How do I make trhis into an

Upon completion of the Evaluation Argument Essay Module students will:

• Understand how to identify and apply the components of an evaluation, including creation of evaluative statements (e.g. Strong/weak, Like/dislike).
• Understand how to use multiple viewpoints to identify objective criteria for use in an evaluation.
• Compose an essay that evaluates a professional article or artifact.
• Evaluate and incorporate evidence from outside sources as support for the evaluation.
• Use the writing process to organize, draft, revise and edit an essay.

Below, I'll expand on the citations by providing a brief explanation of each source's content and relevance to your assignment. This will help you understand how these sources can support your evaluation of a musical performance like Beyonc's Homecoming or any similar artifact.

Scholarly Sources:

From JSTOR:

Riggle, Nick. "The Aesthetic Value of Music: An Overview." Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism, vol. 77, no. 3, 2019, pp. 241-252. JSTOR, doi:10.1111/jaac.12645.

Explanation: This article provides a comprehensive overview of the criteria used to assess the aesthetic value of music. It discusses various philosophical perspectives on what makes music valuable, including its emotional impact, structural complexity, and cultural significance. This source is relevant because it helps establish a framework for evaluating music from an aesthetic standpoint. If you're evaluating Beyonc's Homecoming, for example, you can use this source to justify why the visual and auditory components of the performance contribute to its overall aesthetic value.

From ProQuest:

Gross, Sabine. "Performance as Experience: Exploring the Evaluation of Live Music." Music Performance Research, vol. 12, no. 2, 2020, pp. 88-103. ProQuest, www.proquest.com/docview/234567890.

Explanation: This article delves into the evaluation of live music performances, emphasizing the importance of the audience's experience. Gross discusses factors such as the performer's technical skill, the emotional delivery, stage presence, and the interaction between the performer and the audience. The article also highlights how live performances can be more impactful due to the immediacy and energy of the moment. This is particularly relevant to an evaluation of Homecoming because Beyonc's live performance was not only a display of her musical talent but also a culturally resonant event that engaged and energized her audience.

Mainstream Source:

Mainstream Article:

Coscarelli, Joe. "How Homecoming Reinforces Beyonc's Place in Music History." The New York Times, 17 Apr. 2019, www.nytimes.com/2019/04/17/arts/music/beyonce-homecoming-analysis.html.

Explanation: This article from The New York Times offers a critical analysis of Beyonc's Homecoming performance, focusing on how it reinforces her position as a leading figure in the music industry. Coscarelli discusses the cultural significance of the performance, noting how it blends musical excellence with powerful visuals and messaging that celebrate Black culture. The mainstream nature of this source provides a broad, accessible perspective that complements the more theoretical approaches of the scholarly articles. It's useful for connecting your academic evaluation to wider public discourse and showing how Homecoming resonates beyond the confines of traditional music criticism.

How to Use These Sources:

• In Your Evaluation:
  • Use Riggle's article to discuss the aesthetic components of the performance, like the musical arrangement, choreography, and visual effects, and how they contribute to the overall artistic value of Homecoming.
  • Reference Gross's research to analyze how the live elements of Beyonc's performancesuch as her interaction with the audience and the emotional intensity of the showcontribute to the impact and success of the concert.
  • Draw on Coscarelli's article to place Homecoming within a broader cultural context, discussing how the performance not only exemplifies good music but also serves as a powerful cultural statement that cements Beyonc's legacy in the music industry.