In this question we will explore and show some nice properties of Generalized Linear Models, specifically...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
![](https://dsd5zvtm8ll6.cloudfront.net/si.experts.images/questions/2023/09/64f3144a89734_1693652040026.jpg)
![](https://dsd5zvtm8ll6.cloudfront.net/si.experts.images/questions/2023/09/64f3146240ff2_1693652060099.jpg)
Transcribed Image Text:
In this question we will explore and show some nice properties of Generalized Linear Models, specifically those related to its use of Exponential Family distributions to model the output. Most commonly, GLMs are trained by using the negative log-likelihood (NLL) as the loss function. This is mathemat- ically equivalent to Maximum Likelihood Estimation (i.e., maximizing the log-likelihood is equivalent to minimizing the negative log-likelihood). In this problem, our goal is to show that the NLL loss of a GLM is a conver function w.r.t the model parameters. As a reminder, this is convenient because a convex function is one for which any local minimum is also a global minimum, and there is extensive research on how to optimize various types of convex functions efficiently with various algorithms such as gradient descent or stochastic gradient descent. To recap, an exponential family distribution is one whose probability density can be represented p(y;n) = b(y) exp(n¹T(y) - a(n)), where n is the natural parameter of the distribution. Moreover, in a Generalized Linear Model, nis modeled as Tx, where x Rd are the input features of the example, and 0 € Rª are learnable parameters. In order to show that the NLL loss is convex for GLMs, we break down the process into sub-parts, and approach them one at a time. Our approach is to show that the second derivative (i.e., Hessian) of the loss w.r.t the model parameters is Positive Semi-Definite (PSD) at all values of the model parameters. We will also show some nice properties of Exponential Family distributions as intermediate steps. For the sake of convenience we restrict ourselves to the case where n is a scalar. Assume p(Y|X; 0) ~ ExponentialFamily(n), where n E R is a scalar, and T(y) = ) = y. This makes the exponential family representation take the form p(y;n) - b(y) exp(ny - a(n)). (a) [6 points (Written)] Derive an expression for the mean of the distribution. Show that E[Y; n] = a(n) (note that E[Y; n] = E[Y|X;0] since n=0x). In other words, show that the mean of an exponential family distribution is the first derivative of the log-partition function with respect to the natural parameter. Hint: Start with observing that fp(y;n)dy = fp(y;n)dy. (b) [6 points (Written)] Next, derive an expression for the variance of the distribution. In particular, show that Var(Y;n) = a(n) (again, note that Var(Y; n) = Var(Y|X; 0)). In other words, show that the variance of an exponential family distribution is the second derivative of the log-partition function w.r.t. the natural parameter. Hint: Building upon the result in the previous sub-problem can simplify the derivation. (c) [6 points (Written)] Finally, write out the loss function (0), the NLL of the distribution, as a function of 0. Then, calculate the Hessian of the loss w.r.t , and show that it is always PSD. This concludes the proof that NLL loss of GLM is convex. Hint 1: Use the chain rule of calculus along with the results of the previous parts to simplify your derivations. Hint 2: Recall that variance of any probability distribution is non-negative. Remark: The main takeaways from this problem are: . Any GLM model is convex in its model parameters. . The exponential family of probability distributions are mathematically nice. Whereas calculating mean and variance of distributions in general involves integrals (hard), surprisingly we can calculate them using derivatives (easy) for exponential family. In this question we will explore and show some nice properties of Generalized Linear Models, specifically those related to its use of Exponential Family distributions to model the output. Most commonly, GLMs are trained by using the negative log-likelihood (NLL) as the loss function. This is mathemat- ically equivalent to Maximum Likelihood Estimation (i.e., maximizing the log-likelihood is equivalent to minimizing the negative log-likelihood). In this problem, our goal is to show that the NLL loss of a GLM is a conver function w.r.t the model parameters. As a reminder, this is convenient because a convex function is one for which any local minimum is also a global minimum, and there is extensive research on how to optimize various types of convex functions efficiently with various algorithms such as gradient descent or stochastic gradient descent. To recap, an exponential family distribution is one whose probability density can be represented p(y;n) = b(y) exp(n¹T(y) - a(n)), where n is the natural parameter of the distribution. Moreover, in a Generalized Linear Model, nis modeled as Tx, where x Rd are the input features of the example, and 0 € Rª are learnable parameters. In order to show that the NLL loss is convex for GLMs, we break down the process into sub-parts, and approach them one at a time. Our approach is to show that the second derivative (i.e., Hessian) of the loss w.r.t the model parameters is Positive Semi-Definite (PSD) at all values of the model parameters. We will also show some nice properties of Exponential Family distributions as intermediate steps. For the sake of convenience we restrict ourselves to the case where n is a scalar. Assume p(Y|X; 0) ~ ExponentialFamily(n), where n E R is a scalar, and T(y) = ) = y. This makes the exponential family representation take the form p(y;n) - b(y) exp(ny - a(n)). (a) [6 points (Written)] Derive an expression for the mean of the distribution. Show that E[Y; n] = a(n) (note that E[Y; n] = E[Y|X;0] since n=0x). In other words, show that the mean of an exponential family distribution is the first derivative of the log-partition function with respect to the natural parameter. Hint: Start with observing that fp(y;n)dy = fp(y;n)dy. (b) [6 points (Written)] Next, derive an expression for the variance of the distribution. In particular, show that Var(Y;n) = a(n) (again, note that Var(Y; n) = Var(Y|X; 0)). In other words, show that the variance of an exponential family distribution is the second derivative of the log-partition function w.r.t. the natural parameter. Hint: Building upon the result in the previous sub-problem can simplify the derivation. (c) [6 points (Written)] Finally, write out the loss function (0), the NLL of the distribution, as a function of 0. Then, calculate the Hessian of the loss w.r.t , and show that it is always PSD. This concludes the proof that NLL loss of GLM is convex. Hint 1: Use the chain rule of calculus along with the results of the previous parts to simplify your derivations. Hint 2: Recall that variance of any probability distribution is non-negative. Remark: The main takeaways from this problem are: . Any GLM model is convex in its model parameters. . The exponential family of probability distributions are mathematically nice. Whereas calculating mean and variance of distributions in general involves integrals (hard), surprisingly we can calculate them using derivatives (easy) for exponential family.
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Understandable Statistics Concepts And Methods
ISBN: 9781337119917
12th Edition
Authors: Charles Henry Brase, Corrinne Pellillo Brase
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these programming questions
-
Cache memoryis an extremely fastmemorytype that acts as a buffer between the main memory and the CPU. The cache contains a copy of portions of the main memory. Answer all the following questions. (a)...
-
How do you incorporate self-care practices into your busy professional life, and do you see any direct impact on your work, especially in roles like tax preparation and notary services?
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
2. A magazine printer is considering taking on a new weekly publication. The company's financial officer has researched and determined costs and a committee of upper management personnel are deciding...
-
The following table shows grades for performances in a drama class. The table is incomplete. Use the information given to fill in the missing entries and complete the table. Category Frequency...
-
Describe three ways that a sequence can be defined.
-
The price of milk. The U.S. Department of Agriculture Web site provides data on the monthly average price of a gallon of whole milk. The following table gives the values for 2006 and 2007. Date Price...
-
The United Broadcast Network (UBN) sells to advertisers commercial advertising slots on its television shows. The network announces its new fall television schedule during the previous spring and...
-
Brief ise 231 Detter Publications sold annual subscriptions to the man for $42.000 in December 2016. The mag is puud . The new c on received the first magan l ar 2017 What adjustment should be made...
-
Looking for the excel function in Yellow on Q9 Question 9 Annual 3.000% Semi-Annual 3.022% Quarterly 3.034% Monthly 3.042% 4 points Question 10 14.2 14.2 4 points 9) After reviewing the compounding...
-
The notes receivable held by the Tuttle Company on August 3, 20x1, are summarized below. On August 4, 20X1, Tuttle discounted all of these notes at Community Bank and Trust at a discount rate of 10...
-
A monopolist produces sets/boxes of golf balls. Assume that the demand for a set of golf balls is P=100-Q and its MC=20. Suppose the monopolist sets a two-part tariff (a per unit fee and a lump sum...
-
To demonstrate competency in this unit, a person must: Call an Auction Instructions in second document titled Auction Script Guide Execute the contract for the successful bidder This can be a...
-
3. Customers arrive at a two-server service station according to a Poisson process with rate A. Whenever a new customer arrives, any customer in the system immediately departs. A new arrival enters...
-
Question 8 A national survey of 600 Formula One fans was conducted to learn if they can afford the Austin Cota F1 race tickets. Use the data from the excel file to solve the following. What's the...
-
Could you please check and send me the last results, because the system announced the wrong answer. Thanks Question 1 George was offered two options for a car he was purchasing: Lease option: Pay...
-
Provide excel file showing calculations. Your firm which is headquartered in US is considering a 5-year international project, an addition of new product line to your existing product lines in...
-
Provide a few individual examples who revealed what aspects of emotional intelligence?
-
Borrowing money may be necessary for business expansion. However, too much borrowed money can also mean trouble. Are developing countries tending to borrow more? A random sample of 20 developing...
-
The systolic blood pressure of individuals is thought to be related to both age and weight. For a random sample of 11 men, the following data were obtained: (a) Generate summary statistics, including...
-
Wild irises are beautiful flowers found throughout the United States, Canada, and northern Europe. This problem concerns the length of the sepal (leaf-like part covering the flower) of different...
-
7. A teacher working for the City of Lights earns vacation pay of $2,000 during 2008. However, the vacation will not be taken until the end of 2009. In the government-wide financial statements for...
-
8. Assume in question 7 that the teacher takes the vacation late in 2009 and is paid the entire $2,000. What journal entry is reported in creating each of the two types of financial statements?
-
5. A landfill is scheduled to be filled to capacity over a 10-year period. However, at the end of the first year of operations, the landfill is only 7 percent filled. How much liability for closure...
![Mobile App Logo](https://dsd5zvtm8ll6.cloudfront.net/includes/images/mobile/finalLogo.png)
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App