Sue was puzzled as to what course of action to take. She had recently started her...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Sue was puzzled as to what course of action to take. She had recently started her job with a national CPA firm, and she was already confronted with a problem that could affect her future with the firm. On an audit, she encountered a client who had been treating payments to a large number of employees as payments to independent contractors. This practice saves the client the payroll taxes that would otherwise be due on the payments if the workers were classified as employees. In Sue's judgment this was improper as well as illegal and should have noted in the audit. She raised the issue with John, the senior accountant to whom she reported. He thought it was a possible problem but did not seem willing to do anything about it. He encouraged her to talk to the partner in charge if she didn't feel satisfied. She thought about the problem for a considerable time before approaching the partner in charge. The ongoing professional education classes she had received from her employer emphasized the ethical responsibilities that she had as a CPA and the fact that her firm endorsed adherence to high ethical standards. This finally swayed her to pursue the issue with the partner in charge of the audit. The visit was most unsatisfactory. Paul, the partner, virtually confirmed her initial reaction that the practice was wrong, but he said that many other companies in the industry follow such a practice. He went on to say that if an issue was made of it, Sue would lose the account and he was not about to take such action. She came away from the meeting with the distinct feeling that had she chosen to pursue the issue she would have created an enemy. Sue still felt disturbed and decided to discuss the problem with some of her coworkers. She approached Bill and Mike, both of whom had been working for the firm for a couple of years. They were familiar with the problem because they had encountered the same issue when doing the audit the previous year. They expressed considerable concern that if she went over the head of the partner in charge of the audit, they could be in big trouble since they had failed to question the practice during the previous audit. They said that they realized it was probably wrong, but they went ahead because it had been ignored in previous year and hey knew their supervisor wanted them to ignore it again this year. They didn't want to cause problems. They encouraged Sue to be a "team player" and drop the issue. Analyze each of Sue's possible courses of action, detailing the positive and negative ramifications of each alternative. What would you do if confronted with this situation? What would be the deciding factor or factors that shape your decision? Sue was puzzled as to what course of action to take. She had recently started her job with a national CPA firm, and she was already confronted with a problem that could affect her future with the firm. On an audit, she encountered a client who had been treating payments to a large number of employees as payments to independent contractors. This practice saves the client the payroll taxes that would otherwise be due on the payments if the workers were classified as employees. In Sue's judgment this was improper as well as illegal and should have noted in the audit. She raised the issue with John, the senior accountant to whom she reported. He thought it was a possible problem but did not seem willing to do anything about it. He encouraged her to talk to the partner in charge if she didn't feel satisfied. She thought about the problem for a considerable time before approaching the partner in charge. The ongoing professional education classes she had received from her employer emphasized the ethical responsibilities that she had as a CPA and the fact that her firm endorsed adherence to high ethical standards. This finally swayed her to pursue the issue with the partner in charge of the audit. The visit was most unsatisfactory. Paul, the partner, virtually confirmed her initial reaction that the practice was wrong, but he said that many other companies in the industry follow such a practice. He went on to say that if an issue was made of it, Sue would lose the account and he was not about to take such action. She came away from the meeting with the distinct feeling that had she chosen to pursue the issue she would have created an enemy. Sue still felt disturbed and decided to discuss the problem with some of her coworkers. She approached Bill and Mike, both of whom had been working for the firm for a couple of years. They were familiar with the problem because they had encountered the same issue when doing the audit the previous year. They expressed considerable concern that if she went over the head of the partner in charge of the audit, they could be in big trouble since they had failed to question the practice during the previous audit. They said that they realized it was probably wrong, but they went ahead because it had been ignored in previous year and hey knew their supervisor wanted them to ignore it again this year. They didn't want to cause problems. They encouraged Sue to be a "team player" and drop the issue. Analyze each of Sue's possible courses of action, detailing the positive and negative ramifications of each alternative. What would you do if confronted with this situation? What would be the deciding factor or factors that shape your decision?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Sue can either report the incident to the labor department with proof or keep quiet and continue her service in the firm without hiding the clients ac... View the full answer
Related Book For
Federal Tax Research
ISBN: 9781285439396
10th edition
Authors: Roby Sawyers, William Raabe, Gerald Whittenburg, Steven Gill
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these finance questions
-
Which of the following are not top managers? 1. Chief executive officer 2. 3. 4. Managing directors Regional managers Chief operating officer
-
After five years with a national CPA firm with mostly large manufacturing clients, Amy Kimbell joined Hi-Quality Productions Inc. (Hi-Q) as manager of Manufacturing Accounting. Amy has both CPA and...
-
Eric is a tax manager for a national CPA firm that audits Penny- Pinching Bank (PPB). Eric and his staff prepare and review the tax return for PPB. One day, at an alumni football tailgate party, he...
-
Aria Perfume, Inc.. sold 3,210 boxes of white musk soap during January of 2016 at the price of $90 per box. The company offers a full refund for any product returned within 30 days from the date of...
-
Have you had an interview in the past, and the interviewer never got back to you? Or have you sent a rsum and not received a response? Think about one of these situations, and write an email to...
-
What conditions are used to standardize the quench in the Jominy test?
-
An air compressor of mass \(500 \mathrm{~kg}\) has an eccentricity of \(50 \mathrm{~kg}-\mathrm{cm}\) and operates at a speed of \(300 \mathrm{rpm}\). The compressor is to be mounted on one of the...
-
Consider a $6500 piece of machinery, with a 5-year depreciable life and an estimated $1200 salvage value . The projected utilization of the machinery when it was purchased, and its actual production...
-
Identify at least three specific factors that have likely shaped your own implicit or unconscious biases. What examples of bias did you know about before reading the explanations? What examples were...
-
1. Cho, Inc. has the following items: loss on discontinued operations ($400K), loss on disposal of discontinued operations ($250K), tax rate (20%). If the above items are pre-tax dollar amounts, what...
-
Use the graphical information to find the number of members. Number of People 11 10 9 8 7 6 16-20 21-25 26-30 31-35 Age Q A frisbee-golf club recorded the ages of its members and used the results to...
-
Use the following information for the remainder of the questions. Dan has finally decided to create his own product line of cat related items hosted at his new business the Cat Empurrium. Dan wants...
-
To create project schedule, one must understand the Project Schedule Management processes; in particular, one needs to know the project work or tasks to be performed (i.e., the project scope) and...
-
A startup technology company has just finished developing its branding and marketing materials, including the design of its e-newsletter. After conducting a pilot and making adjustments with a few...
-
Your team has been asked to test and document enhancements to a web application that allows buyers to purchase custom-printed canvas shoes. The tasks and dependencies are as follows: a testing plan...
-
The total market value of your portfolio is $20,000,000 and the beta of the portfolio is 1.6. It is 3/23 and you want to hedge till 5/15. You have the following contracts on the S&P500 index...
-
What role does delegation play in fostering innovation and organizational agility by decentralizing decision-making authority, empowering frontline employees, and promoting experimentation and...
-
A number of years ago the United Food and Commercial Workers Union organized 800 workers of the 1035 employees at one of the Wilson Brothers food operations in Toronto, Ontario. The employees include...
-
Eighty percent of the Willigs AGI comes from their submarine sandwich shop operated as a sole proprie-torship. In 2014, the Willigs lost an IRS audit and owed $ 12,000 in 2012 federal income taxes,...
-
What is a case headnote? How might it be useful to the tax researcher?
-
What are KeySearch and the West Key Number System?
-
A container of an organic liquid a $25^{\circ} \mathrm{C}$ has a mass of $1100 \mathrm{~kg}$ and a volume of $0.94 \mathrm{~m}^{3}$. Find the liquid's weight, its density, and its specific gravity.
-
A vertical, cylindrical tank with a diameter of $10 \mathrm{~m}$ and a depth of $4 \mathrm{~m}$ is filled to the top with water at $25^{\circ} \mathrm{C}$. If the water is heated to $60^{\circ}...
-
The system in Figure P1.6 is at $20^{\circ} \mathrm{C}$. If atmospheric pressure is $101.3 \mathrm{kPa}$ and the absolute pressure at the bottom of the tank is $264.1 \mathrm{kPa}$, what is the...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App