Ethical Decision Making Grading Rubric

Ethical Decision Making Trait Problem Identication (1} Does Not Meet Expectations Fails to demonstrate an ability to articulate important ethical issues and identify alternative positions for those issues (2} Meets Expectations Demonstrates an ad equate ability to articulate important ethical issues and identify alternative positions for those issues (3} Exceeds Expectations Demonstrates an exceptional ability to articulate important ethical issues and identify alternative positions for those issues Viewpointsfstakeholders lmplicationstonsequences EthicalSolution Does not incorporate multiple viewpointsj' stakeholders Does not address implications;f Consequences for alternative courses of action [no implications or only one side} Unable to apply ethical theories to specific cases. Decides only in selfinterest. Does not take a stand on ethical matters. Unwilling to act maturely or ethicall Incorporates some relevant viewpoints! stakeholders 12 Considers some relevant implications;r consequences for alternative courses of action [both sides, 12, +'s, -'s Begins to formulate a reasoned decision-making process. Decides in the interest ofa widening circle of stakeholders. Takes a stand of ethical dilemmas not necessarily affectin_ one's self Incorporates a careful evaluation of relevant viewpointsfstakeholders {2-3} Identifies and carefully evaluates relevant implications! Consequences for alternative courses of action {both sides, 23, +'s, 's] Applies wellthoughto ut process of decision making to ethical dilemmas. Maturely commits to a decision. Decides in the interest ofjustice. Makes decisions with a high level of maturity and careful reflection