Poor - 2 points Exemplary- 10 points Correctly identifies the Satisfactory - 8 points Identifies the issue, but misses key components Average - 6 points Misidentifies the Misses the Issue/Legal Question issue or issue identifies many completely issue the case is covering wrong components Rule of law is Rule of law is Rule of law is close, but key points may be misinterpreted Rule/Relevant Law Rule of law is correctly identified and slightly identified but completely missed major points are misinterpreted Does not include Misses major all key facts in interpreted to fit the case Includes most of the relevant facts Facts Includes all details and relevant facts and the and reasoning the case demonstrates lack of reasoning logically connects awareness about the case the facts to the rule of law Demonstrates Does not Insufficient Decision/Action/Questions Demonstrates understanding of understanding of the vote and understanding of decision and understand the the vote of the action taken or court, the action action taken but insufficiently poor follow up the court has fails to answer answers many answers. follow up questions. follow up taken and answers all follow up questions in a sufficient manner. questions adequately Dressed in Attire not Presentation Both attire and Overall Presentation appropriate attire appropriate or inadequate preparation preparation are insufficient and attire both are severely lacking and excellent overall preparation