Explain the ratio decidendi of noble v. Devon county council LORD CLYDE My Lords, [Para 1] At
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
LORD CLYDE My Lords, [Para 1] At dawn on a frosty December morning in 1991 Mr. Paul Noble was driving his Vauxhall Nova on the A386 at Marsden Hill near Dunnsfield in Devon. As he moved out to overtake on a straight stretch of road, a rear wheel skidded on a patch of black ice. He lost control and the car crashed into the parapet of the bridge over the Marsden River. He suffered dreadful injuries and is now almost entirely paralysed. [Para 2] Mr. Noble claims damages against Devon County Council on the ground that it was in breach of its statutory duty under section 41(1) of the Highways Act 1980 to "maintain the highway." He does not complain that there was anything wrong with the road surface. In freezing weather, black ice can form on the best laid surfaces. But he says that the council should have prevented the formation of the ice by spreading salt and grit on the road before dawn. So the short point in this appeal concerns the council's statutory duty of care in adverse wintry weather conditions. The statement of claim also contained an allegation that the council had been guilty of common law negligence. But this was not pressed at the trial and has disappeared from the case. The courts below said that they were bound by previous authority to hold that section 41(1) imposed the wider duty. But the Court of Appeal gave leave to appeal so that those authorities could be examined in your Lordship's House. There was a difference of opinion on whether the council had complied with the duty. The judge held that it had done enough and dismissed the action. In the Court of Appeal [...Aldous L.J] agreed. But the majority ...held that the council was in breach and allowed the appeal. 1 A thin layer of transparent ice on a road Page 3 of 12 [Para 3] Although the council denies it has a statutory duty to keep the roads free of ice, it does in fact make considerable efforts to do so. The Highway Superintendent receives weather forecasts from the Exeter Meteorological Office and decides whether and when to send out the council's fleet of gritting lorries. Each lorry has a route to cover. The council follows a Code of Good Practice issued by the Association of County Councils and three other local authority associations. This says, among other things, that the salting should be completed before the morning rush hour begins at 7.30. In the present case there had been a forecast of freezing conditions in the early hours and the lorries had been despatched at 5.30. Unfortunately, by the time of the accident, the lorry covering the A386 had not yet got to Marsden Hill. It arrived a few minutes later and would have been able to complete its route by 7.30. But a majority of the Court of Appeal decided, on the assumption that the statute imposed a duty to keep the road free of ice, that the council was nevertheless in breach of duty, in that the gritting should have been completed before the time when, according to the forecast, ice was likely to form. [Para 4] There is a partial definition of "maintain" in section 329(1) of the Act of 1980. It provides that "maintenance' includes repair, and 'maintain' and ' maintainable' are to be construed accordingly" [Para 5] The Act of 1980 was a consolidation Act and section 41(1) and the accompanying definition reproduced identical provisions which had first appeared as section 44(1) and section 295(1) (the definition clause) of the Highways Act 1959. There is nothing to suggest that any change of meaning was intended. The Highways Act 1959 was also a consolidation Act. The long title was "An Act to consolidate with amendments certain enactments relating to highways." But there is no exact antecedent of section 44(1) and the definition. [Para 6] Mr. Reuben, who appeared for Mr. Noble, put forward an attractive argument on construction. He said that although the Act of 1959 was a consolidation Act, the court should interpret section 44(1) of the Act of 1959 in the same way as if it formed part of a new Act. This was for two reasons. First, it was not simply a consolidation Act. It also contained amendments. Section 44(1) might therefore have been intended to amend the previous law by extending the duties of highway authorities from maintenance of the fabric to other forms of maintenance necessary to prevent the highway from being dangerous to the public. Secondly, even in the case of a pure consolidation Act, the courts should not delve into the antecedent legislation unless the obscurity of the statutory language made it necessary to do so. As Lord Wilberforce said in Farrell v. Alexander [1977]: "self-contained statutes, whether consolidating previous law, or so doing with amendments, should be interpreted, if reasonably possible, without recourse to antecedents, and that the recourse should only be had when there is a real and substantial difficulty or ambiguity which classical methods of construction cannot resolve" LORD CLYDE My Lords, [Para 1] At dawn on a frosty December morning in 1991 Mr. Paul Noble was driving his Vauxhall Nova on the A386 at Marsden Hill near Dunnsfield in Devon. As he moved out to overtake on a straight stretch of road, a rear wheel skidded on a patch of black ice. He lost control and the car crashed into the parapet of the bridge over the Marsden River. He suffered dreadful injuries and is now almost entirely paralysed. [Para 2] Mr. Noble claims damages against Devon County Council on the ground that it was in breach of its statutory duty under section 41(1) of the Highways Act 1980 to "maintain the highway." He does not complain that there was anything wrong with the road surface. In freezing weather, black ice can form on the best laid surfaces. But he says that the council should have prevented the formation of the ice by spreading salt and grit on the road before dawn. So the short point in this appeal concerns the council's statutory duty of care in adverse wintry weather conditions. The statement of claim also contained an allegation that the council had been guilty of common law negligence. But this was not pressed at the trial and has disappeared from the case. The courts below said that they were bound by previous authority to hold that section 41(1) imposed the wider duty. But the Court of Appeal gave leave to appeal so that those authorities could be examined in your Lordship's House. There was a difference of opinion on whether the council had complied with the duty. The judge held that it had done enough and dismissed the action. In the Court of Appeal [...Aldous L.J] agreed. But the majority ...held that the council was in breach and allowed the appeal. 1 A thin layer of transparent ice on a road Page 3 of 12 [Para 3] Although the council denies it has a statutory duty to keep the roads free of ice, it does in fact make considerable efforts to do so. The Highway Superintendent receives weather forecasts from the Exeter Meteorological Office and decides whether and when to send out the council's fleet of gritting lorries. Each lorry has a route to cover. The council follows a Code of Good Practice issued by the Association of County Councils and three other local authority associations. This says, among other things, that the salting should be completed before the morning rush hour begins at 7.30. In the present case there had been a forecast of freezing conditions in the early hours and the lorries had been despatched at 5.30. Unfortunately, by the time of the accident, the lorry covering the A386 had not yet got to Marsden Hill. It arrived a few minutes later and would have been able to complete its route by 7.30. But a majority of the Court of Appeal decided, on the assumption that the statute imposed a duty to keep the road free of ice, that the council was nevertheless in breach of duty, in that the gritting should have been completed before the time when, according to the forecast, ice was likely to form. [Para 4] There is a partial definition of "maintain" in section 329(1) of the Act of 1980. It provides that "maintenance' includes repair, and 'maintain' and ' maintainable' are to be construed accordingly" [Para 5] The Act of 1980 was a consolidation Act and section 41(1) and the accompanying definition reproduced identical provisions which had first appeared as section 44(1) and section 295(1) (the definition clause) of the Highways Act 1959. There is nothing to suggest that any change of meaning was intended. The Highways Act 1959 was also a consolidation Act. The long title was "An Act to consolidate with amendments certain enactments relating to highways." But there is no exact antecedent of section 44(1) and the definition. [Para 6] Mr. Reuben, who appeared for Mr. Noble, put forward an attractive argument on construction. He said that although the Act of 1959 was a consolidation Act, the court should interpret section 44(1) of the Act of 1959 in the same way as if it formed part of a new Act. This was for two reasons. First, it was not simply a consolidation Act. It also contained amendments. Section 44(1) might therefore have been intended to amend the previous law by extending the duties of highway authorities from maintenance of the fabric to other forms of maintenance necessary to prevent the highway from being dangerous to the public. Secondly, even in the case of a pure consolidation Act, the courts should not delve into the antecedent legislation unless the obscurity of the statutory language made it necessary to do so. As Lord Wilberforce said in Farrell v. Alexander [1977]: "self-contained statutes, whether consolidating previous law, or so doing with amendments, should be interpreted, if reasonably possible, without recourse to antecedents, and that the recourse should only be had when there is a real and substantial difficulty or ambiguity which classical methods of construction cannot resolve"
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
South-Western Federal Taxation 2018 Comprehensive
ISBN: 9781337386005
41st Edition
Authors: David M. Maloney, William H. Hoffman, Jr., William A. Raabe, James C. Young
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
Question (700 words) John Densmore, a law student and part-time musician, was seriously injured in a car accident. The other car's driver, Ray Manzarek, a renowned life motivation coach and a...
-
The classic iPod is 10.5 millimeters thick. Suppose that the actual thickness T of any particular iPod has a maximum error tolerance that is less than 0.05 millimeter. (a) Write an absolute value...
-
These data were collected from a bouncing-ball experiment. Recall that the height in centimeters, y, is exponentially related to the number of the bounce, x. Find the values of a and b for an...
-
Madetoja Oy's job-costing system has two direct-cost categories: direct materials and direct manufacturing labour. Manufacturing overhead (both variable and fixed) is allocated to products on the...
-
Look up the FASB home page on the Internet at the following address: www.fasb.org. Find the list of technical projects that are currently on the boards agenda. Choose one of the projects that will...
-
PharmaPlus operates a chain of 30 pharmacies. The pharmacies are staffed by licensed pharmacists and pharmacy technicians. The company currently employs 85 full-time equivalent pharmacists...
-
Discuss the challenges an employer may face in administering the record keeping of Social Insurance Numbers.
-
PTS Ltd is a manufacturing company which uses three production and three service departments to make its products. It has the following overhead costs from primary distribution. Production...
-
Ann Landers, an advice columnist, once wrote Nothing shocks me anymore, especially when I know that 50 percent of the doctors who practice medicine graduated in the bottom half of their class [14]....
-
Roll four six-sided dice ten times, each time recording the sum of the four numbers rolled. Calculate the mean and median of your ten rolls. Repeat this experiment 20 times. Which of these two...
-
Why do you suppose that large, well-known companies such as Oracle, Starbucks, and Nextel prefer to have their shares traded on the NASDAQ rather than on one of the major listed exchanges, such as...
-
Joanna is staring work with an annual salary of $40,000. If her salary increases by 5 percent a year, what will her salary be 40 years from now? If prices increase by 3 percent a year, how much...
-
Explain why this statement is incorrect: When two assets have a +1.00 correlation, they move up and down at the same time, with the same magnitude.
-
Read the case study Holding the (Price) Line on Luxury Goods What other pricing promotions could a luxury retailer offer to build sales? Should a retailer use different strategies when targeting...
-
Subprime loans have higher loss rates than many other types of loans. Explain why lenders offer subprime loans. Describe the characteristics of the typical borrower in a subprime consumer loan.
-
Mega Tech, Inc. designs and manufactures automotive components. For years, the company enjoyed a stable marketplace, a small but loyal group of customers, and a relatively predictable environment....
-
In 2003, the Department of Health and Human Services in Victoria, Australia, initiated a AU$323 million project to develop HealthSMART, an integrated IT system that would deliver resource management,...
-
Describe the features of a project. How do they differ from day-to-day processes within an organization?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App