Discussion Question #$3$:

The Benevolence Team$$s three major initiatives$$improving the representativeness of datasets and targeting at$-$risk users; moderating discussion; and experimenting on users to find best practices$$ were aimed at improving the experience for Charlie$$s users. But with each change, Charlie also came to play a more active role in nudging users towards particular behaviors. In what ways, if any, does

Charlie$$s shift from aggregator$/$provider of information to curator$/$nudger impact the issue of $$informed consent$?$

Discussion Question #$4$:

AI has created opportunities for highly personalized medical care. But in order to provide such care, apps like Charlie need to collect lots of data about their users. Many users are happy to share their data for the purposes of improving healthcare but worry about how sensitive information will be used in the future. What responsibilities, if any, does Charlie have to be transparent about their data collection, use and sharing policies?