Payback Period Analysis for Mutually Exclusive Projects - Example 3 Question: Consider 2 mutually exclusive investments...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Payback Period Analysis for Mutually Exclusive Projects - Example 3 Question: Consider 2 mutually exclusive investments with the following after tax cash flow (ATCF). Which project is economically better assuming a minimum rate of return of i* = 15% Note: in thousands j* = Project A B Solution for Project A YEAR ATCF Cummulative ATCF Solution for Project B YEAR ATCF 15% Year O -$200 -$200 Payback period = 4 + 200/600 = 4.33 years NPVA = $98.31 Cummulative ATCF Year O -200 -200 Year O -200 -200 Payback period = 2 + 40/80 = 2.5 years NPVB = $68.17 Year 1 $80 Year 1 0 -200 at i* = 15% Year 1 80 -120 Year 2 - $80 Year 2 0 -200 Year 2 80 -40 Year 3 1 $80 Year 3 0 -200 Year 3 80 40 Year 4 $80 Year 4 0 -200 Year 4 80 120 Year 5 $600 $80 Year 5 600 400 Year 5 80 200 at i* = 15% Answer: Although Project B has a lower payback period (2.5 years). However, Project A with a payback period of 4.33 years is more attractive for investment as it has a better NPV. 7 Payback Period Analysis for Mutually Exclusive Projects - Example 3 Question: Consider 2 mutually exclusive investments with the following after tax cash flow (ATCF). Which project is economically better assuming a minimum rate of return of i* = 15% Note: in thousands j* = Project A B Solution for Project A YEAR ATCF Cummulative ATCF Solution for Project B YEAR ATCF 15% Year O -$200 -$200 Payback period = 4 + 200/600 = 4.33 years NPVA = $98.31 Cummulative ATCF Year O -200 -200 Year O -200 -200 Payback period = 2 + 40/80 = 2.5 years NPVB = $68.17 Year 1 $80 Year 1 0 -200 at i* = 15% Year 1 80 -120 Year 2 - $80 Year 2 0 -200 Year 2 80 -40 Year 3 1 $80 Year 3 0 -200 Year 3 80 40 Year 4 $80 Year 4 0 -200 Year 4 80 120 Year 5 $600 $80 Year 5 600 400 Year 5 80 200 at i* = 15% Answer: Although Project B has a lower payback period (2.5 years). However, Project A with a payback period of 4.33 years is more attractive for investment as it has a better NPV. 7
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
In this Payback Period Analysis for Mutually Exclusive Projects two investment ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these finance questions
-
Consider two investments with the following sequences of cash flows: (a) Compute the i* for each investment. (b) Plot the present-worth curve for each project on the same chart and find the interest...
-
The importance of conducting experiments properly.
-
Write statements that can be used in a JavaFX application to draw the five interlocking rings that are the symbol of the Olympics. (Dont worry about the color.)
-
Compare and contrast these explanations of FDI: internalization theory and Knickerbocker's theory of FDI
-
In Problem find f(x) and the equation of the line tangent to the graph of f at the indicated value of x. Find the value(s) of x where the tangent line is horizontal. f(x) = 5e x2 - 4x + 1 ; x = 0
-
The Howell Corporation has the following account balances (in millions): Prepare an income statement and a supporting schedule of cost of goods manufactured for the year ended December 31, 2017. (For...
-
In 1987, Herman Moore Company completed the construction of a building at a cost of $2,000,000 and first occupied it in January 1988. It was estimated that the building will have a useful life of 40...
-
Keynesians believe that the tools (G, T and MS) should be used to try to help the economy. Should we? Why or why not?
-
Suppose that Sasha and Jayla both collect data to investigate whether people tend to call heads more often than tails when they are asked to call the result of a coin flip. If Sasha has a smaller...
-
Statement evaluation. Specify whether each statement below is (i) always true, (ii) sometimes true, or (iii) never true. For those that are (ii) sometimes true, explain when the statement is true. a....
-
How do modern operating systems leverage hardware-assisted virtualization technologies, such as Intel VT-x and AMD-V, to support efficient virtualization of resources while maintaining strong...
-
Why is value-add real estate investments attractive to an investor?
-
How to maximize sale and control Cost Measurements in consulting?
-
In (horizontal/vertical) common size analysis, the base year selected impacts how the trends of a company's financial results in recent years are portraye?
-
Analyze the case study, identify the missing or inadequate security controls, and propose alternative controls that could have mitigated the risks.
-
The Companies Act 2006 clearly spells out the duty directors owe to a registered company. With reference to relevant case law and statutes, discuss in detail any FIVE duties directors owe to the...
-
What are three disadvantages of using the direct write-off method?
-
You just purchased a pin-inserting machine to relieve some bottleneck problems that have been created in manufacturing a PC board. The machine cost $56,000 and has an estimated service life of five...
-
You are buying a home for $360,000. If you make a down payment of $60,000 and take out a mortgage on the rest at 8.5% compounded monthly, what will be your monthly payment if the mortgage is to be...
-
The following data are available for two companies, Apple and Oracle, all stated in thousands of dollars. (a) Calculate each companys return on equity (ROE) and return on assets (ROA). (b) Which...
-
Use the Internet to access Home Depot's most recent annual report. a. What evidence did you find that Home Depot continues to rely on present worth analysis in its corporate decision making? b. Does...
-
Use an Internet search engine to identify three companies or agencies that use present worth analysis to make business decisions as evidenced in their annual reports.
-
Use the Internet to access ConocoPhillips's most recent annual report. a. What evidence do you find that ConocoPhillips continues to rely on present worth analysis in its corporate decision making?...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App