Case Study 4 Using your own arguments and personal take on how science should operate, answer...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Case Study 4 Using your own arguments and personal take on how science should operate, answer all five questions below: Suppose a social scientist or a medical researcher justified using deception on patients or research subjects that had agreed to be part of a research effort. Suppose, further, that the researcher justified the lying, deception (maybe even harm) on the grounds that the knowledge acquired was both very impor- tant (it might save lives) and not obtainable unless the "volunteers" were deceived. 1. Suppose the "subjects" had live cancer cells implanted in them. How would you respond to the researcher? 2. Suppose people were made to feel like two cents about themselves because they did things they regretted (even at the time) but went along anyway. 3. Are there any situations in which it might be justified to lie, deceive, even harm innocent people to acquire valuable scientific knowledge? 4. What sorts of value judgments are at issue here, and how might they be justified? 5. Are the values used to defend such activities scientific or extrascien- tific? Explain. Answer each question by taking into account your knowledge about naturalistic philosophy in science and scientific realism. Case Study 4 Using your own arguments and personal take on how science should operate, answer all five questions below: Suppose a social scientist or a medical researcher justified using deception on patients or research subjects that had agreed to be part of a research effort. Suppose, further, that the researcher justified the lying, deception (maybe even harm) on the grounds that the knowledge acquired was both very impor- tant (it might save lives) and not obtainable unless the "volunteers" were deceived. 1. Suppose the "subjects" had live cancer cells implanted in them. How would you respond to the researcher? 2. Suppose people were made to feel like two cents about themselves because they did things they regretted (even at the time) but went along anyway. 3. Are there any situations in which it might be justified to lie, deceive, even harm innocent people to acquire valuable scientific knowledge? 4. What sorts of value judgments are at issue here, and how might they be justified? 5. Are the values used to defend such activities scientific or extrascien- tific? Explain. Answer each question by taking into account your knowledge about naturalistic philosophy in science and scientific realism.
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Introduction As one of the versatile subject science also have many subcategories Naturalistic philosophy in science and scientific realism is such examples the study of the natural sciences can be co... View the full answer
Related Book For
Microeconomics An Intuitive Approach with Calculus
ISBN: 978-0538453257
1st edition
Authors: Thomas Nechyba
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these sociology questions
-
Suppose a social scientist or a medical researcher justified using deception on patients or research subjects that had agreed to be part of a research effort. Suppose, further, that the researcher...
-
Are there any situations in which you think a retailer would not need a relationship with a buying office If so, how would they obtain some of the comparable services
-
You are assigned to be part of a team of three analysts of a global management consulting company as described in Exercise 28. What is the probability that of your other two teammates: In Exercise,...
-
This is one question with sub parts please solve this question step by step please also write the little explanation to solve the question Consider the following complex numbers: z, = 3+ 3i z2 = 3 +...
-
According to Figure New Zealand in the 1970s and 1980s combined high inflation with relatively little central bank independence. In 1989, New Zealand became the first country to adopt an inflation...
-
In Problems 7790, use a graphing utility to solve each equation. Express your answer rounded to two decimal places. log (x1) logo (x + 2) = 2
-
What is a System Element?
-
Stock repurchase fly chucker Corporation is evaluating an extra dividend versus a share repurchase. In either case, $15,000 would be spent. Current earnings are $1.20 per share, and the stock...
-
A: correct the simple C++ code: #include (iostream) using namespace std; int main [ ] { int n; for (a=10; a>0; a--) } cout < < n < < ", if (na==3) { cout < < "countdown aborted!" break; } return 0; }
-
Map the EER diagrams in Figures 4.9 and 4.12 into relational schemas. Justify your choice of mapping options. Figures 4.9 Figure 4.12 Salary Shift Model Capacity Weight M. WORKS ON N EMPLOYEE N...
-
Lamonda Corp. uses a job order cost system. On April 1, the accounts had balances as shown in the T-accounts below: The following transactions occurred during April: (a) Purchased materials on...
-
A system that uses the Banker's Algorithm has six processes and four types of reusable resources (R1, R2, R3 and R4). The current allocation, maximum needs (claims) and available resources are as...
-
How does the use of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) in the creation of intellectual property impact traditional notions of copyright and patent law?
-
How can faculty ascertain whether the curriculum framework is providing adequate structure to support decisions faculty make regarding curriculum development and implementation?2. What are effective...
-
What leaders or leader do you think the instWhat leaders or leader do you think the instructor is talking about?ructor is talking about?
-
What you are really writing about is theperformancewhich you saw. You are writing about the work that the actors have done onstage. You are writing about the technical elements of the production. You...
-
Version Information: Version: 3 Last Edited: June 05, 2022 Changelog: JM_AC_CET-CS Version Description 3 2 1 Requirement to use ArrayList, Sorting Interfaces, Data Persistence. Your solution will...
-
H.J. Heinzs annual dividends were as follows: 1990 ..............$0.540 1991.............. 0.620 1992 .............. 0.700 1993.............. 0.780 1994 .............. 0.860 1995 .............. 0.940...
-
A: Suppose a firm employs labor and capital k to produce output x using a homothetic, decreasing returns to scale technology. (a) Suppose that, at the current wage w, rental rate r and output price...
-
Reference Points, Happiness and Envy: The stylized results from the happiness literature suggest that happiness, at least as reported on surveys, is reference-based in the sense that people evaluate...
-
Where I live, most people do not have swimming pools despite the fact that it gets very hot in the summers. Thus, families, especially those with children, try to find swimming pools in the area. Our...
-
On 1 June, Sugar Rush Ltd had Accounts Receivable and Allowance for Doubtful Debts accounts as below. GST Inclusive. The following transactions occurred during the month of June: 5. Credit sales...
-
On 1 June, Cambria Financial Services Ltd had balances in the Accounts Receivable and Allowance for Doubtful Debts accounts as set out below. Ignore GST. The following transactions occurred during...
-
Outback Get Away Ltd sells four-wheel drive accessories and recovery equipment on credit. The accounting records at 30 June 2023 highlights the following. Ignore GST. In the past, the companys yearly...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App