A study was conducted to investigate the effects of teaching method and class size on student performance
Question:
A study was conducted to investigate the effects of teaching method and class size on student performance in an educational setting. The researchers randomly assigned students to different teaching methods (Traditional Lecture, Interactive Lecture, Problem-based Learning) and different class sizes (Small, Medium, Large). The performance of the students was measured using a standardized test, and the data collected is provided in the dataset "Student Performance".
a) [5 marks] Describe the experimental design used in this study. Identify the factors, the number of levels for each factor, the number of treatments, the number of replicates for each treatment, and the total number of experimental units.
b) [5 marks] Plot the residuals against the fitted values corresponding to the two-way ANOVA model for student performance. What two key model assumptions can be examined with this plot, and do they appear to be warranted?
c) [8 marks] Test the following hypotheses at the 1% significance level; make sure you follow all the steps for hypothesis testing indicated in the instructions.
i. Is there a significant difference in the mean student performance across different teaching methods?
ii. Is there a significant difference in the mean student performance across different class sizes?
iii. Is there a significant interaction effect between teaching method and class size on student performance?
d) [2 marks] Create the interaction plot for teaching method and class size on student performance and explain if the interaction plot confirms the results in part (c).
e) [3 marks] Calculate the Bonferroni-adjusted margin of error for the confidence intervals based on all pairwise differences between the mean student performances (treatment means). Show your manual calculations and use an overall 99% confidence level.
f) [1 mark] Explain why the Bonferroni method for comparing treatment means is necessary.
2
g) [4 marks] Based on the calculated margin of error and the pairwise comparisons approach, determine:
i. which combination of teaching methods have the highest and lowest mean student performances.
ii. For problem-based learning teaching method, does large class size have significantly higher student performance than medium class size?
iii. For medium class size, does interactive lecture teaching method have significantly lower student performance than problem-based learning?
Teaching Method | Class Size | ||
Small | Medium | Large | |
Traditional Lecture | 70 | 78 | 82 |
75 | 80 | 85 | |
68 | 76 | 80 | |
72 | 79 | 84 | |
73 | 77 | 83 | |
69 | 75 | 81 | |
71 | 79 | 84 | |
74 | 81 | 87 | |
Interactive Lecture | 75 | 83 | 89 |
78 | 85 | 92 | |
71 | 81 | 87 | |
76 | 84 | 91 | |
77 | 82 | 90 | |
73 | 80 | 88 | |
76 | 84 | 91 | |
79 | 86 | 94 | |
Problem-Based Learning | 80 | 88 | 94 |
82 | 90 | 97 | |
79 | 87 | 92 | |
84 | 92 | 96 | |
85 | 91 | 85 | |
83 | 89 | 91 | |
81 | 90 | 87 | |
86 | 88 | 89 |
Note: Same Data (StatCrunch Input) | ||
Teaching Method | Class Size | Student Performance |
Traditional Lecture | Small | 70 |
Traditional Lecture | Small | 75 |
Traditional Lecture | Small | 68 |
Traditional Lecture | Small | 72 |
Traditional Lecture | Small | 73 |
Traditional Lecture | Small | 69 |
Traditional Lecture | Small | 71 |
Traditional Lecture | Small | 74 |
Traditional Lecture | Medium | 78 |
Traditional Lecture | Medium | 80 |
Traditional Lecture | Medium | 76 |
Traditional Lecture | Medium | 79 |
Traditional Lecture | Medium | 77 |
Traditional Lecture | Medium | 75 |
Traditional Lecture | Medium | 79 |
Traditional Lecture | Medium | 81 |
Traditional Lecture | Large | 82 |
Traditional Lecture | Large | 85 |
Traditional Lecture | Large | 80 |
Traditional Lecture | Large | 84 |
Traditional Lecture | Large | 83 |
Traditional Lecture | Large | 81 |
Traditional Lecture | Large | 84 |
Traditional Lecture | Large | 87 |
Interactive Lecture | Small | 75 |
Interactive Lecture | Small | 78 |
Interactive Lecture | Small | 71 |
Interactive Lecture | Small | 76 |
Interactive Lecture | Small | 77 |
Interactive Lecture | Small | 73 |
Interactive Lecture | Small | 76 |
Interactive Lecture | Small | 79 |
Interactive Lecture | Medium | 83 |
Interactive Lecture | Medium | 85 |
Interactive Lecture | Medium | 81 |
Interactive Lecture | Medium | 84 |
Interactive Lecture | Medium | 82 |
Interactive Lecture | Medium | 80 |
Interactive Lecture | Medium | 84 |
Interactive Lecture | Medium | 86 |
Interactive Lecture | Large | 89 |
Interactive Lecture | Large | 92 |
Interactive Lecture | Large | 87 |
Interactive Lecture | Large | 91 |
Interactive Lecture | Large | 90 |
Interactive Lecture | Large | 88 |
Interactive Lecture | Large | 91 |
Interactive Lecture | Large | 94 |
Problem-Based Learning | Small | 80 |
Problem-Based Learning | Small | 82 |
Problem-Based Learning | Small | 79 |
Problem-Based Learning | Small | 84 |
Problem-Based Learning | Small | 85 |
Problem-Based Learning | Small | 83 |
Problem-Based Learning | Small | 81 |
Problem-Based Learning | Small | 86 |
Problem-Based Learning | Medium | 88 |
Problem-Based Learning | Medium | 90 |
Problem-Based Learning | Medium | 87 |
Problem-Based Learning | Medium | 92 |
Problem-Based Learning | Medium | 91 |
Problem-Based Learning | Medium | 89 |
Problem-Based Learning | Medium | 90 |
Problem-Based Learning | Medium | 88 |
Problem-Based Learning | Large | 94 |
Problem-Based Learning | Large | 97 |
Problem-Based Learning | Large | 92 |
Problem-Based Learning | Large | 96 |
Problem-Based Learning | Large | 85 |
Problem-Based Learning | Large | 91 |
Problem-Based Learning | Large | 87 |
Problem-Based Learning | Large | 89 |
Statistics For Business And Economics
ISBN: 9780321826237
12th Edition
Authors: James T. McClave, P. George Benson, Terry T Sincich