Question: please solve the question of the given case for me as soon as possible Can Judges Really Assess Credibility ? When the only evidence in

please solve the question of the given case for me as soon as possible

please solve the question of the given case for me as soon

Can Judges Really Assess Credibility ? When the only evidence in a case is the testimony of the mosaic . In a 2003 program called " The Challenge of Diver - disputing parties , the case becomes a " credibility contest . " sity , " the N'T grappled with this challenge for adjudicators The judge has to assess the credibility of the witnesses and The presentation pointed out that " access to justice will be decide whose version seems more reasonable . ( Most trials\\ diminished if the adjudicator fails to recognize and deal with are heard by a judge without a jury . ! Credibility includes both* such issues as : cultural difference ; language; disability; sys- truthfulness and reliability . One person may not have seen or* temic discrimination . " heard clearly , may not remember well , or may have observed only part of an event . Even though a witness is honest , his QUESTIONS TO CONSIDER testimony might not be reliable . It is widely accepted in the legal system that the trial 1 . if judges are no better than average at assessing the judge is in the best position to assess the witnesses' cred - truthfulness of witnesses , what are the implications ibility . Lawyers and judges seem to believe that years of for the interpretation of contracts in which the par- experience on the bench equip judges to evaluate witnesses" ties" testimony conflicts and there is no independent credibility better than most people can . Even appeal courts Evidence ? hesitate to question a trial judge's assessment because the 2 . How do you think judges , who , like all of us , have their judge had the opportunity to see and hear the witnesses own inherent (and perhaps unconscious ) biases , can and observe their demeanour . However , recent social science* better assess testimony in a diverse society like Canada ?" research does not support this belief . In particular , studies have shown that judges are no 3 . What steps might a business person take to reduce the better than average at assessing the truthfulness of wit - likelihood of problems in interpreting contracts ?" nesses . Also interesting in our increasingly diverse Canadian* Sources : Alvin Esau , " Credibility and Culture , " Comments at Judi- society , researchers have pointed out cultural differences cial Workshop , September 24, 1988, www. "manitoba. caifaculties ! in people's behaviour that may affect perceptions of cred - law` / Courses/esquilegal_ sistunits_culture. html; George Thompson, ibility . If the judge was raised in the belief that looking an " The Challenge of Diversity , " National Judicial Institute , COBA authority straight in the eye is a sign of truth- telling , and the Conference , November 6, 2003 , available online at www. soar. on . call witness was raised in the belief that downcast eyes show COBA` ZO P a per's ! Thompson . pdf . SEE also MY. Justice I.D. Rooke, respect - or Vice versa - the judge may misinterpret the wit - "Assessing Credibility in Arbitrations and in Court : A Difficult Task ness's demeanour and wrongly assess his credibility , without* for Judge , Jury or Arbitrator('s ), " Presentation to Canadian Bar having any conscious bias against the Witness . itssociation , Edmonton, AB, March 20, 19:50, as discussed in "ASSESSING The National Judicial Institute IN ! ! ) seems to be paying the Credibility of Witnesses : A Practical Guide," Council of Canadian Administrative Tribunal's Conference, June 1 1, 2000, W` Chat- Clad.org !" attention to the issue of assessing credibility in a multicultural download s /conference_ text . puff

Step by Step Solution

There are 3 Steps involved in it

1 Expert Approved Answer
Step: 1 Unlock blur-text-image
Question Has Been Solved by an Expert!

Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts

Step: 2 Unlock
Step: 3 Unlock

Students Have Also Explored These Related Law Questions!