Question: Jill hears a voice even when no-one is talking to her. The voice in her head tells her she has been a bad girl and

Jill hears a voice even when no-one is talking to her. The voice in her head tells her she has been a bad girl and will be punished severely.

Jill tells her voice she is very sorry and does not want to be punished.

Her voice tells her someone must be punished for her badness.

Jill beats her younger sister with a cricket bat handle till he is unconscious.

As a result Jill is arrested and charged.

At the police station, Jill tells the police she had 'to obey the voice', the voice gives her 'no other choice'. There's 'never any other choice'.

Can Jill use the excuse of insanity as a defence?

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer
Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image
Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock
Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related Law Questions!

Q:

This text was adapted by The Saylor Foundation under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 License without attribution as requested by the work's original creator or licensee. 1...

Q:

Case Study: please someone should help me answer my case study assignment. thank you 1. What do you do when one of your small competitors pulls out its big gun? 2. "Do you really think people will...

Q:

Thoughts on what an outstanding HR manager would do to prevent this problem from happening in the first place and what intervention they should use at this point in these situations to improve and...

Q:

\f 134 THE BIG SQUEEZE munications Workers of America that has sought to unionize high"tech workers. "They hire whomever Microsoft tells them to put on their payroll. Then they p~ocess their...

Q:

\f 134 THE BIG SQUEEZE munications Workers of America that has sought to unionize high"tech workers. "They hire whomever Microsoft tells them to put on their payroll. Then they p~ocess their...

Q:

PRE Misery (1).pdf X C File | C:/Users/camil/Downloads/Misery%20(1).pdf Summertime Soun... My Drive - Google... MLA Citation Gener... WNC Canvas Math textbook Desmos | Graphing... History 111 eBook...

Q:

Unit 3.2 Discussion - Exploring Characterization and Drafting a Thesis Choose Jesse Turblatt's character from the short story "Welcome to your Authentic Indian Experience" ? in this unit by...

Q:

LaDonna Powell My first day in the field was not great. I was put with this guy. He was an older white guy. And he was very nice to me but very mean to the people we were screening going onto the...

Q:

the language to do out this code is python. Create a dictionary to count the number of words in the book. Use the stop_words_english to remove any stop words found in the book. Remove all...

Q:

I need the answer of this article- the name of article is Kim Jong un life under. please give answer. The Washington Post LIFE UNDER KIM JONG UN Recent North Korean escapees relate how the secretive...

Q:

1. The subject property is a 5-year-old warehouse with an economic life of 50 years when new. A comparable warehouse in the area sold for $1,200,000. The comparable is identical to the subject in all...

Q:

The Mitchell Company needs to raise $50 million of new equity capital. Its common stock is currently selling for $50 per share. The investment bankers require an underwriting spread of 3% of the...

Q:

Find two positive integers such that their sum is 9 0 , and ( a ) maximize and ( b ) minimize the sum of their squares. The two positive integers that maximize the sum of their squares are 4 5 0 The...

Q:

Plot contours of the function f (u, v) = u 3r at f = 0, 1,2,3 and 4. The axes, contours and graph should be appropriately labelled. [10 Marks)

Q:

What date or event does the profession believe should be used in determining the value of a stock option? Please discuss the arguments that support this position. ALSO, As it relates to securities,...

Q:

What do many organizations use to schedule and coordinate changes for information systems? Question 2 3 options: A . Impact analysis B . Backout plans C . Maintenance windows D . Version control

Q:

4. Give examples of how a communication situation can change from a win-lose to a winwin situation.

Q:

3. Why is the following statement, If the Church is a context, it is because it is inside our heads, correct?

Q:

1. Discuss the following statements: a) Jeppe drinks because Holberg (the author) forced him to. b) When the soup you are served tastes bad, complain to the cookbook publisher. c) The purpose of an...