Could someone help me with a feedback to my classmate post

Here is the question

1) For your first topic in this conference I would like for you to briefly review either your personal experiences and/or the financial literature to identify and present a description of one actual capital project/product success or failure and the reasons attributed to the success or failure.

In your response please provide financial information regarding the project (what is available): initial outlay, projected cash flows, final dollar profit. Remember this is a one to two paragraph exercise - do not go overboard - a few hours research and summation is all thats required. I am interested only in your short, concise description of the project and the major reasons you believe it was successful or not.

2) Synthesize your one-paragraph position on what 3-5 specific factors you believe most likely to contribute to capital project analysis success or failure.

Here is their post

:An example of a capital product through personal experience is the purchase of a new piece of equipment at my company. This equipment was bought in 2010 for $50,000(Initial Outlay). We projected that the equipment would "pay for itself" over the course of 5 years (Projected cash flows). Our guess was right, and it has continually made an average of $5000 per year in profit since it was paid off(Final dollar profit). This was a capital product success that I believe was because of proper planning, pricing, and the actual "need" for the product. Specific factors that I believe contribute to capital product success include planning, pricing, need for the product, and continued profit after the initial outlay is paid