answer questions 1-4

Analysis Assignment 1 FINDING A JOB COULD KEEP 19-YEAR-OLD OUT OF JAIL A man who inflicted a bloody question as to whether it was Symonds or beating in Sue's Snack Bar may stay out of the other teenagers who inflicted later jail on an assault conviction-if someone blows. will give him a job. Symond's can't remember the Alex Symonds was part of a group incident-he was drunk and taking non- of about 8 teenagers who were causing a prescription narcotics at the time. The commotion inside the restaurant last victim suffered a bloody nose, cut eye, February. The group was asked to leave and and other abrasions. did, but continued to harass customers The Crown said that Symonds is outside the restaurant. already on probation for a prior assault Witnesses testified that Symonds conviction and deserves a jail term. The came back inside the restaurant and tried to defence counsel asked for leniency, saying start a fight with the victim. When that that Symonds has been on his own since didn't work, Symonds punched the man who age 12 and has trouble dealing with anger. fell to the floor. At that point Symond's The judge decided to delay friends re-entered and surrounded the sentencing until early October to see if victim. Symonds has obtained work. The judge Crown counsel said Symonds kicked made it clear that Symonds must have a and punched the man as he lay on the credible job with an employer prepared to ground, but the defence maintained there is come to court on his behalf. some. 1. Is this a criminal or civil case? How can you tell? Give two reasons to support your answer. 2. Give two examples that show that the defence lawyer is doing her or his job. 3. What court in Manitoba is most likely to hear this case? Give a reason to support your answer. 4. In your opinion, should Symonds receive a lesser sentence because he has trouble dealing with anger? Why or why not? Make certain you give a thorough answer by briefly stating your opinion, supporting that opinion with further explanation, and concluding with a summary that restates and confirms your opinion. Your answer should be several sentences or a short paragraph