Share your thoughts on the descriptions of coaching versus mentoring. Discuss which technique you personally find more
Question:
- Share your thoughts on the descriptions of coaching versus mentoring.
- Discuss which technique you personally find more helpful, incorporating your peers' example scenarios if possible.
- Provide insights on your peers' scenarios (below)
Coaching and mentoring are two different ways to help someone improve at their job, but they focus on different things. Coaching is all about helping someone get better at specific tasks right now. It's like having a personal trainer for your job, giving you tips and tricks to do better in the short term. Mentoring, however, is more like having a wise friend who helps you think about your whole career and where you want to go in the long run. Mentors give advice and support that can help you grow over time, not just on one project or task (Garvey & Stokes, 2021).
When coaching is better: Imagine a new person at a company needs to learn how to manage a big project that's due soon. Coaching is perfect for this situation because it can give them the specific advice they need to do well quickly.
When mentoring is better: On the other hand, if someone wants to move up in their company over the next few years, mentoring is a better choice. Let's say this person is good at their technical job but wants to become a manager someday. A mentor can help them understand what they need to do to get there, offering advice and support along the way. This is more about long-term goals and growing in your career, not just doing well on one project.
These examples show why it's important to choose the right approach, coaching or mentoring, based on what you need help with. Coaching is great for quick, task-focused advice, while mentoring is best for long-term career advice and growth (Kopp, 2023).
Systems analysis and design in a changing world
ISBN: 978-1423902287
5th edition
Authors: John W. Satzinger, Robert B. Jackson, Stephen D. Burd