(Question 1)Patty owns Baba O'Reilly Farm, a permitted swine operation in Bladen County. Patty is sued...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
(Question 1)Patty owns Baba O'Reilly Farm, a permitted swine operation in Bladen County. Patty is sued by Ryan, his neighbor, for nuisance. The judge in the case - the Honorable Keith Moon - denies Patty's motion to dismiss based on North Carolina's Right to Farm statute and allows the case to continue. At trial, Ryan introduces no evidence of Patty's waste management technology, nor did Patty raise use of waste management technology as a defense. Judge Moon issues a jury instruction that makes no mention of waste management technology in his charge to the jury to determine the reasonableness of Patty's farming activity and its resulting harm to Ryan. The jury enters a nuisance verdict against Patty, requiring Patty to pay money damages to Ryan but allowing Pete to continue operating his swine farm. Patty timely files an appeal of the verdict to the North Carolina Court of Appeals. After filing his appeal, Patty enters a cooperative agreement with Smithfield and Duke Energy to install a methane digester over his hog lagoon, which studies suggest may reduce odor, which was the foundation of Ryan's nuisance complaint. In his appellate brief and oral argument, Patty argues that the Court should reverse the trial verdict because studies have shown that his new technology is shown to reduce odor. What is the appeals court required to do? a) Reverse and remand back to trial court, because Patty's new evidence of better technology may result in a different verdict b) Affirm the verdict, if the Court of Appeals finds no error in Judge Moon's decision to not allow the Right to Farm statute as a defense (Question 2) Bjorn operates a farm in Hyde County, NC and signs a contract with Ivar's Applications, LLC - a company organized under the laws of Virginia with its sole office in Wakefield, Virginia - for an aerial pesticide application to Bjorn's soybean crop. Ivar mistakenly applies the wrong pesticide to the crop, fully destroying the soybean crop which- under current market conditions and normal county yield history - would likely gross $100,000. Bjorn feels he has a state common law breach of contract claim for that amount. Which court below may not exercise jurisdiction over the case? a) Hyde County Superior Court b) Hyde County District Court (Question 1)Patty owns Baba O'Reilly Farm, a permitted swine operation in Bladen County. Patty is sued by Ryan, his neighbor, for nuisance. The judge in the case - the Honorable Keith Moon - denies Patty's motion to dismiss based on North Carolina's Right to Farm statute and allows the case to continue. At trial, Ryan introduces no evidence of Patty's waste management technology, nor did Patty raise use of waste management technology as a defense. Judge Moon issues a jury instruction that makes no mention of waste management technology in his charge to the jury to determine the reasonableness of Patty's farming activity and its resulting harm to Ryan. The jury enters a nuisance verdict against Patty, requiring Patty to pay money damages to Ryan but allowing Pete to continue operating his swine farm. Patty timely files an appeal of the verdict to the North Carolina Court of Appeals. After filing his appeal, Patty enters a cooperative agreement with Smithfield and Duke Energy to install a methane digester over his hog lagoon, which studies suggest may reduce odor, which was the foundation of Ryan's nuisance complaint. In his appellate brief and oral argument, Patty argues that the Court should reverse the trial verdict because studies have shown that his new technology is shown to reduce odor. What is the appeals court required to do? a) Reverse and remand back to trial court, because Patty's new evidence of better technology may result in a different verdict b) Affirm the verdict, if the Court of Appeals finds no error in Judge Moon's decision to not allow the Right to Farm statute as a defense (Question 2) Bjorn operates a farm in Hyde County, NC and signs a contract with Ivar's Applications, LLC - a company organized under the laws of Virginia with its sole office in Wakefield, Virginia - for an aerial pesticide application to Bjorn's soybean crop. Ivar mistakenly applies the wrong pesticide to the crop, fully destroying the soybean crop which- under current market conditions and normal county yield history - would likely gross $100,000. Bjorn feels he has a state common law breach of contract claim for that amount. Which court below may not exercise jurisdiction over the case? a) Hyde County Superior Court b) Hyde County District Court
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Answer Question 1 a Reverse and remand back to trial court because Pattys new evidence of better tec... View the full answer
Related Book For
The Legal Environment of Business A Critical Thinking Approach
ISBN: 978-0132664844
6th Edition
Authors: Nancy K Kubasek, Bartley A Brennan, M Neil Browne
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
Question (700 words) John Densmore, a law student and part-time musician, was seriously injured in a car accident. The other car's driver, Ray Manzarek, a renowned life motivation coach and a...
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
1- The z-axis carries filamentary current of 10. A. Find Hat (-3,74,0) ? p= = = 2- The Y-axis carries filamentary current of 10 A. Find H at (-3,4,1) ? p= ,= = p= , = H p= 3- The X-axis carries...
-
The position of a buyer of a credit default swap is similar to the position of someone who is long a risk-free bond and short a corporate bond. Explain this statement.
-
Using a 10% interest rate, compute B in the diagram. 400 300 200 100 2B 3B 4B
-
The boundary condition corresponding to the free end of a bar in longitudinal vibration is given by a. \(u(0, t)=0\) b. \(\frac{\partial u}{\partial x}(0, t)=0\) c. \(A E \frac{\partial u}{\partial...
-
Word Wizard is a publishing company with a number of different book lines. Each line has contracts with a number of different authors. The company also owns a printing operation called Quick Press....
-
Explore the concept of signals in process management. How do processes handle signals, and what precautions should be taken to avoid race conditions and signal misinterpretation ?
-
Explain the Concept of International Law according to Jeremy Bentham's statement: "The end that a disinterested legislator upon international law would propose to himself would ... be the greatest...
-
A system that uses the Banker's Algorithm has six processes and four types of reusable resources (R1, R2, R3 and R4). The current allocation, maximum needs (claims) and available resources are as...
-
How does the use of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) in the creation of intellectual property impact traditional notions of copyright and patent law?
-
How can faculty ascertain whether the curriculum framework is providing adequate structure to support decisions faculty make regarding curriculum development and implementation?2. What are effective...
-
What leaders or leader do you think the instWhat leaders or leader do you think the instructor is talking about?ructor is talking about?
-
What you are really writing about is theperformancewhich you saw. You are writing about the work that the actors have done onstage. You are writing about the technical elements of the production. You...
-
a) Name a distinctive characteristic of services and explain how marketers have attempted to manage it. b) Based on the classification of services, what types of services are more likely to be...
-
Write out the formula for the total costs of carrying and ordering inventory, and then use the formula to derive the EOQ model. Andria Mullins, financial manager of Webster Electronics, has been...
-
A pattern is not intended to represent a model for a complete system. Explain.
-
Why is it important that each pattern must focus on one specific problem?
-
Why is it important to decompose a system into individual components?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App