Steven Light bought a $55,050 wedding ring for his wife, Sherri Light, on credit from Royal...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
Steven Light bought a $55,050 wedding ring for his wife, Sherri Light, on credit from Royal Jewelers, Inc., a store in Fargo, North Dakota. The receipt granted Royal a security interest in the ring. Later, Royal assigned its interest to GRB Financial Corp. Steven and GRB signed a modification agreement changing the repayment terms. An attached exhibit listed the items pledged as security for the modification including the ring. Steven did not separately sign the exhibit. A year later, Steven died. Royal and GRB filed a suit in North Dakota state court against Sherri, alleging that GRB had a valid security interest in the ring. Sherri cited UCC 9-203, under which there is an enforceable interest only if "the debtor has authenticated a security agreement that provides a description of the collateral." Sherri argued that the modification agreement did not "properly authenticate" the description of the collateral, including the ring, because Steven had not signed the attached exhibit. The court issued a judgment in GRB's favor. Sherri appealed. Issue: Was GRB's security interest in the ring valid and enforceable? Decision: Yes. The North Dakota Supreme Court affirmed the lower court's judgment. Questions to answer: 1. Do you agree or disagree with the decision that was made by the courts? Why or why not? 2. Why do you think Sherri felt that she was able to appeal? Was her decision impractical? Why? 3. What implications do you think his death should have since he gave Sherri the ring as a gift? Should she still be responsible to pay the remaining balance? 4. Discuss the ethical implications that you believe are at play with this case Steven Light bought a $55,050 wedding ring for his wife, Sherri Light, on credit from Royal Jewelers, Inc., a store in Fargo, North Dakota. The receipt granted Royal a security interest in the ring. Later, Royal assigned its interest to GRB Financial Corp. Steven and GRB signed a modification agreement changing the repayment terms. An attached exhibit listed the items pledged as security for the modification including the ring. Steven did not separately sign the exhibit. A year later, Steven died. Royal and GRB filed a suit in North Dakota state court against Sherri, alleging that GRB had a valid security interest in the ring. Sherri cited UCC 9-203, under which there is an enforceable interest only if "the debtor has authenticated a security agreement that provides a description of the collateral." Sherri argued that the modification agreement did not "properly authenticate" the description of the collateral, including the ring, because Steven had not signed the attached exhibit. The court issued a judgment in GRB's favor. Sherri appealed. Issue: Was GRB's security interest in the ring valid and enforceable? Decision: Yes. The North Dakota Supreme Court affirmed the lower court's judgment. Questions to answer: 1. Do you agree or disagree with the decision that was made by the courts? Why or why not? 2. Why do you think Sherri felt that she was able to appeal? Was her decision impractical? Why? 3. What implications do you think his death should have since he gave Sherri the ring as a gift? Should she still be responsible to pay the remaining balance? 4. Discuss the ethical implications that you believe are at play with this case
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 I agree with the decision made by the courts While its true that UCC 9203 requires authentication ... View the full answer
Related Book For
South-Western Federal Taxation 2018 Comprehensive
ISBN: 9781337386005
41st Edition
Authors: David M. Maloney, William H. Hoffman, Jr., William A. Raabe, James C. Young
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these law questions
-
Managing Scope Changes Case Study Scope changes on a project can occur regardless of how well the project is planned or executed. Scope changes can be the result of something that was omitted during...
-
In July 2004, Emellie Anderson hired Kenneth Whitten, a licensed building contractor, to construct a two-story addition to her home. The bottom floor was to be a garage and the second floor a home...
-
Provide a brief description of the seven basic steps to use JDBC.
-
As chief lending officer for a bank, you need to decide whether to make a loan to Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, Inc. The current items, listed in alphabetical order, are taken from the...
-
This information is available for Abdullah's Photo Corporation for 2020, 2021, and 2022. Instructions a . Calculate the inventory turnover for 2020, 2021, and 2022. (Round to one decimal place.) b ....
-
The cash flows associated with a project are shown below. The interest rate varies from year to year as shown. Determine an equivalent uniform annual series of cash flows. EOY Cash Flow Interest...
-
The partners in New Yorker Company decide to liquidate the firm when the balance sheet shows the following The partners share income and loss 5 : 3 : 2. During the process of liquidation, the...
-
For the gas station site your firm has been provided a budget of $30,000 to perform a field investigation. Design an investigation to further evaluate the extent of contamination at and downgradient...
-
The combustion of a sample of butane, C4H10 (lighter fluid), produced 2.64 grams of water. 2 C4H10 + 1302 8CO2 + 10H2O a. How many moles of water formed?
-
If you live outside the limits of a city in Texas, water, sewer, sanitation, and electricity services are offered by Question 5 options: a) auxiliary utility districts (AUDs). b) federal utility...
-
(b) Use MATLAB to calculate &=y-X(XX)'X'y and ', where 1 X 1-1-1 - 10 1 1 -1 -1 20 1 - -1 15 1 - -1 and 13 y 1 1 1 -1 - - 1 23 1 24 1 28 11 1 16 Show your final results of and ', as well as the...
-
Let A be the matrix 1 1 1 -2 0-3 4 0 6.5 (a) Let = [100], = [010] and d = [001]. Use Gauss-Jordan elimination, solve the three equations Ax = 6, Ay = and Az = d to find x, y and z. (b) Hence, or...
-
Briefly explain the meaning of moral hazard, and identify two ways in which an insurer can design a policy covering theft to reduce the risk of moral hazard
-
2] Merrick goes to the farmer's market to buy exotic fruit. Last week, he bought 15 rambutan at 20 cents each. This week, rambutan prices increased to 30 cents each, and Merrick buys only 10 rambutan...
-
A share of 5% preferred stock has a par value of $60 and market value of $80. The owners of the preferred stock will receive a dividend of: (Round your answer to the nearest cent.)
-
2.) Find the Laplace transform of f(t) 7e-St cos 2t +9 sinh2 2t. Use Laplace Table. %3D
-
Troy, a cash basis taxpayer, is employed by Eagle Corporation, also a cash basis taxpayer. Troy is a full-time employee of the corporation and receives a salary of $60,000 per year. He also receives...
-
Evan is single and has AGI of $277,300 in 2017. His potential itemized deductions before any limitations for the year total $52,300 and consist of the following: Medical expenses (before the...
-
An S corporations election revocation is effective if it is signed by shareholders owning: a. More than 50% of S corporations voting stock only. b. 50% or more of S corporations voting stock only. c....
-
What is an injunction?
-
What is the main effect of increased use of liability insurance?
-
What are the arguments in favour of imposing a wide liability on professionals?
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App