Starbucks's Corporate Social Responsibility Journey Starting with a single store in Seattle in 1971, Starbucks grew...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Starbucks's Corporate Social Responsibility Journey Starting with a single store in Seattle in 1971, Starbucks grew to 30,000 stores worldwide with revenues of $25 billion in 2019. Since its 1987 pur- chase by Howard Schultz, Starbucks has positioned itself as a company that, in the words of Schultz, "puts people first and profits last." In the 1990s, it created a corporate social responsibility (CSR) department and named a senior vice president for CSR. Since 2001, Starbucks-in addition to its tra- ditional Annual Report to Shareholders-has been publishing a Global Corporate Social Responsibility Annual Report, whose title changed to Global Social Impact Report in 2017. Running hundreds of pages, the Global Social Impact Report is available in nine languages. Yet, for a company so serious about CSR, it has become a perpetual target for CSR activists. Episode 1: Fair Trade In 2000, Global Exchange, a nongovernmental organization (NGO) promoting the idea of "Fair Trade," launched a campaign against Starbucks. The Fair Trade movement advocated a minimum "fair" price of $1.26 per pound to ensure a "living wage" for coffee producers-regardless of the highly volatile market price, which was only 64 cents per pound at that time. Global Exchange activists demonstrated in front of a San Francisco Starbucks store after a local TV station aired a clip on child labor on Guatemalan coffee farms. A few days later, during Starbucks's shareholders meeting, Global Exchange activists took the microphone and demanded that Starbucks offer Fair Trade coffee. Things got heated and the activists were physically removed from the meeting. After rounds of protests and negotiations, Starbucks eventually agreed to sell Fair Trade coffee in its domestic stores. Soon it became the largest US purchaser of Fair Trade coffee, purchasing 20 million pounds (6% of its coffee purchases). In addition, Starbucks launched Coffee and Farmer Equity (CAFE) guidelines, with inspectors, to "ensure the sustainable supply of high quality coffee, achieve economic accountability, pro- mote social responsibility within the coffee supply chain, and protect the environment." By 2009, Star- bucks had purchased 77% of its coffee from CAFE suppliers. However, Global Exchange continued to be unhappy, demanding that Starbucks serve Fair Trade coffee once a week instead of once a month (the current practice). Although Global Exchange acknowledged CAFE to be a "launching point for improvements," it "in no way reduces our initial and still unmet demands." Episode 2: UK Tax In 2012, news broke out that since entering the United Kingdom in 1998, Starbucks, despite its thriving business, had paid only 0.3% of its sales of 3 billion ($4 billion) for UK corporation tax between 1998 and 2011 for a total of 8.6 million payment. The tax rate should be 24%. Starbucks Coffee Company (UK) Ltd. claimed to be losing money. However, the parent company informed investors that the subsidiary was profitable. Such news triggered a media storm, store pickets, and consumer boycotts. Starbucks executives were yanked before the UK Parliament to explain such behavior. It turned out that such tax-avoidance behavior was legal. The parent company set up a European headquarters in the Netherlands, where it needed to pay a combined Dutch and US tax rate of 16%-as opposed to the 24% in the UK. After paying a 6% royalty of its sales to the European headquar- ters, the UK subsidiary hardly made any money and thus was hardly taxable. "We're not accusing you [Starbucks] of being illegal," thundered a member of Parliament in the public hearing, "we're accusing you of being immoral." Quite a devastating attack on a company that was serious about CSR. Overall, Starbucks was accused of using artificial corporate structures to shift profits and tax burdens from the UK to lower-tax jurisdictions. Facing relentless pressure, Starbucks agreed to voluntarily pay 20 million in additional UK corporation tax. Episode 3: Philadelphia Bathroom Incident In April 2018, two African American college students in a Philadelphia Starbucks store who did not buy any- thing and were waiting for someone else asked to use the bathroom. Instead, the store manager called the police, claiming the two men were trespassing, leading to their arrest. This incident sparked a me- dia firestorm and triggered protests outside Star- bucks stores. CEO Kevin Johnson apologized, and 315 founder and chairman Schultz said in an interview that he was "ashamed" by the incident. Starbucks reached an undisclosed settlement with the two men. In May 2018, it closed all 8,000 US stores for an entire afternoon to provide racial bias training for all employees at a cost of $16.7 million in lost sales. The company clarified that "any person who enters our spaces, including patios, cafes, and restrooms, regardless of whether they make a purchase, is considered a customer." While such an "open bathroom" policy calmed CSR activists down, it came with a heavy cost-not only in terms of extra cleaning cost, but also in terms of lost customers and reduced in-store time for (the paying) customers who do show up. This effect is espe cially large among Starbucks locations close to homeless shelters. Given the large homeless population in many cities, can the "open bathroom" policy be sustainable? Sources (1) BBC, 2012, Starbucks, Google and Amazon grilled over tax avoidance, November 12: www.bbc.com; (2) Business Week, 2007, Saving Starbucks' soul, April 9: 56-61; (3) Forbes, 2019, Starbucks' open bathroom policy comes with heavy cost, November 12: www.forbes.com; (4) PR Week, 2018, Timeline of a crisis, July 6: www.prweek.com; (5) Reuters, 2012, Star- bucks's European tax bill disappears down $100 million hole, November 1: uk.reuters.com; (6) Starbucks, 2018, Global Social Impact Report, www.starbucks.com; (7) Vox, 2018, Starbucks says everyone's a customer after Philadelphia bias incident, May 19: www.vox.com. Starbucks's Corporate Social Responsibility Journey Starting with a single store in Seattle in 1971, Starbucks grew to 30,000 stores worldwide with revenues of $25 billion in 2019. Since its 1987 pur- chase by Howard Schultz, Starbucks has positioned itself as a company that, in the words of Schultz, "puts people first and profits last." In the 1990s, it created a corporate social responsibility (CSR) department and named a senior vice president for CSR. Since 2001, Starbucks-in addition to its tra- ditional Annual Report to Shareholders-has been publishing a Global Corporate Social Responsibility Annual Report, whose title changed to Global Social Impact Report in 2017. Running hundreds of pages, the Global Social Impact Report is available in nine languages. Yet, for a company so serious about CSR, it has become a perpetual target for CSR activists. Episode 1: Fair Trade In 2000, Global Exchange, a nongovernmental organization (NGO) promoting the idea of "Fair Trade," launched a campaign against Starbucks. The Fair Trade movement advocated a minimum "fair" price of $1.26 per pound to ensure a "living wage" for coffee producers-regardless of the highly volatile market price, which was only 64 cents per pound at that time. Global Exchange activists demonstrated in front of a San Francisco Starbucks store after a local TV station aired a clip on child labor on Guatemalan coffee farms. A few days later, during Starbucks's shareholders meeting, Global Exchange activists took the microphone and demanded that Starbucks offer Fair Trade coffee. Things got heated and the activists were physically removed from the meeting. After rounds of protests and negotiations, Starbucks eventually agreed to sell Fair Trade coffee in its domestic stores. Soon it became the largest US purchaser of Fair Trade coffee, purchasing 20 million pounds (6% of its coffee purchases). In addition, Starbucks launched Coffee and Farmer Equity (CAFE) guidelines, with inspectors, to "ensure the sustainable supply of high quality coffee, achieve economic accountability, pro- mote social responsibility within the coffee supply chain, and protect the environment." By 2009, Star- bucks had purchased 77% of its coffee from CAFE suppliers. However, Global Exchange continued to be unhappy, demanding that Starbucks serve Fair Trade coffee once a week instead of once a month (the current practice). Although Global Exchange acknowledged CAFE to be a "launching point for improvements," it "in no way reduces our initial and still unmet demands." Episode 2: UK Tax In 2012, news broke out that since entering the United Kingdom in 1998, Starbucks, despite its thriving business, had paid only 0.3% of its sales of 3 billion ($4 billion) for UK corporation tax between 1998 and 2011 for a total of 8.6 million payment. The tax rate should be 24%. Starbucks Coffee Company (UK) Ltd. claimed to be losing money. However, the parent company informed investors that the subsidiary was profitable. Such news triggered a media storm, store pickets, and consumer boycotts. Starbucks executives were yanked before the UK Parliament to explain such behavior. It turned out that such tax-avoidance behavior was legal. The parent company set up a European headquarters in the Netherlands, where it needed to pay a combined Dutch and US tax rate of 16%-as opposed to the 24% in the UK. After paying a 6% royalty of its sales to the European headquar- ters, the UK subsidiary hardly made any money and thus was hardly taxable. "We're not accusing you [Starbucks] of being illegal," thundered a member of Parliament in the public hearing, "we're accusing you of being immoral." Quite a devastating attack on a company that was serious about CSR. Overall, Starbucks was accused of using artificial corporate structures to shift profits and tax burdens from the UK to lower-tax jurisdictions. Facing relentless pressure, Starbucks agreed to voluntarily pay 20 million in additional UK corporation tax. Episode 3: Philadelphia Bathroom Incident In April 2018, two African American college students in a Philadelphia Starbucks store who did not buy any- thing and were waiting for someone else asked to use the bathroom. Instead, the store manager called the police, claiming the two men were trespassing, leading to their arrest. This incident sparked a me- dia firestorm and triggered protests outside Star- bucks stores. CEO Kevin Johnson apologized, and 315 founder and chairman Schultz said in an interview that he was "ashamed" by the incident. Starbucks reached an undisclosed settlement with the two men. In May 2018, it closed all 8,000 US stores for an entire afternoon to provide racial bias training for all employees at a cost of $16.7 million in lost sales. The company clarified that "any person who enters our spaces, including patios, cafes, and restrooms, regardless of whether they make a purchase, is considered a customer." While such an "open bathroom" policy calmed CSR activists down, it came with a heavy cost-not only in terms of extra cleaning cost, but also in terms of lost customers and reduced in-store time for (the paying) customers who do show up. This effect is espe cially large among Starbucks locations close to homeless shelters. Given the large homeless population in many cities, can the "open bathroom" policy be sustainable? Sources (1) BBC, 2012, Starbucks, Google and Amazon grilled over tax avoidance, November 12: www.bbc.com; (2) Business Week, 2007, Saving Starbucks' soul, April 9: 56-61; (3) Forbes, 2019, Starbucks' open bathroom policy comes with heavy cost, November 12: www.forbes.com; (4) PR Week, 2018, Timeline of a crisis, July 6: www.prweek.com; (5) Reuters, 2012, Star- bucks's European tax bill disappears down $100 million hole, November 1: uk.reuters.com; (6) Starbucks, 2018, Global Social Impact Report, www.starbucks.com; (7) Vox, 2018, Starbucks says everyone's a customer after Philadelphia bias incident, May 19: www.vox.com.
Expert Answer:
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these general management questions
-
The expected costs to make replacements, alterations, or improvements to a building that materially prolong its life and increase its value is referred to as: Question 7 options: a) operating...
-
Complete the reading and view the videos for this module. Review the Tax Communication Ordinary Expense Assignment Tax Communication Ordinary Expense Assignment. Use the fact pattern and resources...
-
Harley-Davidson: Preparing for the Next Century There are very few products that are so exciting that people will tattoo your logo on their body. Richard Teerlink, Retired CEO, Harley-Davidson In...
-
Halemav paid $2 in dividends for each share over the past year and the company is not expected to increase its dividend distribution in the future. The risk free rate is 2% and the risk premium on...
-
A survey of 500 randomly selected high school students determined that 288 played organized sports. (a) What is the probability that a randomly selected high school student plays organized sports?...
-
This project is a continuation of the previous project. Many applications require pseudorandom number sequences that are not uniformly distributed. For example, a program that simulates the birth of...
-
Discuss how boards could best achieve diversity of thought. How does this relate to diversity of the composition of the board?
-
Digital World is a retail store that sells cameras and photography supplies. The firm's credit purchases and purchases returns and allowances transactions for June 2016 appear below, along with the...
-
how and what other reason Government budgets, particularly in the latter part of the fiscal year, can be notoriously tight. My software project, desperately needing funding to get off the ground,...
-
what is Andrea Illy's approach to leadership? What evidence is there to suggest that his approach can be successful? Identify some other business leaders who have similar leadership ideas. Have they...
-
c) A "Valid" XML document is a "Well Formed" XML document, which also conforms to the rules of a Document Type Definition (DTD): John Jane Confirm Remember to buy the Car this weekend! The DOCTYPE...
-
what are he examples of ergonomics programme in the workplace?
-
Puget Sound Divers is a company that provides diving services such as underwater ship repairs to clients in the Puget Sound area. The company's planning budget for May appears below: Puget Sound...
-
Are you courageous enough to abandon a practice that has made you successful in the past? Great leaders dare to be different. They build the emotional stamina to withstand opposition.?
-
On March 1, 2017 Green Company purchased a new piece of equipment for 210,000 cash. On March 1 Green recorded the equipment purchase with a Debit to the Equipment account and a Credit to the Cash...
-
Nicole has asked you to prepare a bank reconciliation for NGS. According to her records, NGS's cash balance is $6,000 at December 31, but the bank reports a balance of $5,500. a. The bank deducted...
-
The area of square PQRS is 100 ft2, and A, B, C, and D are the midpoints of the sides. Find the area of square ABCD. B A
-
The following e-mail with an authentic looking e-mail address and logo was received by the controller of a small business: Required a. What should Justin do about these e-mails? b. What should Big...
-
An accountant employed by the organizing committee for the Atlanta Summer Olympic Games was charged with embezzling approximately \($60,000.\) The money allegedly was used to purchase a used...
-
Zaire Company had a \(\$ 26,000\) net loss from operations. Depreciation expense for the year was \(\$ 9,600\), and a dividend of \(\$ 2,000\) was declared and paid. The balances of the current asset...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App