True story: fairly recently, an old student of mine who became a high school teacher got...
Fantastic news! We've Found the answer you've been seeking!
Question:
Transcribed Image Text:
True story: fairly recently, an old student of mine who became a high school teacher got back in contact with me to ask a math question. He and a fellow high school teacher were arguing about the equation a+b√2=c+d√2 where a, b, c, d are unknown real numbers (this appeared somewhere in the high school math curriculum for some reason). In particular, his colleague thought that one could immediately conclude that a = c and b=d, which seems reasonable, since seemingly one would "equate similar parts" or something like that. However, there is no obvious algebra rule to settle this, and that's why he contacted me. It's an arithmetic/algebra issue for sure, but it is slightly tricky, as it turns out. (a) First of all, as much as we might be tempted to, we're not allowed to just "equate similar parts" in the above expression, as it is possible to have a+b√2 = c+d√2 but NOT have a = c and b=d! So, your task here is to find real number values for a, b, c, and d for which a +b√2 = c+d√2 but it isn't true that a b=d. = c and [Note: yes, this is very different from things we've done previously. But, as it so happens, it will be very similar to things that are coming up very shortly in this course, so it doesn't hurt to get our feet wet now.] [Hint: play with numbers. Try a nice irrational value for one of the unknowns!] (b) Ah, but it does turn out that things behave well for certain types of numbers. So. prove the following statement with a proof by contradiction: If a +b√2=c+d√2 and a, b, c, d are all integers, then actually a = c and b=d! [Hint: setting up the proof by contradiction requires you to simplify ~ (a = c and b = d) with the help of DeMorgan, so first write that carefully. Then notice that there are actually three possibilities (cases) here, when you think about the meaning of the word "or": it might be that ac, b=d; it might be that a = c, b d; finally, it might be that a c, b + d. Find a contradiction in each case!] [Moral of the story; different types of proof techniques combine in unexpected ways! True story: fairly recently, an old student of mine who became a high school teacher got back in contact with me to ask a math question. He and a fellow high school teacher were arguing about the equation a+b√2=c+d√2 where a, b, c, d are unknown real numbers (this appeared somewhere in the high school math curriculum for some reason). In particular, his colleague thought that one could immediately conclude that a = c and b=d, which seems reasonable, since seemingly one would "equate similar parts" or something like that. However, there is no obvious algebra rule to settle this, and that's why he contacted me. It's an arithmetic/algebra issue for sure, but it is slightly tricky, as it turns out. (a) First of all, as much as we might be tempted to, we're not allowed to just "equate similar parts" in the above expression, as it is possible to have a+b√2 = c+d√2 but NOT have a = c and b=d! So, your task here is to find real number values for a, b, c, and d for which a +b√2 = c+d√2 but it isn't true that a b=d. = c and [Note: yes, this is very different from things we've done previously. But, as it so happens, it will be very similar to things that are coming up very shortly in this course, so it doesn't hurt to get our feet wet now.] [Hint: play with numbers. Try a nice irrational value for one of the unknowns!] (b) Ah, but it does turn out that things behave well for certain types of numbers. So. prove the following statement with a proof by contradiction: If a +b√2=c+d√2 and a, b, c, d are all integers, then actually a = c and b=d! [Hint: setting up the proof by contradiction requires you to simplify ~ (a = c and b = d) with the help of DeMorgan, so first write that carefully. Then notice that there are actually three possibilities (cases) here, when you think about the meaning of the word "or": it might be that ac, b=d; it might be that a = c, b d; finally, it might be that a c, b + d. Find a contradiction in each case!] [Moral of the story; different types of proof techniques combine in unexpected ways!
Expert Answer:
Related Book For
Organizational Behaviour Concepts Controversies Applications
ISBN: 978-0132310314
6th Canadian Edition
Authors: Nancy Langton, Stephen P. Robbins, Timothy A. Judge, Katherine Breward
Posted Date:
Students also viewed these mathematics questions
-
Planning is one of the most important management functions in any business. A front office managers first step in planning should involve determine the departments goals. Planning also includes...
-
The Crazy Eddie fraud may appear smaller and gentler than the massive billion-dollar frauds exposed in recent times, such as Bernie Madoffs Ponzi scheme, frauds in the subprime mortgage market, the...
-
Late Thursday afternoon, Chris Peterson was reflecting on the meeting she would have tomorrow with her boss, Meg Cooke. The purpose of the meeting was to give Meg an update on the status of the...
-
Define price and name the various types of prices described in this chapter.
-
Write down logical representations for the following sentences, suitable for use with Generalized Modus Ponens: a. Horses, cows and pigs arc mammals. b. An offspring of a horse is a horse. c....
-
Define the term 'excess property'. Give an informatory note on the excess free energy of a component in a mixture.
-
The income statement and balance sheet for Clark Industries at March 31, 2010, are presented next: Requirements 1. Calculate the gross profit percentage for Clark Industries for the year. 2. The...
-
You would like to buy an industrial property in Pointe-Claire that has two tenants occupying all of the leasable area. The current owner provides you with the following information. One tenant has...
-
On 1 November 20.18 Mars Traders paid rental to the amount of R25 740 for 12 months. The pre-adjustment trial balance for the year ended 28 February 20.19 reflected an amount for rental expenses of...
-
55 Jason Ready, single, attended the University of San Diego during 2015-2019 under the Army ROTC program. Excluding the school expenses covered by his ROTC scholarship, he incurred additional school...
-
Suggest improvements for the companys web-site and web presence. Read the following discussion: Pandora is the Internets most successful radio service. As of May 2014, it had over 250 million...
-
Appliance maker forecast consulting: You are hired to recommend a forecasting solution to a small-scale home appliance maker. The three managers namely the shop floor, marketing, and finance make an...
-
New Jersey Valve Company manufactured 7,800 units during January of a control valve used by milk processors in its Camden plant. Records indicated the following: Direct labor Direct material...
-
The statement from Jackson County Bank on December 31 showed a balance of $27,541. A comparison of the bank statement with the Cash account revealed the following facts. 1. The bank collected a note...
-
A man is running on a straight road perpendicular to a train track and away from the track at a speed of 11 m/s. The train is moving with a speed of 22 m/s with respect to the track. What is the...
-
Suppose the following information was taken from the 2025 financial statements of FedEx Corporation, a major global transportation/delivery company. (in millions) 2025 2024 Accounts receivable...
-
17. Write a SQL query to display product categories with more than 50 ordered products in one bill (order). (5 points) 18. Write a SQL query to retrieve all employees and their managers. (5 points)...
-
Compare and contrast debt financing and equity financing as ways of starting a new business. Does one have an overall advantage over the other? What situation is more favorable to the use of debt...
-
Apply the rational decision-making model to deciding where your group might eat dinner this evening. How closely were you able to follow the rational model in making this decision?
-
Michael Eisner, former CEO at the Walt Disney Corporation, wanted to stimulate conflict inside his firm. But he wanted to minimize conflict with outside partiesagents, contractors, unions, etcetera....
-
Compare Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal values.
-
An axial flow fan balanced at one speed often exhibits substantial vibrational effects when operated at other speeds, mainly due to (a) primary critical speed effect (b) secondary critical speed...
-
In the case of an involute toothed gear, involute starts from (a) addendum circle (b) dedundum circle (c) pitch circle (d) base circle.
-
In the epicyclic gear train shown in the given Fig. \(33, A\) is fixed. \(A\) has 100 teeth and \(B\) has 20 teeth. If the arm \(C\) makes three revolutions, the number of revolutions made by \(B\)...
Study smarter with the SolutionInn App