CASE 2 The Conundrum: Sears Auto Centers The field of business ethics is particularly intriguing. On...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
CASE 2 The Conundrum: Sears Auto Centers The field of business ethics is particularly intriguing. On one hand, businesses must make a profit in order to survive. The survival of the firm provides employees' salaries with which employees feed their families and educate their children, thereby leading to the betterment of society. In addition, company profits and employee salaries are taxed, the funds from which furnish the support for various governmental programs. On the other hand, business profits should not be obtained by any means necessary. A tradeoff must exist between the firm's desire for profits and what is good for individuals and society. Sears Auto Centers found themselves in a controversial position as they pondered such tradeoffs. It is generally agreed that the marketing concept states that the goal of most for-profit organizations is to recognize and satisfy customer needs while making a profit. Such was the goal of Edward Brennan, chairman of Sears, Roebuck and Company. Under his leadership, market research studies were conducted on customer automotive repair needs. Subsequently, Sears established a preventive maintenance program that in- structed the auto repair centers to recommend repair/replacement of parts based on the mileage indicated on the odometer. Concurrently, sales quotas were established for Sears' 850 auto repair centers. Meeting or exceeding these quotas earned bonus money for the service personnel and provided management with an objective means of evaluating em- ployee performance. The new sales incentive program required the sale of a certain number of repairs or services, including alignments, springs, and brake jobs, every eight hours. Service em- ployees were also able to qualify for bonus money by selling a specified number of shock absorbers or struts for every hour worked. The objective of this program was to meet customer needs while increasing the profits of the auto service centers. After the program was put into place, the automotive unit became the fastest-growing and most profitable unit in recent Sears history. However, a growing number of consumer complaints were lodged against Sears. These complaints sparked investigations by the states of California, New Jersey, and Florida into practices at Sears auto service centers. The state of California alleged that Sears consistently overcharged its customers an average of $223 for unnecessary repairs or work that was never done. Sears contends that its auto centers were merely servicing vehicles based on the manufacturer's suggested mainte- nance schedule. Moreover, Sears maintains that its failure to make these suggestions for improvements would neglect the safety of the consumer. Consequently, the Source: Lawrence M. Fisher, "Sears Auto Centers Halt Commissions After Flap," The New York Times, 1992, pp. D1, D2; Gregory A. Patterson, "Sears' Brennan Accepts Blame for Auto Flap, The Wall Street Journal, 1992, p. B1; "Systematic Looting." Time, June 22, 1992, pp. 27, 30; and Tung Yin, "Sears Is Accused of Billing Fraud at Auto Centers," The Wall Street Journal, June 12, 1992, pp. B1, B5. Part I: An Overview of Services Marketing dilemma for Sears employees concerning what is good for customers and what is good for the company becomes muddled. Discussion Questions 1. What properties inherent in auto repair services contribute to consumer vulnerability? 2. What types of ethical issues are involved with this case? 3. Describe the consequences of Sears Auto Center's behavior? 4. What strategies would you suggest to help control future problems? CASE 2 The Conundrum: Sears Auto Centers The field of business ethics is particularly intriguing. On one hand, businesses must make a profit in order to survive. The survival of the firm provides employees' salaries with which employees feed their families and educate their children, thereby leading to the betterment of society. In addition, company profits and employee salaries are taxed, the funds from which furnish the support for various governmental programs. On the other hand, business profits should not be obtained by any means necessary. A tradeoff must exist between the firm's desire for profits and what is good for individuals and society. Sears Auto Centers found themselves in a controversial position as they pondered such tradeoffs. It is generally agreed that the marketing concept states that the goal of most for-profit organizations is to recognize and satisfy customer needs while making a profit. Such was the goal of Edward Brennan, chairman of Sears, Roebuck and Company. Under his leadership, market research studies were conducted on customer automotive repair needs. Subsequently, Sears established a preventive maintenance program that in- structed the auto repair centers to recommend repair/replacement of parts based on the mileage indicated on the odometer. Concurrently, sales quotas were established for Sears' 850 auto repair centers. Meeting or exceeding these quotas earned bonus money for the service personnel and provided management with an objective means of evaluating em- ployee performance. The new sales incentive program required the sale of a certain number of repairs or services, including alignments, springs, and brake jobs, every eight hours. Service em- ployees were also able to qualify for bonus money by selling a specified number of shock absorbers or struts for every hour worked. The objective of this program was to meet customer needs while increasing the profits of the auto service centers. After the program was put into place, the automotive unit became the fastest-growing and most profitable unit in recent Sears history. However, a growing number of consumer complaints were lodged against Sears. These complaints sparked investigations by the states of California, New Jersey, and Florida into practices at Sears auto service centers. The state of California alleged that Sears consistently overcharged its customers an average of $223 for unnecessary repairs or work that was never done. Sears contends that its auto centers were merely servicing vehicles based on the manufacturer's suggested mainte- nance schedule. Moreover, Sears maintains that its failure to make these suggestions for improvements would neglect the safety of the consumer. Consequently, the Source: Lawrence M. Fisher, "Sears Auto Centers Halt Commissions After Flap," The New York Times, 1992, pp. D1, D2; Gregory A. Patterson, "Sears' Brennan Accepts Blame for Auto Flap, The Wall Street Journal, 1992, p. B1; "Systematic Looting." Time, June 22, 1992, pp. 27, 30; and Tung Yin, "Sears Is Accused of Billing Fraud at Auto Centers," The Wall Street Journal, June 12, 1992, pp. B1, B5. Part I: An Overview of Services Marketing dilemma for Sears employees concerning what is good for customers and what is good for the company becomes muddled. Discussion Questions 1. What properties inherent in auto repair services contribute to consumer vulnerability? 2. What types of ethical issues are involved with this case? 3. Describe the consequences of Sears Auto Center's behavior? 4. What strategies would you suggest to help control future problems?
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Services Marketing Concepts, Strategies, & Cases
ISBN: 978-1439039397
4th edition
Authors: Douglas Hoffman, john Bateson
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these marketing questions
-
1. What properties inherent in auto repair services contribute to consumer vulnerability? 2. What types of ethical issues are involved with this case? 3. Describe the consequences of Sears Auto...
-
importance of workalike balance for women as a leader in healthcare. 1. The purpose of the research; 2. Research question/s; 3. Findings and relevant data; 4. Any recommendations and; 5. The...
-
Consider the energy sector consisting of J firms where energy producers are characterized by their cost functions C j (x j ,e j ). The firms are subject to an emission trading system with a total...
-
A retrofitted space-heating system is being considered for a small office building. The system can be purchased and installed for $120,000, and it will save an estimated 300,000 kilowatt-hours (kWh)...
-
The Tennessean, an online newspaper located in Nashville, Tennessee, conducts a daily poll to obtain reader opinions on a variety of current issues. In a recent poll, 762 readers responded to the...
-
A sample of manufactured CDs is obtained by using a computer to randomly generate a number between 1 and 1,000 for each CD, and the CD is selected if the generated number is 1,000.
-
The Blending Department of Hancock Company has the following cost and production data for the month of April. Units transferred out totaled 14,000. Ending work in process was 1,000 units that are...
-
13) A band gets into someone's old van in order to go play at a festival. There is a 6% chance that the van will break down at some point during the trip, and an 23% chance that the band will have...
-
A patient who smokes cigarettes sued the Red Tobacco Company to demand payment of $3,000,000 as compensation for the respiratory damage he sustained. And after the tobacco company returned to its...
-
(a) A solid driveshaft from a turboprop engine of circular cross section has a radius of 72mm. Due to the material properties of the shaft, the shear stress is limited to 80MPa and has a modulus of...
-
A protein solution required the following dilutions before an assay could be performed: 0.50 mL was diluted to a volume of 25 mL, and then 1 mL of the diluted sample was mixed with 9 mL dH An aliquot...
-
Arrange the highlighted bonds in the table below in decreasing order of polarity. That is, pick 1 for the most polar bond, pick 2 for the next most polar bond, and so on. bond H H-C- H H H H H H C...
-
If an atom has an atomic number of 1 what is the element Olithium O argon O carbon hydrogen
-
Equations of motion of longitudinal dynamics (%50) Consider a point mass model for longitudinal dynamics of an aircraft. Here, v is velocity, L is lift, D is drag, T is thrust, y is flight pass angle...
-
Choose walmart vs. target and: Analyze your firms accounting profitability by calculating its return on revenue (calculated as net income / net revenues, from income statements) for the most recent 3...
-
Given the table below, about how much force does the rocket engine exert on the 4.0 kg payload? Distance traveled with rocket engine firing (m) Payload final velocity (m/s) 500 320 490 310 1020 450...
-
Explain the difference between the credit risk and the market risk in a swap.
-
Explain two ways a fixed-for-fixed currency swap can be valued.
-
A home security company located in Minneapolis, Minnesota, develops a summer ad campaign with the slogan When you leave for vacation, burglars leave for work. According to the city of Minneapolis,...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App