QUESTION $1$

$(20$ Marks$)$

"Strategic Human Resource Development $($SHRD$)$ has a responsibility to provide strategies, training, and development opportunities to help organisations and their employees to achieve their business goals $($Tseng and McLean, $2007)."$

Based on the information presented in the article, critically discuss the extent to which SAA's approach to Human Resource Development $($HRD$)$ is strategic.

QUESTION $2$

$(20$ Marks$)$

The report by the German Federal Bureau of Aircraft Accident Investigation includes an evaluation of the training that the SAA pilots, who temporarily lost control of the Airbus $340-346$ on the Johannesburg$-$Frankfurt flight, underwent. Based on the information presented in the article, critically discuss the German Federal Bureau of Aircraft Accident Investigation's evaluation of the SAA pilots' training from the perspective of Kirkpatrick's evaluation framework.