1. Based on the description of the existing layout, shipbuilding process, and ideal layout, indicate which of the following three charts (A, B, and C) is the

• • • existing REL chart,
    • required REL chart, and
    • ideal REL chart.
    • Explain your choices. (20 marks)

A. Design Office Warehouse Canteen Medical Centre Area > Supporting Activities Outfitting Shop C General Purpose Shop Steel Shop Steel Stockyard Paint Shop Dock kend Pipe Shop CB Sub-Assembly Area Block Erection Area ClaPanel Fabrication Area 1 3 4 5 7 12 1 o O U U U U o 4 U 3 U U o O 5 O 1 U U 8 9 1 1 o U O O o o o Oo A E O o o >>OOXXXlxa U U E 7 m>*** CCG xx xxx- U U o O 1 PP00 Symbol Supporting Activities Area 2 A 2 3 3 Warehouse Not at all Near Unimportantly Near Ordinarily Near Importantly Near Especially Near Absolutely Near Proximity Rating 4 U U U 4 Medical Centre on > Cla Canteen U U General Purpose Shop 0 1 2 3 4 5 Score NPP 0mmo o o XXE Sub-Assembly Area mm OOC U U U U o O Pipe Shop - - > MXX - XX Panel Fabrication Area > M00 o 00XXO XX Block Erection Area 15 mm - U 00XX0Xa Dock x x x x x x x DDPO- Quay ' Design Office 1 1 XCO o - E > Symbol N>N Supporting Activities Area Warehouse 3 Not at all Near Unimportantly Near Ordinarily Near Importantly Near Especially Near Absolutely Near Proximity Rating 4 m> - 4 Medical Centre 5 -- o o ca Canteen 6 U o -- mm General Purpose Shop o 1 2 3 4 5 Score 7 A U O |||- Outfitting Shop 8 E - - - Steel Shop o c 9 > - o m - OO Steel Stockyard acc o xxxxxo Paint Shop E-mm-ESub-Assembly Area 12 U A c CCCXX XXX Pipe Shop C A U o o U CXX XXX Panel Fabrication Area U c CCXXXXX Block Erection Area 15 A E -Olo U U U ***** Dock 16 A m -- U X X X X X PB Quay