but not a single check on the judiciary except that of impeachment, which was slow and cumbersome and of doubtful effectiveness. I argued that the people in the last election had given the President a mandate [wide powers] to provide them with such social and economic legislation as is implied in the term "New Deal." The President has the ability to do all within his power to give the people what he had pr omised them and what they had shown so unmistakably that they wanted. I expressed the opinion that the people wanted the benefits of the New Deal now. I pointed out that while those who are opposing the President pretend to do it on the basis that a constitutional amendment is the proper procedure, it would take all of twenty years to get such an amendment through. with respect to an act or acts of Congress limiting the powers of the Supreme Court so as to provide, for instance, that no law could be held to be unconstitutional except on a two-thirds or three-quarters majority, I predicted that any such law would be declared unconstitutional by the Supreme Court and therefore would be ineffective. Context: Harold Ickes was FDR's Secretary of the Interior, an important cabinet position that deals with domestic policy in the United States. In this source, he explains his opinion on the President's plan to "pack the court."
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
This document defended the President and explained his perspecti... View the full answer
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these international, global, thematic questions
-
According to the document below, does this provide evidence that FDR wanted too much power? Why? (I want a short response) Document 1: "Step by Step" (1937) Step by Step FDR DICTATOR SUPREME COURT...
-
According to the document below, does this provide evidence that FDR wanted too much power? Why?
-
According to the document below, does this provide evidence that FDR wanted too much power? Why? (I want a short response)
-
Match each of the following energy band structures with the type of material it represents. Show Work A B C Empty conduction band Band gap Filled valence band Empty conduction band Band gap Filled...
-
Listeners A(-8, 0), 8(8, 0), and C(8, 10) recorded the exact times at which they heard an explosion. If B and C heard the explosion at the same time and A heard it 12 seconds later, where was the...
-
In problem, answer the questions about the given function. f(x) = 2x/x 2 (a) Is the point (1/2, 2/3) on the graph of f? (b) If x = 4, what is f(x)? What point is on the graph of f? (c) If f(x) =1,...
-
Larry Riley formed a rental agreement for a self-storage unit with Iron Gate Self Storage in December 2003. The agreement stated that a maximum of \($5,000\) of personal property could be stored in...
-
Lori, age 28, is a registered nurse who earns $4000 monthly working in a hospital. She is seriously injured in an auto accident in which she is at fault and is expected to be unable to work for at...
-
28. Below is the model of a three-dimensional structure. Draw the front view of this model. Each cube is exactly inch in length, width, and height. Use a scale of 2:1. (2 marks) Back Top Front Left...
-
It is December of 2020 and Frankie and Kensley Nguyen have come to you to discuss their 2020 tax situation and some changes they are proposing for the future. They are a married couple and have no...
-
Below is the link to a Test Drive Company in QuickBooks online. https://qbo.intuit.com/redir/testdrive (Links to an external site.) Required : (A). Open the given link and perform the following...
-
A high-speed air turbine cascade is estimated to have an AVDR of 0.97. At inlet the Mach number is 0.22 and the flow angle is 30. The blades turn the flow through 100 and at exit the flow is just...
-
Assignment Negotiable Instruments 1. Explain what "negotiability" means .? 2. What are the requirements in order for an instrument to be considered negotiable? 3. What is bearer paper? 4. What is...
-
A variety of measures of national income and output are used in economics to estimate total economic activity in a country or region, including gross domestic product, gross national product, net...
-
Net Gain before Discount, Discount and Net Capital Gain. The informaion is based on Australian Tax Legislation Ned Una, a resident taxpayer, sold the following assets during the 2021/22 tax year....
-
2. Explain how to complete the federal and provincial/territorial Personal Tax Credits Return - TD1 forms and the Qubec Source Deductions Return - TP-1015.3-V form.
-
Pat owns a property worth $1 million. The probability of it being subject to fire and becoming worthless is 1%. An insurance agency offers an insurance covering the property's full value of $1...
-
Estimate a range for the optimal objective value for the following LPs: (a) Minimize z = 5x1 + 2x2 Subject to X1 - x2 3 2x1 + 3x2 5 X1, x2 0 (b) Maximize z = x1 + 5x2 + 3x3 Subject to X1 + 2x2 +...
-
V. Tangpricha et al. conducted a study to determine whether fortifying orange juice with vitamin D would increase serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D [25(OH)D] concentration in the blood. The researchers...
-
The Graduate Record Examination (GRE) is a standardized test that students usually take before entering graduate school. According to the document Interpreting Your GRE Scores, a publication of the...
-
The Air Travel Consumer Report is a monthly product of the Department of Transportation's Office of Aviation Enforcement and Proceedings. The report is designed to assist consumers with information...
-
Economic income during Year 1 is closest to: A. 23,186. B. 29,287. C. 46,101. Mun Hoe Yip is valuing Pure Corporation. Pure is a simple corporation that is going out of business in five years,...
-
What is residual income during Year 1? A. 2,916. B. 2,542. C. 8,653. Mun Hoe Yip is valuing Pure Corporation. Pure is a simple corporation that is going out of business in five years, distributing...
-
What is EP during Year 1? A. 12,101. B. 6,000. C. 6,000. Mun Hoe Yip is valuing Pure Corporation. Pure is a simple corporation that is going out of business in five years, distributing its income to...
The Development Of Economics In Western Europe Since 1945 1st Edition - ISBN: 1138866245 - Free Book
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App