The article below is a part of the myRA account debate. The funds deposited in myRA/IRA...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
The article below is a part of the myRA account debate. The funds deposited in myRA/IRA accounts are not subject to taxation until withdrawal, which can happen without penalty only after the program participants reach the age of 59. The new retirement account, myRA, would replace the current saver's tax credit with a federal 401k-style match for middle- and low-income workers. 1) according to the system of national accounts that we studied in Lectures 1 and 2, Investment and Saving have different meanings. Explain the difference between how these terms are used in the article vs. in the system of national accounts. The article says "myRA .. was a long-term investment in national saving." However, 2) illustrate the expected effect of the myRA introduction. Label both axes, all curves, and write out expressions for demand and supply of loanable funds. Explain the economic meaning of the slope of the supply curve. To prepare for bonus parts of the exam, you might want to express the slope of each curve using derivatives. Assume supply of loanable funds is inelastic. Using the loanable funds market diagram, 3) Describe how the new equilibrium is different from the old equilibrium. 4) Draw the new loanable funds market diagram and illustrate the expected effect of the myRA introduction. Label both axes, all curves, and write out expressions for demand and supply of loanable funds. Explain the economic meaning of the slope of the supply curve. To prepare for bonus parts of the exam, you might want to express the slope of each curve using derivatives. Relax the assumption of inelastic supply of loanable funds, that is assume supply is elastic. 5) from the equilibrium predicted by your model in part (3). Describe how the new equilibrium is different from the old equilibrium and how it is different 6) and substitution effects and use these terms in your explanation. Why are the slopes of the supply curves you drew in parts (2) and (4) different? Define income 7) Hint: recall our discussion of Mankiw's article on the first day of the course. Do you think the introduction of myRA is a good idea for the US economy? Why? Was myRA Misrepresented? Why the Trump Administration Killed the Program by John Sullivan. Editor-In-Chief January 10, 2019 [T]he reason for the interview, was [Mark Iwry's] role as a principal architect and author of the myRA program, announced during President Obama's State of the Union speech in 2014, only to be discontinued in July 2017. ... Mark Iwry doesn't like certain descriptions of the now defunct, about-to-be-revived myRA program, a high-profile part of the previous administration's attempt to help Americans save. ... The Trump administration justified their decision to cancel based on low adoption and high per- account costs incurred by the government, but Iwry doesn't buy it. ... "What was reported was simply that the Trump Administration looked at the myRA a little over a year after it had launched, and there were only several tens of thousands of accounts that were funded so far." Iwry explains. ... But the myRA, he argues, was a long-term investment in national saving, a starter account designed to play out over many years and be used for a variety of purposes-not to be judged prematurely and terminated based on the first year's activity. One of those purposes was to support the aforementioned federal or state-based auto IRAS. At the time, California was about to enact its auto IRA program; the only hold-up was the need to reach agreement on the type of default investment in which participants would be placed. Rather than delay the program entirely while debating the issue, the California legislation was amended to specify that the everyone who didn't opt out would be invested in "United States Treasuries, myRAs, or similar investments" at least temporarily for up to the first three years of the program. So, a major purpose of the myRA, by 2016, was to serve as a key element of the auto-IRA programs in Oregon, Illinois and California, as requested by those states and probably other states in the future (the auto-IRA was also explicitly required to be offered as an option on state "marketplaces" under legislation signed into law in Washington and New Jersey). "In the first year of the myRA, 2016. our focus at Treasury was mainly on ensuring we had the capacity to meet the very large expected demand from California, Oregon, and Illinois," Iwry explains. "Far from the supposed low numbers, California officials, in accordance with their legislation, made clear to Treasury that they were interested in using the myRA as their temporary placeholder default investment, or sole investment, for up to three years to auto-enroll 6.8 million workers." .. However, in the spring of 2017, the Trump White House and/or Treasury realized (or were told) that continuing to make the myRA available to the states' auto IRA programs would be inconsistent with their intent to sign legislation hostile to those programs. So the Trump Treasury then informed California-as well as Oregon and Illinois-that it was pulling the plug "on the states' plans to promote saving by millions of workings families through myRAs." Shortly after thwarting the states, Treasury announced that the myRA's expected takeup was small and therefore not worth the cost of continuing. "That's the real story of the premature demise of the myRA," Iwry concludes. "It was not the flop they made it out to be. Take-up among those just signing up for it on their own was starting slow, but the key point was that, but for Treasury's intervention, millions of myRAs were about to be deployed to help working families start saving in California and other states." The article below is a part of the myRA account debate. The funds deposited in myRA/IRA accounts are not subject to taxation until withdrawal, which can happen without penalty only after the program participants reach the age of 59. The new retirement account, myRA, would replace the current saver's tax credit with a federal 401k-style match for middle- and low-income workers. 1) according to the system of national accounts that we studied in Lectures 1 and 2, Investment and Saving have different meanings. Explain the difference between how these terms are used in the article vs. in the system of national accounts. The article says "myRA .. was a long-term investment in national saving." However, 2) illustrate the expected effect of the myRA introduction. Label both axes, all curves, and write out expressions for demand and supply of loanable funds. Explain the economic meaning of the slope of the supply curve. To prepare for bonus parts of the exam, you might want to express the slope of each curve using derivatives. Assume supply of loanable funds is inelastic. Using the loanable funds market diagram, 3) Describe how the new equilibrium is different from the old equilibrium. 4) Draw the new loanable funds market diagram and illustrate the expected effect of the myRA introduction. Label both axes, all curves, and write out expressions for demand and supply of loanable funds. Explain the economic meaning of the slope of the supply curve. To prepare for bonus parts of the exam, you might want to express the slope of each curve using derivatives. Relax the assumption of inelastic supply of loanable funds, that is assume supply is elastic. 5) from the equilibrium predicted by your model in part (3). Describe how the new equilibrium is different from the old equilibrium and how it is different 6) and substitution effects and use these terms in your explanation. Why are the slopes of the supply curves you drew in parts (2) and (4) different? Define income 7) Hint: recall our discussion of Mankiw's article on the first day of the course. Do you think the introduction of myRA is a good idea for the US economy? Why? Was myRA Misrepresented? Why the Trump Administration Killed the Program by John Sullivan. Editor-In-Chief January 10, 2019 [T]he reason for the interview, was [Mark Iwry's] role as a principal architect and author of the myRA program, announced during President Obama's State of the Union speech in 2014, only to be discontinued in July 2017. ... Mark Iwry doesn't like certain descriptions of the now defunct, about-to-be-revived myRA program, a high-profile part of the previous administration's attempt to help Americans save. ... The Trump administration justified their decision to cancel based on low adoption and high per- account costs incurred by the government, but Iwry doesn't buy it. ... "What was reported was simply that the Trump Administration looked at the myRA a little over a year after it had launched, and there were only several tens of thousands of accounts that were funded so far." Iwry explains. ... But the myRA, he argues, was a long-term investment in national saving, a starter account designed to play out over many years and be used for a variety of purposes-not to be judged prematurely and terminated based on the first year's activity. One of those purposes was to support the aforementioned federal or state-based auto IRAS. At the time, California was about to enact its auto IRA program; the only hold-up was the need to reach agreement on the type of default investment in which participants would be placed. Rather than delay the program entirely while debating the issue, the California legislation was amended to specify that the everyone who didn't opt out would be invested in "United States Treasuries, myRAs, or similar investments" at least temporarily for up to the first three years of the program. So, a major purpose of the myRA, by 2016, was to serve as a key element of the auto-IRA programs in Oregon, Illinois and California, as requested by those states and probably other states in the future (the auto-IRA was also explicitly required to be offered as an option on state "marketplaces" under legislation signed into law in Washington and New Jersey). "In the first year of the myRA, 2016. our focus at Treasury was mainly on ensuring we had the capacity to meet the very large expected demand from California, Oregon, and Illinois," Iwry explains. "Far from the supposed low numbers, California officials, in accordance with their legislation, made clear to Treasury that they were interested in using the myRA as their temporary placeholder default investment, or sole investment, for up to three years to auto-enroll 6.8 million workers." .. However, in the spring of 2017, the Trump White House and/or Treasury realized (or were told) that continuing to make the myRA available to the states' auto IRA programs would be inconsistent with their intent to sign legislation hostile to those programs. So the Trump Treasury then informed California-as well as Oregon and Illinois-that it was pulling the plug "on the states' plans to promote saving by millions of workings families through myRAs." Shortly after thwarting the states, Treasury announced that the myRA's expected takeup was small and therefore not worth the cost of continuing. "That's the real story of the premature demise of the myRA," Iwry concludes. "It was not the flop they made it out to be. Take-up among those just signing up for it on their own was starting slow, but the key point was that, but for Treasury's intervention, millions of myRAs were about to be deployed to help working families start saving in California and other states."
Expert Answer:
Answer rating: 100% (QA)
1 Savings and investment must be equal in value in study of national accounts This is because according to the macroeconomic identity whatever saved is invested However in the article provided it is m... View the full answer
Related Book For
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these economics questions
-
Below is part of payroll controls at your client: - The payroll system takes the hourly rate from each employees master file and multiplies this by the hours entered by employees to calculate gross...
-
The plane frame shown below is part of an elevated freeway system. Supports at A and D are fixed but there are moment releases at the base of both columns (AB and DE), as well near in column BC and...
-
Name three primary market lenders that are not subject to banking regulations?
-
Samples of size n = 5 are collected from a process every half hour. After 50 samples have been collected, we calculate. x = 20.0 and s 1.5. Assume that both charts exhibit control and that the...
-
Explain the information contained in box plots and dot-scale diagrams.
-
How often should standards be revised?
-
For approximately 20 months, Robert E. McDonald perpetrated a scheme to solicit millions of dollars purportedly for a \($100\) million purchase by the RAI Entities and certain other related corporate...
-
Purchase of Equipment with Zero-Interest-Bearing Debt Sterling Inc. has decided to purchase equipment from Central Michigan Industries on January 2, 2010, to expand its production capacity to meet...
-
Antelopes, native to Africa and Asia, range in size from 30 cm to over 180 cm at the shoulder, with most between 90-120 cm. This is related to the humerus length. The data below gives the length and...
-
The worksheet used to produce Figure 23.2 is on the authors web site. How does the loss distribution change when the loss severity has a beta distribution with upper bound of 5, lower bound of zero,...
-
Find the quartic function that is the best fit for the data in the table below. Report the model with three significant digits in the coefficients. X -2 -1 y <
-
Comment on this statement: The risk-based guidelines for commercial banks attempt to gauge the interest rate risk associated with a bank's balance sheet.
-
Describe the basic features of the money multiplier.
-
What is the discount rate, and to what type of action by a bank does it apply?
-
The reactance of a generator, with the nominal specifications of \(14 \mathrm{kV}\) and \(500 \mathrm{MVA}\), is \(1.1 p . u\). Determine its impedance in percent if \(20 \mathrm{kV}\) and \(100...
-
Distinguish between an open market sale and a matched sale (which is the same as a matched sale-purchase transaction or a reverse repurchase agreement).
-
Jenae, a principal in Maryville Corporation, makes a personal guaranty of a $100, 000 loan for Maryville Corporation. Maryville Corporation defaults on the loan with a balance of $85,000. The total...
-
Prove the result that the R 2 associated with a restricted least squares estimator is never larger than that associated with the unrestricted least squares estimator. Conclude that imposing...
-
At the flower shop, where you manage two employees, your employees perform two tasks: caring for the displays of cut flowers and making flower arrangements to fill customer orders. Explain how you...
-
Leo runs a bicycle repair shop. He recently exam-ined information on wage and employment levels and noted that he employs the same number of workers today that he employed in 2009. How-ever, wages...
-
The industry in Figure 13P-5 consists of many firms with identical cost structures, and the industry experiences constant returns to scale. a. Draw the short-run market supply curve. b. Draw the...
-
The relativity of simultaneity. Two clocks are placed at rest on the \(x^{\prime}\) axis of the primed frame, clock A at \(x^{\prime}=0\) and clock B at \(x^{\prime}=L_{0}\). They are therefore a...
-
A primed frame moves at \(V=(3 / 5) c\) relative to an unprimed frame. Just as their origins pass, clocks at the origins of both frames read zero, and a flashbulb explodes at that point. Later, the...
-
Synchronized clocks A and B are at rest in our frame of reference, a distance five light-minutes apart. Clock \(\mathrm{C}\) passes \(\mathrm{A}\) at speed (12/13) \(c\) bound for \(\mathrm{B}\),...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App