Do Male Symphony Conductors Really Live Longer? Several media reports made the interesting observation that male...

 

Transcribed Image Text:

Do Male Symphony Conductors Really Live Longer? Several media reports made the interesting observation that male symphony conductors live longer than other males. John Amaral wrote in Awaken that orchestra conductors "live longer than almost any other group of people by three to seven years." Robert Levine wrote in Polyphonic.org that they live longer "because they stand up while working." Some provided other explanations for this phenomenon, often referring to cardiovascular activity. But do male symphony conductors really live longer than other groups of males? The Internet can be researched for possible answers. Let's also consider the following. Analysis 1. Consider the statement that "male symphony conductors live longer." Identify the specific group that they supposedly live longer than. Does that other group consist of males randomly selected from the general population? 2. It is reasonable to assume that males do not become symphony conductors until they have reached at least the age of 40 years. When comparing life spans of male conductors, should we compare them to other males in the general population, or should we compare them to other males who lived until at least 40 years of age? Explain. 3. Without any disabilities, males qualify for Medicare if they are 65 or older and meet a few other requirements. If we compare life spans of males on Medicare to life spans of males randomly selected from the general population, why would we find that males on Medicare have longer life spans? 4. Explain in detail how to design a study for collecting data to determine whether it is misleading to state that male symphony conductors live longer. Should the study be an experiment or an observational study? Do Male Symphony Conductors Really Live Longer? Several media reports made the interesting observation that male symphony conductors live longer than other males. John Amaral wrote in Awaken that orchestra conductors "live longer than almost any other group of people by three to seven years." Robert Levine wrote in Polyphonic.org that they live longer "because they stand up while working." Some provided other explanations for this phenomenon, often referring to cardiovascular activity. But do male symphony conductors really live longer than other groups of males? The Internet can be researched for possible answers. Let's also consider the following. Analysis 1. Consider the statement that "male symphony conductors live longer." Identify the specific group that they supposedly live longer than. Does that other group consist of males randomly selected from the general population? 2. It is reasonable to assume that males do not become symphony conductors until they have reached at least the age of 40 years. When comparing life spans of male conductors, should we compare them to other males in the general population, or should we compare them to other males who lived until at least 40 years of age? Explain. 3. Without any disabilities, males qualify for Medicare if they are 65 or older and meet a few other requirements. If we compare life spans of males on Medicare to life spans of males randomly selected from the general population, why would we find that males on Medicare have longer life spans? 4. Explain in detail how to design a study for collecting data to determine whether it is misleading to state that male symphony conductors live longer. Should the study be an experiment or an observational study?

Answer rating: 100% (QA)

The study mentioned in the problem concludes that the male symphony conductors live longer Also the ... View the full answer