Question: Read the PDF article below, then answer the questions in the dropbox on Canvas. Grading for this assignment is based on your demonstration of an
Read the PDF article below, then answer the questions in the dropbox on Canvas. Grading for this assignment is based on your demonstration of an understanding of the ethical guidelines in the reading and lecture. Failure to legally analyze and defend with ethical evidence will result in no credit. 1. Consider the following hypothetical situation. Ms. Fillmore is representing Mr. Smith, who has been charged with receiving stolen property. Specifically, Mr. Smith was caught moving a television set from a junked car into the back seat of his Pontiac. The case hinges on whether Mr. Smith knew that the television set was stolen property. Ms. Fillmore plans to argue to the jury that if Mr. Smith had known the television set was stolen, he would have hidden it in the trunk of his Pontiac, and not placed it in the back seat. In fact, Ms. Fillmore is aware that the trunk of the Pontiac was broken, and would not open. What is Ms. Fillmore's ethical duty in this situation? Does Ms. Fillmore have an ethical duty to reveal this fact to the court? or is it the responsibility of the prosecution to discover it on its own? Provide legal justifications for your positions. 2. Is a defense attorney ethically obliged to represent a client who has committed a crime? or will commit a future crime? Provide legal justifications for your positions. 3. What would be the consequences to justice in the U.S., if public defenders could decide not to represent defendants because of their presumed guilt? Provide legal argumentation for your positions. Cite all sources consulted to provide a thorough
Step by Step Solution
There are 3 Steps involved in it
Get step-by-step solutions from verified subject matter experts
