Note two differences from the video: Wagons have FOUR wheels. (In contrast to one brownie per sundae.) Also, in this case there are tax-rate differences between the two divisions. In the video lectures, I pointed out that the company as a whole doesnt care what the TP is if there are no tax implications. But in this case there are. The company will want to move (legallyusing a TP within the range) income to the lowest-tax country. (See pp. 784-786 of text for more help if needed.)

Wagonco has two divisions: Wheels and Wagons. Each wagon needs four wheels. Fixed costs = 0.

	Wheels	Wagons
Sales/Market Price	$5 per wheel	$50 per wagon
VC	$3 per wheel	$22.50 per wagon, not including the cost of wheels (four wheels per wagon)
Items sold to outside market	2,250 wheels per month	800 per month
Capacity	5,000 wheels per month	800 per month

1. If there were no tax implications, what range of transfer prices would instill goal congruence?
2. If the Wheel division is in Canada, where the marginal tax rate is 23%, and the Wagon division is in the U.S., where the marginal tax rate is 34%, what transfer price (within the range you identified in #1) will the company prefer?
3. Calculate the tax savings to the company if it uses the transfer price you calculated in #3 instead of the transfer price at the opposite end of the range you calculated in #1.

Note two differences from the video: Wagons have FOUR wheels. (In contrast to one brownie per sundae.) Also, in this case there are tax-rate differences between the two divisions. In the video lectures, I pointed out that the company as a whole doesnt care what the TP is if there are no tax implications. But in this case there are. The company will want to move (legallyusing a TP within the range) income to the lowest-tax country. (See pp. 784-786 of text for more help if needed.)

Wagonco has two divisions: Wheels and Wagons. Each wagon needs four wheels. Fixed costs = 0.

	Wheels	Wagons
Sales/Market Price	$5 per wheel	$50 per wagon
VC	$3 per wheel	$22.50 per wagon, not including the cost of wheels (four wheels per wagon)
Items sold to outside market	2,250 wheels per month	800 per month
Capacity	5,000 wheels per month	800 per month

1. If there were no tax implications, what range of transfer prices would instill goal congruence?
2. If the Wheel division is in Canada, where the marginal tax rate is 23%, and the Wagon division is in the U.S., where the marginal tax rate is 34%, what transfer price (within the range you identified in #1) will the company prefer?
3. Calculate the tax savings to the company if it uses the transfer price you calculated in #3 instead of the transfer price at the opposite end of the range you calculated in #1.