Question: Evidence - based management ( also known as EBM or EBMgt ) is a management approach that involves using multiple sources of scientific evidence and

Evidence-based management (also known as EBM or EBMgt) is a management approach that involves using multiple sources of scientific evidence and empirical results as a means of attaining knowledge (Barends, Rousseau, & Briner, 2014). To be an evidence-based manager is to use the scientific literature as a means of answering questions, inspiring strategy decisions, and forming long term plans. Published academic research from the fields of psychology, behavioral economics, communications, and even sociology can help to intorm the decisions of a well-informed evidence-based manager. An evidence based manager carefully considers the body of evidence, evaluating research for its quality and relevance.growing number of managers and professionals draw on scientific researchEvidence-based management takes its inspiration from evidence-based medicine, an approach that relies on experimental, carefully tested approaches to treating illness. Just as there is a massive and ever-growing body of knowledge on how to treat and prevent disease, there is also a voluminous, ever-growing knowledge base from the social sciences regarding how to manage individuals and run organizations effectively.While many managers still make decisions based on instinct, personal experience, or industry-wide trends (Rynes, Colbert, & Brown, 2002), a growing number of educated, scientifically-minded professionals opt instead to use the academic literature to determine "best practices" and select options that have been demonstrated to succeed in numerous studies.There are myriad benefits to taking an evidence-based approach to managing individuals within an organization. There are challenges and barriers to taking this approach, too - most notably, for some managers and professionals, a lack of familiarity and comfort with scientific journals and academic writing. This blog post will review some of the greatest benefits to taking an evidence-based management approach, and outline some solutions to common reservations that managers have about adopting this approach.Management skills newsletteremail addressJoin our monthly news etter to receive management tips, tricks and insights directly into your inbox!By signing up you agree to receive email newsletters or alerts from CQ Net - Management skills for everyone! You can unsubscribe at any time.Evidence-based management reduces errors in judgementExperienced professionals often rely on a finely-tuned sense of intuition; as a manager, your accumulated past experiences help inform your "gut feelings" today, often in useful ways (see Rew & Barrow, 2007, for a discussion of intuition as a decision-making guide). However, even an expert manager can make snap judgements tainted by mental biases, latent prejudices, or even lazy thinking (Sanders, van Riemsdijk, & Groen, 2008). While all people have momentary lapses in judgement, psychological research on the subject reveals that most people cannot recognize when their judgement is biased (Koch, D'Mello, & Sackett, 2015).An evidence based approach to management reduces the potential for irrational thinking, bias, or exhaustion to negatively impact management decisions. Rather than selecting an intervention or strategy based on gut feelings, personal experiences, or popular trends in the industry, an evidence-based manager reviews the published literature on the subject, critically appraises the quality of the evidence, and selects a strategy that is supported by science (Rynes, Giluk, & Brown,2007).This method of decision-making is systematic, and requires that a manager familiarize themselves with the work of dozens, even hundreds, of other cases studied in the literature. By relying on the aggregated results of many others, an evidence-based manager is able to "zoom out" of their own circumstances, and see more clearly the factors that ought to impact theirSearch decision-making. This can slow down the decision-making process in some instances, but it increases objectivity and clarity of thought.Evidence-based management (EBM) in a nutshellSelecting the best available evidenceEBM involves using multiple sources of scientific evidence and empirical results as a means of attaining knowledge and finding interventions and strategies. The goal is to make decisions based on the best available evidenceSystematicRe-evaluatingdecision-makingand adaptingMental biases, prejudices or lazyLike in the social science, decisions are criticallythinking are reduced byexamined and accuratelytaking into considerationevaluated using thepublished literature,scientific method. Constantcritically appraisingre-evaluation and improvement of theevidence, and selecting a strategy supported byhypothesis determinesscience.whether the strategy isEvidence-based management is driven by science and dataAfter a manager introduces a new strategy within their organization, it can be immensely difficult to determine whether the strategy was effective in objective terms. Any observed changes within the organization may be due to the new strategy, or due to extraneous factor such as personnel changes, shifting market forces, sociopolitical events, or even changes in the weather.Human behavior is notoriously tricky to explain or predict, and it is influenced by numerous variables at all times.Furthermore, a manager may not be able to interpret the effects of their decisions objectively (Tschan et al,2009); there may be a strong temptation to see an intervention as more effective than it actually is, or to "cherry pick" signs that a strategy was effective, in spite of any evidence suggesting otherwise.An evidence-based management approach, in contrast, relies on the scientific method to fairly examine interventions and accurately evaluate their performance. Social science research is guided by firm principles regarding how to prove cause and effect relationships. After an intervention has been instituted, statistical methods are used to document improvements and determine whether a strategy is worthwhile in simple mathematic terms. Conclusions can be easily drawn, interpreted, and conveyed to stakeholders in a non-biased manner as a result.Evidence-based management increases accountabilityAs a manager and professional, decision-making is your daily business. Making the right or wrong decision has an immediate impact on organizational performance. It is your responsibility to make sure your decision-making processEvidence-based management increases accountabilityAs a manager and professional, decision-making is your daily business. Making the right or wrong decision has an immediate impact on organizational performance. It is your responsibility to make sure your decision-making process adheres to the highest quality standards available. This is not just important for you as an individual, but for the organization, department, project, or team you are responsible for. It is the quality of your decision-making process that impacts their future.Taking an evidence-based management approach makes sure you consider the best available evidence when taking decisions. More specifically, it points towards the following four sources of evidence:1. Organizational data2. Professional expertize3. Stakeholder values and concerns4. Insights from scientific researchFour kinds of evidence in evidence-based managementScientific literatureEmpirical studies2PractitionersProfessional expertiseOrganizationInternal dataAskAcquire AppraiseAggregateApplyAssessStakeholdersValues and concernsAll four sources of evidence are considered equally important. However, their quality and availability differs depending on the specific business challenge you are facing. Consequently, it is of critical importance to appraise the quality of the available evidence before using it in decision-making.A decision-making process that relies on a structured and quality-oriented approach increases transparency and therefore accountability. As a result, you will not just increase organizational performance but also your standing, reputation, and career perspectives as a manager and professional.Common mistakes when taking an evidence-based management approachMany managers are aware that scientific research on management and organizational behavior exists. However, since relatively few managers have academic or scientific training, few feel empowered to access, search, and make productive use of that research. If a manager does choose to venture into the published literature, they may find that peer-reviewed journal articles are written in a jargon-filled, dry manner that is difficult or intimidating to read (de Bruin & Bostrom, 2013)One of the first steps to becoming an evidence-based manager is to get over the "intimidation factor",, when it comes tosearching and consuming published science. Scientific research is intended to serve the public interest, and is frequently made available to individuals outside of academia. Published, high-quality research can be found in databases such as STOR and Psychinto, and via academic search engines like Google Scholar. Journals devoted to organizational research, such as SAGEs Journal of Management, can also be searched for empirical work relevant to a manager's needs and interests.Reading and interpreting scientific research is daunting; however, most sections of a standard journal article can be read and understood without any statistical or higher-level scientific training. This guide to reading scientific literature can help you familiarize yourself with how a peer-reviewed article is written, and how to go about locating needed information within one. Learning a few basic statistical concepts can also help empower a manager to consume research productively - this guide reviews basic statistics in an approachable way, without any mathematics.CQ Dossiers provide reviews and distillations on a variety of evid

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer
Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image
Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock
Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related General Management Questions!