Select one of these articles to evaluate.

• A Fly in the Buttermilk: Descriptions of University Life by Successful Black Undergraduate Students at a Predominately White Southeastern University
• The Impact of High School Teacher Behaviors on Student Aggression
• Why do Teachers Not Practice What They Believe Regarding Technology Integration?

Image source: https://www.coe.int/en/web/eurimages/-/external-evaluation-of-eurimages

Also attached are ten evaluation criteria questions for you to use in your Power Point presentation.

In order to receive full credit

1) a Power Point presentation in which you evaluate this article using the ten criteria provided

2) One slide per criterion.

3) Provide detailed responses with specific examples from the article. One-word answers will not suffice.

4) Include the title of the article you selected on the first slide

Project 6 Evaluation questions

Qualitative Designs

1. What is the foreshadowed problem and how clearly is it stated?

Is it formulated later on, after some initial data have been collected?

1. Is the conceptual and theoretical framework for the study clear?

How well does the literature review argue for the importance of the current research?

1. What are the biases and preconceived ideas of the researcher?

How are these dealt with in the study? Is the researcher well prepared to complete the study?

1. Is the method of selecting participants clear and appropriate to the foreshadowed problem? How well are the participants and sites described?

1. How involved was the researcher in the setting being observed?

Could this involvement have affected the behavior of the participants?

1. If appropriate, were multiple methods of data collection used?

What was the duration and intensity of data collection?

1. Are issues of credibility directly addressed by the researchers?

How, and how effectively?

1. Are the findings presented clearly? Are the data sufficiently detailed to allow a rich description? Are results accompanied by illustrative quotes and specific instances?

1. Do conclusions and interpretations follow logically from the results presented?

1. Is sufficient detail provided to discern which parts of the study might be applicable to other settings? To which contexts is the study transferable?

Answer rating: 100% (QA)

Given the options you provided I will evaluate the article A Fly in the Buttermilk Descriptions of University Life by Successful Black Undergraduate Students at a Predominately White Southeastern Univ... View the full answer