PART III: CASE ANALYSIS. Total sanay kang nagpapaliwanag, pwes ilahad mo ang lahat, yong wala kang...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
PART III: CASE ANALYSIS. Total sanay kang nagpapaliwanag, pwes ilahad mo ang lahat, yong wala kang tinatago. CASE I The National Development Company (NDC) sold five of its vessels in 1988 to the private respondents therein pursuant to a government privatization. The NDC is a VAT-registered and the activity is leasing out PERSONAL property. The NDC did not pay the VAT on its sale due to the reason that it is for government purposes. The commissioner of internal revenue questioned the nonpayment of tax and assessed the NDC a VAT payable plus interest, penalties and surcharges. The NDC countered it by filing a motion of reconsideration in the court of tax appeals. (Actual Tax case) Is the commissioner correct on its assessment? Explain. If you are the court of tax appeal, what will be your decision regarding the case of NDC? Explain. CASE II St. Luke's Medical Center Inc., is a non-stock, non-profit hospital. The BIR assessed St. Luke's based on the argument that all of the St. Luke's income be subject to 10% tax. St Luke's countered by saying that its free services to patients was 65% of its operating income and that no part of its income inures to the benefit of any individual. The issue is the income of non- profit hospitals be exempted from business tax instead subject to 10% preferential rate. Among both parties, who is correct? State why. If you are the court of tax appeals, will you entertain the counter action of the St. Luke's and favor the government? Why or why not? PART III: CASE ANALYSIS. Total sanay kang nagpapaliwanag, pwes ilahad mo ang lahat, yong wala kang tinatago. CASE I The National Development Company (NDC) sold five of its vessels in 1988 to the private respondents therein pursuant to a government privatization. The NDC is a VAT-registered and the activity is leasing out PERSONAL property. The NDC did not pay the VAT on its sale due to the reason that it is for government purposes. The commissioner of internal revenue questioned the nonpayment of tax and assessed the NDC a VAT payable plus interest, penalties and surcharges. The NDC countered it by filing a motion of reconsideration in the court of tax appeals. (Actual Tax case) Is the commissioner correct on its assessment? Explain. If you are the court of tax appeal, what will be your decision regarding the case of NDC? Explain. CASE II St. Luke's Medical Center Inc., is a non-stock, non-profit hospital. The BIR assessed St. Luke's based on the argument that all of the St. Luke's income be subject to 10% tax. St Luke's countered by saying that its free services to patients was 65% of its operating income and that no part of its income inures to the benefit of any individual. The issue is the income of non- profit hospitals be exempted from business tax instead subject to 10% preferential rate. Among both parties, who is correct? State why. If you are the court of tax appeals, will you entertain the counter action of the St. Luke's and favor the government? Why or why not?
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
Tax law is a complex and nuanced field that stands at the intersection of legal principle public policy and economic reality It involves the interpretation of statutes regulations and case law all of ... View the full answer
Related Book For
Income Tax Fundamentals 2013
ISBN: 9781285586618
31st Edition
Authors: Gerald E. Whittenburg, Martha Altus Buller, Steven L Gill
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
The following additional information is available for the Dr. Ivan and Irene Incisor family from Chapters 1-5. Ivan's grandfather died and left a portfolio of municipal bonds. In 2012, they pay Ivan...
-
Explain the meaning of the terms emoluments, employments and office for the purposes of PAYE as you earn systems. 2. Explain the actual receipts basis of assessing the emoluments from the employment...
-
What would a profile look like across a restraining bend? Releasing bend?
-
What is Father Prior's strategy for achieving his vision? What competitive advantage might Mystic Monk Coffee's strategy produce?
-
Draw the shear and moment diagrams forbeam. 50 Ib/ft 200 Ib - ft 9 t ft
-
You are working for a car-battery manufacturer, and your boss complains that to be more competitive, the company needs to produce batteries that will last longer while minimizing the amount of metal...
-
The standard direct labor cost per unit for a company was $7 (= $28 per hour 0.25 hours per unit). During the period, actual direct labor costs amounted to $45,000, 1,600 labor-hours were worked,...
-
The formula of a compound is Y3(PO4)2. The electronic configuration of the atom of Y is 15. A. 2.8.2 B. 2.8.3 C 2.8.4 16. D. 2.8.5 The atomic numbers and mass numbers of atoms, W, X, Y and Z are...
-
This is a case we worked on during the Annual AICPA Accounting and Tax Conference in Washington DC a few years ago. It is a fairly complicated case that took my team a while to figure out. I believe...
-
If an interrupt handler executes for too long and the next interrupt occurs before the last call to the handler has finished, what happens?
-
Use a cycle-accurate CPU simulator to determine the execution time of a program.
-
Write a C code for a state machine that implements a four-cycle handshake.
-
In five years, you will have to pay a single and deterministic liability, amounting to \(\$ 10,000\). The only asset you may use is a bond paying a \(7 \%\) annual coupon and maturing in six years....
-
You are designing a system a bus-based computer: the input device I1 sends its data to program P1; P1 sends its output to output device O1. Is there any way to overlap bus transfers and computations...
-
Ayelik Enterprise conducts budget studies for 2020. The entity plans its annual budget in quarterly periods. The sales quantities and prices planned by the business for 2020 are as follows. Q1 Q2 Q3...
-
Use integration by parts to evaluate the following. Check your answer by taking the derivative. x2e-xdx
-
Larry and Lisa Williams, both 33 years old, have been married for 9 years. They live at 638 Arctic Way, Fairbanks, AK 99701. Lisa's Social Security number is 445- 81-1423 and Larry's is 798-09-8526....
-
Sherry Hopson owns a retail family clothing store. Her store is located at 4321 Circle Drive, Houston, TX 77001. Her employer identification number is 95- 1234321 and her Social Security number is...
-
The following additional information is available for the Dr. Ivan and Irene Incisor family from Chapters 1-7. Ivan sold the following securities during the year and received a Form 1099-B that...
-
A sodium atom in the \(3 p\) state emits a photon, decreasing the energy of the atom by \(2.10 \mathrm{eV}\). By how much does the orbital angular momentum of the atom change? Does it increase or...
-
Assume instead that the spot exchange rate between the dollar and Swiss franc is a fixed or pegged rate within a narrow band around a central rate. For each change shown in Problem 9, assume that...
-
A 1.5 V D-cell battery is rated at \(15,000 \mathrm{~mA} \cdot \mathrm{h}\). For how long could such a battery power a flashlight bulb rated at \(1.5 \mathrm{~W}\) ?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App