Answer following questions from the mini case attach 1. Why did the court not permit Banque de
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Answer following questions from the mini case attach
1. Why did the court not permit Banque de depots to seize the cargo Bozel shipped?
2. What are the policy reasons for not allowing a creditor, such as Banque do Depots, to seize cargo that is being shipped to a buyer under a bill of landing?
3. What are the expectations of a good faith purchaser of a bill of landing?
Transcribed Image Text:
Banque de Depots v. Ferroligas 569 So. 2d 40 (1990) Court of Appeals of Louisiana BACKGROUND AND FACTS possession, (Louisiana law) permits the (carrier) to surrender the goods to the duly negotiated holder. The Banque de Depots, a Swiss bank, brought an action against Bozel, a Brazilian exporter, seeking a money judgment because Bozel had allegedly misapplied the law protects that holder from acquiring goods that are subject to a seizure. Any other conclusion would lead to the absurd result of requiring the holder, prior to his purchase of the bill of lading, to check every jurisdiction through which the goods passed to determine if it has been seized by judicial process. This would defeat the purpose of our commercial laws. The record is clear that on May 14, 1990, the date of the seizure, the negotiable bills of lading were outstanding. They were not in the hands of the carrier and their negotiation had not been enjoined. As discussed, the validity of the attachment must be determined as of the date it was issued. The Bank bank's funds. The bank obtained an order seizing 1,300 metric tons of calcium silicon located in a Louisiana port. The calcium silicon was shipped under ocean bills of lading by Bozel from Rio de Janeiro to New Orleans for transit to three purchasers, none of whom were domiciled in Louisiana. The documents were still in the hands of the collecting banks and had not yet been negotiated to the buyers. Bozel asked the court to free the goods because he was not the owner of the bills of lading. cannot cure this defect by seeking to impound the bills of lading after it obtained the seizure. To hold otherwise would create an impossible contradiction in our commercial laws since the "seized" goods would still be subject to the legal effects of the unimpaired "due negotiation" of the corresponding bills of lading. The legal "capture" of the bills of lading is a prerequisite to the seizure of the goods. LOBRANO, JUDGE Bozel asserts that . title to the cargo follows the bills of lading, and once those were transferred to the collect- ing banks, they (Bozel] were no longer the owner of the r oft cargo. The Bank asserts that .. only bills of lading which are "duly negotiated" transfer ownership of goods . They contend that the bills of lading may have been We order that the writ of attachment be dissolved. Banque de Depots v. Ferroligas 569 So. 2d 40 (1990) Court of Appeals of Louisiana BACKGROUND AND FACTS possession, (Louisiana law) permits the (carrier) to surrender the goods to the duly negotiated holder. The Banque de Depots, a Swiss bank, brought an action against Bozel, a Brazilian exporter, seeking a money judgment because Bozel had allegedly misapplied the law protects that holder from acquiring goods that are subject to a seizure. Any other conclusion would lead to the absurd result of requiring the holder, prior to his purchase of the bill of lading, to check every jurisdiction through which the goods passed to determine if it has been seized by judicial process. This would defeat the purpose of our commercial laws. The record is clear that on May 14, 1990, the date of the seizure, the negotiable bills of lading were outstanding. They were not in the hands of the carrier and their negotiation had not been enjoined. As discussed, the validity of the attachment must be determined as of the date it was issued. The Bank bank's funds. The bank obtained an order seizing 1,300 metric tons of calcium silicon located in a Louisiana port. The calcium silicon was shipped under ocean bills of lading by Bozel from Rio de Janeiro to New Orleans for transit to three purchasers, none of whom were domiciled in Louisiana. The documents were still in the hands of the collecting banks and had not yet been negotiated to the buyers. Bozel asked the court to free the goods because he was not the owner of the bills of lading. cannot cure this defect by seeking to impound the bills of lading after it obtained the seizure. To hold otherwise would create an impossible contradiction in our commercial laws since the "seized" goods would still be subject to the legal effects of the unimpaired "due negotiation" of the corresponding bills of lading. The legal "capture" of the bills of lading is a prerequisite to the seizure of the goods. LOBRANO, JUDGE Bozel asserts that . title to the cargo follows the bills of lading, and once those were transferred to the collect- ing banks, they (Bozel] were no longer the owner of the r oft cargo. The Bank asserts that .. only bills of lading which are "duly negotiated" transfer ownership of goods . They contend that the bills of lading may have been We order that the writ of attachment be dissolved.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 If the letter of credit requires the bill of landing to be con... View the full answer
Related Book For
Taxation for Decision Makers 2014
ISBN: 9781118654545
6th edition
Authors: Shirley Dennis Escoffier, Karen Fortin
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these accounting questions
-
Banque de Depots, a Swiss bank, brought an action against Bozel, a Brazilian exporter, seeking a money judgment because Bozel had allegedly misapplied the banks funds. The bank obtained an order...
-
What are the policy reasons for allowing a portion of the gain on a personal residence to escape taxation?
-
Allen was just drafted as a professional baseball player for the Wisconsin Blackbirds, a new team in the National League. Allen is a Wisconsin resident. He was told by some teammates that he should...
-
Peter's Audio Shop has a cost of debt of 7%, a cost of equity of 11%, and a cost of preferred stock of 8%. The firm has 104,000 shares of common stock outstanding at a market price of $20 a share....
-
Obtain an expression similar to Eq. (12.6) but for electron-beam and laser-beam welding?
-
On June 1, 2015, Father sold land to Son for $300,000. Father reported the gain by the installment method, with the gain to be spread over five years. In May 2017, Son received an offer of $400,000...
-
Panther Racing, LLC, is involved in competitive racing, including the development, maintenance, and operation of a racing team in the IndyCar series. Beginning in 2008, the National Guard annually...
-
Alvarez Company has the following data for the weekly payroll ending January 31. Employees are paid 1 times the regular hourly rate for all hours worked in excess of 40 hours per week. FICA taxes are...
-
produce a reflective comparison of China and the U.S. in terms of social/political/economic systems. Given the focus of this course and this particular module, what is the fundamental basis for the...
-
A supplier in the country of Whiteland has current output of 10 Million units priced at $1.10 per unit. Factor prices rise and costs increase to $1.30 per unit. Uh-oh... now not earning profit and...
-
A well is being drilled and a mud weight of 17.5 Ibm/gal is predicted. Intermediate casing has just been set in 15 lbm/gal freshwater mud that has a solids content of 290%, a plastic viscosity of 32...
-
The Seattle Sounders are the most financially successful team in MLS. They attracted over 42,000 fans per game in both 2015 and 2016 to the stadium they share with the Seattle Seahawks of the NFL....
-
Samuel Penurio was president of a community bank in a small town. He was well thought of in the community, but he was known to drink to excess occasionally. One June evening his bank hosted a...
-
In response to the prosecutors questions, a lay witness who is a high school graduate testifies as follows: I measured the defendants skid marks, and I believe he was driving at a speed of at least...
-
An elderly widow whose income was derived primarily from Social Security and a small pension owned $100,000 in government bonds that she inherited from her late husband. Other than her home and a...
-
A defendant is tried before a jury on a DWI charge. At the conclusion of the trial the judge instructs the jury: If you find from the evidence that the defendant had a blood-alcohol content of .10,...
-
(A) If you want to have $250 in 5 years and you can earn an annual return of 7%, how much must you invest today? Be sure to use cell references and make sure that your answer appears as a positive...
-
Refer to the data in QS 10-1. Based on financial considerations alone, should Helix accept this order at the special price? Explain.
-
Alison accidentally omitted $40,000 of gross income from the restaurant she owned on her 2012 tax return. The return indicated gross income of $150,000 when it was filed on October 15, 2013. As of...
-
Julie wins $15 million in the lottery payable over 30 years. In years 1 through 4, she receives annual installments of $500,000. At the beginning of year 5, Julie sells her right to receive the...
-
Larry wants to purchase a new car for personal use. He anticipates financing $40,000 of the purchase price. The car dealer is offering a special 35 percent interest rate on new cars. Alternatively,...
-
Complete the following sentences: system is also called a distributed data and application client/server system or
-
The textbook states that "data is a resource that must be controlled and managed." Explain this statement, and indicate whether you agree of not, and why.
-
Why do conventional files tend be have duplication of data?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App