Create a peer review using the peer review rubric and ensure to use all the criteria with constructive comments to improve paper in each peer review.

Mini-Paper Peer Review Rubric

Criteria

Ratings

Pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome Peer Review Engagement

30 pts Exceptional Submitted feedback to 3 peers.

20 pts Effective Submitted feedback to 2 peers.

10 pts Developing Submitted feedback to 1 peer.

0 pts Unacceptable Did not engage in peer review.

30 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome Quality of Feedback(1) Included at least 3 constructive comments to improve paper in each peer review (2) Focused feedback on grading criteria featured in the Mini-Paper Assignment rubric (3) Used professional and respectful language

60 pts Exceptional Quality of feedback reflected all 3 required criteria.

40 pts Effective Quality of feedback reflected only 2 of 3 required criteria. Or there were minor issues with meeting the 3 required criteria.

20 pts Developing Quality of feedback reflected only 1 of 3 required criteria. Or there were significant issues with meeting the 3 required criteria.

0 pts Unacceptable Quality of feedback did not reflect the 3 required criteria. Or feedback was not submitted.

60 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome Spelling, Grammar, and Mechanics

10 pts Exceptional No errors related to spelling, grammar, and mechanics.

7 pts Developing Minimal errors related to spelling, grammar, and mechanics.

4 pts Developing Multiple errors related to spelling, grammar, and mechanics.

0 pts Unacceptable Numerous errors related to spelling, grammar, and mechanics. Or feedback was not submitted.

10 pts

Total Points: 100