Problem: Constructive eviction is a legal doctrine by which a landlord who substantially interferes with a tenant's use and enjoyment of the premises will be considered to have evicted the tenant. Such a landlord cannot collect rent from the tenant. In this connection, Isabel signed a lease for an apartment owned by Carolyn. A clause in the lease stated that all tenants must keep noise to a minimum during evening hours. After moving in, Isabel found that another tenant played his stereo all night long at ear-splitting levels. Carolyn declined to enforce the noise clause in the lease. After one week without sleep, Isabel moved out, and Carolyn now sues Isabel for rent. There are two controlling cases in this jurisdiction: Evaluate the arguments from analogy contained in the dialogue between Jason andTalisa.

Question: First, identify the primary and secondary analogues in each analogy and coun-teranalogy. Next, list the similarities between the primary and secondary analogues andnote their relevance to the conclusion. Add any additional similarities you can think of. Finally, identify the disanalogies associated with each analogy or counteranalogy andevaluate their effectiveness in destroying the original analogy